[Z_Infidel]

I saw a couple of nice revolvers today at my favorite gun shop and I want to get some opinions on the deals.

The first is a M10-5 priced at $299.99.

The second is a M28-2 5" priced at $329.99.

Both seem to be in excellent condition. I ran "the check" on them and they both passed with flying colors. This was a big help.

If I am correct about the M10, the -5 makes it the same age as me.

Any input or opinions would be helpful, thanks.

[Dave Markowitz]

Unless the Model 10 is mint, in the original box, with all the papers, that price seems high.

That's a decent price for the Model 28, though. I don't see them around much. Fantastic gun. Closing the cylinder feels like a bank vault being shut. :)

[JDSlack]

I don't know where you hail from, but in my area the price on the 10 seems a tad high...but it would be your call. The 28 is about right, but are you sure it is a 5"? I don't think the 28 came in a 5". only 4" and 6". The model 27 came in a 5", and if that's a 27 I think the price is good, I'd buy it. In fact, if it's a 27 and you don't want let me know where it is and I might buy it.

[C.R.Sam]

5" 28 very unusual....but at least 25 were made that way.
Florida Highway Patrol got 25 Nickel 5 inchers in 1959.

Sam

[Brian Williams]

http://www.auctionarms.com/search/displayitem.cfm?ItemNum=4852222

Listing for a Mod 10-5 at 185

[Standing Wolf]

I'd snap up the model 28-2 at that price in half a heart beat.

[Z_Infidel]

Thanks for the replies. I'm sure I was wrong about the M28, it must be a 6" bbl. They might be willing to come down on the price, especially if I offer to buy both guns. Either way, your feedback is very helpful.

Even though the M10 may be overpriced, I was very impressed with the gun. It is about as nice as the one in that auction that was linked, but it has a longer barrel (I noticed the reserve has not been met on that sale, BTW). This was the first time I have examined one up close, and it just seems the workmanship really shows through. Somehow, it just feels "right" when you hold it. All the parts have a nice fit, the edges are nicely formed, it's kinda hard to describe (although I'm sure many of you already know). I became somewhat enamored with it, so hopefully they'll come down a bit on the price. I guess I was wrong about its age, too. I had thought the 10-5 was only made in 1962 and the 10-6 was adopted in 1963. But the auction lists the age of that gun to 1967. I have a lot to learn.

I really like the M28 too. I already own a 586-1, and this would be a good compliment. I like the weight of the big N frame, and it is very solid.

Oh, and another question about the M10: How fragile is the ejector rod on these guns? All of my other revolvers have ejector shrouds, and that's the only thing I can't get used to on this gun. Thanks again.

[Tamara]

Five years ago, Model 28's were selling at 1/2 to 3/4 the price of a comparable Model 27. As the supply of choice Model 27's has dwindled, Model 28 prices have crept inexorably upward. $300ish seems to be the going tarriff for a cherry Highway Patrolman these days...

[Ala Dan]

Greeting's All-

I think it is wise to try to bargain for both weapons!:D
If they pass the Jim March revolver quick check tip's, I'd
make an offer of $500 for the pair! You might not get 'em
but at least you would be in the ball park.:rolleyes: :uhoh:

Best Wishes,
Ala Dan, N.R.A. Life Member

[Frenchy]

The Model 10 price does seem high, but what the heck...I'm asking the same amount for my 1953 pre-10 on GB!! :D

[4v50 Gary]

What Ala Dan says. $500 takes all. :D

[C.R.Sam]

I like Ala Dan's style.
His suggestion is great in my book.

Sam....patience and carry green.

[Z_Infidel]

Crap! I went back today to make an offer on the M28 and it had sold over the weekend. Aaarrgghhh! Oh well, snooze ya lose I guess...

[FPrice]

"Crap! I went back today to make an offer on the M28 and it had sold over the weekend."

Welcome to the club. I am sure that most of us have done the same thing from time to time. This is one of the best reasons to study older guns on a regular basis and have a good idea of what you are looking at. It helps cut down the decision time and keep you from losing such great bargains.