Just something to plink with & shoot varmints. But with enough power for social situations if needed.
I'm thinking of a 32 mag or 38/357. Anyone use the 38/357 on coyotes? If so what bullets?
How well will 45 acp or 10mm work on larger varmints?
If you enjoyed reading about "What centerfire handgun for loafing in the great outdoors?" here in TheHighRoad.org archive, you'll LOVE our community. Come join TheHighRoad.org today for the full version!
MacPelto
June 19, 2003, 11:28 AM
Just for loafing...I have my eye on the Ruger Vaquero with interchangeable cylinders in 357/9mm. 3 calibers for one gun, and 9 is cheap to shoot.
mtnbkr
June 19, 2003, 11:57 AM
Definitely a 38/357 in either a K-Frame or L-Frame (or equiv). Mine is a Ruger GP100 with cocobolo grips and Firesights. I carry hot 180gr loads for serious shooting and light 38s for everything else.
Chris
J. Parker
June 19, 2003, 12:42 PM
I like a 357 magnum snubbie. Easy packin', powerful, and reliable. Just for funsies I've shot magnum snubbies out to 100 yards. Believe it or not they can be quite accurate out to that distance.
This summer I'll be packin' a 10mm Glock in the woods.:D
Jim March
June 19, 2003, 02:09 PM
For the price and performance and packin' weight, not much beats a GP100 with a 6" short-shroud barrel.
Depending on load, it can kill anything this side of a Griz, at considerable range.
They turn up used at $350 or less:
http://www.gunsamerica.com/guns/976300562.htm
Here's a full-lug; if you're gonna shoot the really serious loads (158grain @ 1500 or similar power range) the extra weight might be worth it for recoil control:
http://www.gunsamerica.com/guns/976341089.htm
There's no better deal in a general purpose do-it-all handgun.
Single Actions are OK if you're willing to commit to really mastering them.
Al Thompson
June 19, 2003, 02:57 PM
Guess I'm different. My always gun is a Glock 19. I do upgrade to a M629 when piggies are on the menu, I.E., hunting. If I'm hunting, camping or hiking where discression is advised, a G26 hides in a small black pouch on the belt.
Trumpet
June 19, 2003, 03:24 PM
I'd look at a S&W 625. Loading with moonclips is fast. Total versatility of cartridge choice. You can shoot mild 45ACP all the way to blazing 45 auto rim.
Rich
ACP230
June 19, 2003, 06:10 PM
My current choice would probably be my nickel Smith & Wesson M58. Its a nice gun with good power, and the nickel finish should be tougher than the blued finish on my M57 or my Ruger Redhawk .41.
Did I take it the last time I was out in the woods?
No. I took two 1911 types pistols. Besides doing a little shooting, I was also testing a holster.
Penforhire
June 19, 2003, 07:22 PM
I'm assuming you don't need to conceal it so I'd second that L-frame S&W. Probably in 6" (or longer) for easier plinking. Say a stainless 686 so you don't worry about the finish. Plink with 38's and load 357 Mag for more, ah, serious uses.
blades67
June 20, 2003, 12:49 AM
I carry my Glock 20 10mm Auto. More potent than a .357 Magnum and higher capacity to boot.
9x19
June 20, 2003, 12:53 AM
I prefer either one of my 3" .38/.357 wheel guns, or one of my Glock sub-compacts (9mm, or .357Sig) for a "loafing around the woods" gun.
Tommy Gunn
June 20, 2003, 02:55 AM
Check the used gun market for an older Colt revolver chambered in .32-20 WCF.
Although semi obsolete, the .32-20 still enjoys modest popularity with farmers, ranchers, trappers, and pot hunters. It can be reloaded easily and at a moderate cost. In addition, it delivers good killing power on small and medium game at ranges out to 100 yards without destroying all the edible meat.
32-20 (32 Winchester Center Fire) (http://www.reloadbench.com/cartridges/p3220.html)
jem375
June 20, 2003, 11:58 AM
357 mag. with the cheap blazer ammo would be a good plinker and varmint chaser...........the 10MM is too expensive to use as a plinker, although I like the caliber very much, another good one is the 44 mag with a target load..............
MCNETT
June 20, 2003, 12:00 PM
I always take my G20 loaded with 200XTP @ 1250fps and a back up mag of 165GSHP @ 1430fps.
-Mike
Gary H
June 20, 2003, 12:01 PM
S&W 25 in Colt. Accurate at any conceivable distance and a joy to shoot.
Pumpkinheaver
June 21, 2003, 10:41 AM
In my opinion it's hard to beat a ruger single six in .32 Mag.
stevelyn
June 21, 2003, 11:33 AM
A .357 will probably be the most versatle. The choice of launchers is your's.
Edward429451
June 21, 2003, 12:01 PM
Any 357 would be a good choice. But a 44 mag would have some extra versatility over a 357. Load light for plinking / small game, and heavier for nasties. 44 shotshells are much more versatile and efficient than the 357 shotloads, having a bigger payload.
Speedloaders let you carry and load different loadings very well.
FWIW.
Glamdring
June 21, 2003, 10:57 PM
Well, I was thinking something ligher than a 6" L frame :)
If I want to carry something that heavy I carry the 4" 629.
Main reason I was thinking about the 10mm and 45acp is they would be lighter than my 4" 357.
When I said loafing I was thinking sort of an extended camping/varmint trip say a 2-3 day weekend. Either hiking or canoeing, would prefer something light wt because carrying other gear.
sm
June 22, 2003, 02:24 AM
Over the years, just "loafing" I've usually had a 1911[first choce always], or a K frame, many a time just a model 64 3" HB.
But I'm partial to these. Have used others. I"ve just had good luck. "Loafing" in dirty/sandy/farm contry the 1911 more reliable, IME.
Fun "loafing"...Keltec P-11...groundhogs kinda challenging...fun tho' ;)
one gets a real funny look if a groudhog and 9mm meet at 40 yds...aint' no target pc...I do belive in luck...smart thing is to quit while ahead...I did...
10-Ring
June 22, 2003, 02:54 AM
I'd go w/ a 357 magnum DA revolver. For plinking you can bring some inexpensive ammo & for defensive duty, you've can bring a nice hollow point.
WonderNine
June 22, 2003, 03:54 AM
How about a .454 Casull levergun and a .454 Casull revolver? :)
Skunkabilly
June 22, 2003, 04:19 AM
Loafing? Wouldn't you rather bring toilet paper? :p
CB900F
June 22, 2003, 11:04 AM
Glam;
From the tone of your post, it doesn't sound as though bear/cat defense is a consideration. That being the case, the .32 H&R would be a lot more practical for what you are describing, IMHO.
In the loafing/plinking mode, it's a lot less likely to annoy any others in the area. The report isn't nearly as loud. If you are a handloader, any of them can be cheap to shoot, but the .32 just takes less of everything but primers.
My personal choice would be the Ruger SP101 in .32. If that wasn't in the cards, then like most others here, I'd go with a .357/38 revolver. But I'd stay away from the snubbies. Man can they be loud!
900F
Brian Williams
June 22, 2003, 02:08 PM
I would love to have a 4" pencil barrel S&W mod 13 with a round butt.
you could carry
Snake shot loads
38spec single & double round ball loads
38 spec 140 & 148 gr wad cutters
38 spec 115 jhp +p
357 double & triple (using a plastic shot canister) round ball loads
357 158 gr LSWC
357 125 & 158 JHP or JSP
357 180 gr Deer stoppers....
the list could go on & on & on............
a nice 22 lr J frame would be fun also
I want to take my OM single six and Paco Kelly it. rebarrel it with a nice 22lr barrel, put a nice 1x4 scope and rechamber the worst chamber to 22 mag. Cause it is an Old Model you should load and carry only 5 rounds, but when you want a little more umph you can slip in a 22 mag in that empty chamber.
444
June 22, 2003, 07:41 PM
A few years ago, I had the same dilema. I owned a number of handguns, but I wanted an extremly versitile, rugged, powerful handgun to be mine "go-to" woods gun. Something that I could take deer hunting and have it ride in a holster for up to two weeks with rain and snow while living out of a tent. I wanted it to shoot flat, and be able to take down a big game animal if I wanted to.
My choice wa the Ruger GP-100, 4", full lug, stainless. It has served in that role with distinction. It has also become my faviorite .357 revolver. I have no complaints with it. One of the biggest plusses of the GP100 that is seldom mentioned is that it came be taken completely down to the frame EASILY. After being exposed to dirt, and moisture for a week or two, it gives me great piece of mind to KNOW that the lockwork and internals are clean and dry before I put it away.
The problem with most of the guns mentioned are that they are very loud. When I am rambing around in the back country and want to do a little impromptu plinking, I don't want to carry ear plugs, and I don't want to permenently damage my hearing. For that reason, if I was camping, or canoeing or something like that, I would be inclined to carry a .22. Yes, prolonged exposure to a .22 handgun will damage your hearing, but I think the damage would be minimal for the occasional shot. It would also attract less attention from others.
Dr.Rob
June 22, 2003, 09:52 PM
Hiking to me is hiking, hunting is hunting and defense is something else."Impromtu plinking" sounds a bit like shooting at roadsigns of oppurtunity, rather than following good safe handling. IE don't unload a cylinder of ammo at a pop can in the center of a hiking trail.
Now I hope none of us would do such a thing.
If I've a mind to plink I'll find a nice backstop, like a dry creek bed or riverbank to shoot into. And plinking means I drove the jeep up there. Might be shooting anything.
If I'm just walking around minding my own business in the back country you can bet I'll be packing something. These days its likely stainless a .357 snubby loaded heavy. If I'm hunting, up my sidearm to a 44, because 357 is not big game legal where I hunt.
444
June 22, 2003, 10:26 PM
Dr. Rob, I am not sure if that comment was directed at me or not but since I used the phrase impromtu plinking, I will assume it was. Note that I live in a very large state with a population so small that "they" conducted above ground nuclear testing here. My idea of enjoying nature, is getting away from people. I consider any trip into the outdoors marred by seeing a single person. It is not unusual for me to drive off road in areas that are 50 miles from the nearest house. One of my faviorite areas to enjoy the outdoors is the most sparely populated county in the Untied States. Don't make sweeping generalizations about impromptu plinking or about safe gun handling when you know nothing about the circumstances involved. I have never shot a roadsign in my life and if you are talking to me, I strongly resent the comment.
My Model 28 when I get it back.
It will work for general woods carry and also to hunt with if I ever feel the need to.
I would also like to get a .357 snubby.
Dr.Rob
June 23, 2003, 09:43 PM
444 relax, I'm not singling you out, just reminding us all that the 4 rules still apply no matter if you plan on running into anyone else or not.
Stay safe.
If you enjoyed reading about "What centerfire handgun for loafing in the great outdoors?" here in TheHighRoad.org archive, you'll LOVE our community. Come join TheHighRoad.org today for the full version!