spyderco or benchmade


PDA






desert gator
April 1, 2009, 05:06 PM
I am looking to get a new folding carry knife, just a three inch blade. Which out of these two companies would you guys recommend?

If you enjoyed reading about "spyderco or benchmade" here in TheHighRoad.org archive, you'll LOVE our community. Come join TheHighRoad.org today for the full version!
Yossi
April 1, 2009, 05:14 PM
I can tell you that my Benchmade Osborne with D2 steel is a great pocket knife. It's well made, thin and opens instantly with either hand without using a spring. I really like it a lot.

10-Ring
April 1, 2009, 06:27 PM
I have a couple from both Spyderco & Benchmade. I prefer the Benchmades

SimpleIsGood229
April 1, 2009, 06:54 PM
There is no answer to this question. Although I'm a Spydernut, I have to just tell you to go out and handle as many different ones as you can. That's really the only way to find out what will work for you.

eldiabloe1
April 1, 2009, 07:29 PM
I couldn't make up my mind so I have them both. I have a Spyderco Polywog for dress and a Benchmade Osborne 950 for weekends. I love the Axis lock but the roller lock on the Polywog is stout.

hso
April 1, 2009, 10:08 PM
You're going to get a lot more variety in that blade length from Spyderco. They've made a conscious effort to provide knives in the 3" and under range.

But, consider that the two opening systems are very different and you may find that one or the other is just that much more convenient for you that the choice is simple.

So, handle items from both companies and decide for yourself.

Javelin
April 1, 2009, 10:14 PM
Both are great companys. I do however feel that Benchmade is higher quality. Probably just marketing.

:)

bikerdoc
April 1, 2009, 10:22 PM
have both - due to my current condition I find the Spyderco Native and Endura fit my needs better at this time

TimboKhan
April 1, 2009, 11:03 PM
I have both, but my Griptilian is the 550 model with the hole, so in that regard it's not a whole lot different.

I am a Spyderco fan, but my limited experience with the Grip has taught me that Benchmade makes a darn good knife. Still, in the end, I find that my Endura rides in my pocket more often than anything else does, and I still think that the Native is about the best buy around.

MutinousDoug
April 1, 2009, 11:48 PM
I would not recommend a Spyderco knife to anyone who knows how to sharpen their own knife. That being said, they come from the factory adequately sharp and are a good deal for those who don't know how to do this and they have a sharpening policy to fix the knives you send back to them. They are OK for 90% of what most people put their knives through.
There are better knives at that price point if you are willing to put some effort into it.

alaskanativeson
April 2, 2009, 03:18 AM
I've retired a LOT of excellent knives to carry my Benchmade Doug Ritter Mini-Griptilian. The Axis lock is what did it for me. It's so smooth it's almost unbelievable. I have several Spydercos I like including a Native, a Terzoula custom, and a Centofante 3. All are now sitting in a drawer. The Benchmade even has my small Sebenza collecting dust.

I can't say there's anything wrong with the Spydercos. They are really good knives, and Sal (the owner) is a quality gentleman. The smooth quality of the Benchmade has won me over, though.

BCCL
April 2, 2009, 09:08 AM
I've got some from both companies, but my Benchmades far outnumber my Spydercos.

Omaha-BeenGlockin
April 2, 2009, 10:08 AM
Benchmade and the Axis lock pretty much blow everything else away.

Haven't even looked at another Spyderco since I got my first Benchmade about 3 years ago---and this is coming from a guy who carried an Endura daily for nearly 10 years.

JShirley
April 2, 2009, 10:08 AM
I've had one Benchmade.

I'm not sure how many Spydercos I've had. Twenty, maybe?

John

auschip
April 2, 2009, 10:44 AM
Just like anything else it comes down to individual preference. I recently traded my only folding Spyderco, because the ergonomics weren't right for me. They might be a good fit for you though.

Just to muddy the waters even further, you might also look at Emerson knives. They have just about replaced my Benchmades for EDC.

Limeyfellow
April 2, 2009, 01:39 PM
Benchmade is probably the better quality, but you are going to pay for it. You can usually get a nib Spyderco from Ebay or a store sale for far cheaper. The Benchmade Mini Griptilian will do you just fine, and has a great locking mechanism, however, I still prefer the design of the Spyderco Delica and Enduras. I just like the bigger thumb ramp and jimping it gives me. Either does really well.

CWL
April 2, 2009, 02:32 PM
Both companies have consistently high ratings by users and collectors.

Get the one you like best or fit your price point.

I find that Benchmade makes some "dressier" knives more suitable for the office place, while Spyderco has more rugged designs using FRN and other composites.

Vermonter
April 2, 2009, 03:27 PM
After having the lockback spring fail in my Spyderco Persian I just can't trust them 100% anymore. Also the Spydie hole is a bit hard to operate with gloves on. I'm currently carrying a cheap Buck Nobleman. It's a framelock with a thumb stud. $18 shipped from Ebay. Nice quality for twice that money. When finances get a bit better I'd like to try a Benchmade or an Emerson.

76shuvlinoff
April 4, 2009, 09:45 AM
Not to hijack, but due to this thread I just ordered my first benchmade, the mini griptilian in a smooth edge satin finished blade.

Thanks! .. I think.. ;)

alaskanativeson
April 5, 2009, 02:46 AM
Good choice. I now have 4 mini-grips. Two with 154CM blades (one with thumb stud, one with thumbhole) a D2 from Cabelas, and the S30V Doug Ritter version. All have plain edged blades, the Cabelas and Ritter have black blades, the 154CM have satin blades. All are great knives.

76shuvlinoff
April 5, 2009, 09:10 AM
This one (pardue?) is listed as 154cm blade.
I am no metallurgist, what this this mean in terms of sharpening and holding an edge? I was looking at so many of them on-line over the last few days that were D2 or SV30 (tool steel?). I honestly missed this detail when I made the purchase, my bad.

76shuvlinoff
April 5, 2009, 09:18 AM
Found this in a Google search of 154cm knife blades

154CM knife steel: This is a high carbon steel with 1.05% carbon. It also contains about 14% chromium. Many people consider 154CM knife steel to be “super steel”, if you find the older stock. 154CM is not a standard grade designation, rather a manufacturers trade name. 154CM steel is similar to 440 C. 154CM steel has fair corrosion resistance and a very good edge holding ability, especially on knives for heavy cutting.

Jeff
April 5, 2009, 01:57 PM
I like Spyderco better. I have a BM 710-- with the original M2 blade. It's a nice knife, but I have abandoned it since I acquired my Police w CF handle about 6 yrs ago. Spyderco has far more designs and purposes. Their knives are more utilitarian. Plus Benchmade has all those ugly knives with the flame shaped G2 inserts and other sophomoric features.

I'm certainly not sold on BM's quality control being any better than Spyderco's. Spyderco's is superb. I have purchased many of their blades, having given away most of them as gifts. The 710 I own has some fit and finish issues. There is also considerable blade play; if I tighten it up then it becomes too difficult to open. To be fair, I've heard many times BM has improved their quality control considerably.

In summary, Spyderco, IMO, just makes more practical utilitarian knives with a ton of character and superb quality control, especially on their lockbacks, which I love. BM makes a fine knife,too, with their great Axis lock. (Don't care about liner locks on either brand.)

I would like to see BM go back to their roots and make more down to earth, practical, Emersonian designs, while keeping with their improved QC standards.

CZ.22
April 5, 2009, 02:01 PM
Kershaw :)
Seriously, any one of those will serve you well.

MadMercS55
April 5, 2009, 05:16 PM
I grew up with Benchmades and generally prefer them over most anything else. I have owned alot of Spyderco pieces over the years too, and some were nicer than others, but I find more consistant quality from Benchmade as a whole. I've had more Spydercos with blade play, lockup issues and other little things than BM. But both companies have had their ups and downs in QC over the years. These days I'd imagine you'd be well served by either one.

hignhappy00
April 9, 2009, 02:22 AM
They are both good. but i prefer Benchmades. I love mine:
Benchmade Osborne Rift Black/Gray G10 Handle Plain (http://www.xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx.com/ad_redirect.php?url=http%3A//www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/external-search%3Fmode%3Dblended%26tag%3Ddealstudio0a-20%26keyword%3DB001DBLPJK&ru=283)

bikerdoc
April 9, 2009, 06:38 AM
I would not recommend a Spyderco knife to anyone who knows how to sharpen their own knife.

Im puzzed by this? Are you talking about the VG-10 and S30V steels?
Ya, the are are a more difficult to sharpen because they are hard and have a high Vanadiun content. But anyone with good basic freehand skills just has to spend a little more time and care.

rshackleford
April 9, 2009, 07:45 AM
i love my spyderco's. i have also gone cheap and gotten a couple of byrds. i lose my knife a lot and that's why i went to byrd. i can easily open and close both knives with one hand. i also like how thin they are. they almost disappear in my pocket (like i said sometimes they actually do disappear). i go with the plain blades because i can't sharpen a serrated.

Hawk
April 15, 2009, 07:16 PM
For some reason the Spyderco Meerkat keeps turning up in my pocket. It's small, non-threatening and the gimmick factor is well over the top.

It's oddly addictive especially given the low price point. And the blade is only 2".

BamaBob
April 15, 2009, 07:21 PM
Ive had both and liked the benchmade more. Spyderco is typicaly lighter if that matters.

jahwarrior
April 15, 2009, 07:59 PM
dude, get a Dark Ops...





just kidding.



i'v owned only 3 Benchmades, and i gave two of them away to friends. there's no doubt they're great knives, but they just weren't for me. i was never a fan of Spydies, until i carried and used one. now i'm hooked.

knives are a personal preference deal. it's hard to convince someone why they should try a certain brand, other than providing basic facts about blade design, steel, and price. everything else is pretty subjective, i think. i know guys who swear by Cold Steel, and others who won't carry anything other than a Microtech (i wish i had one, though).

just go to a shop that has different knives, and pick them up, and tell us what you decide on.

snorky18
April 21, 2009, 11:37 AM
I've never owned a Benchmade, but I have a spyderco that I've been using/abusing for 12+ years, still extremely sharp, and still functions as new.

It started out life as a Endura, but stupid me in my youth broke the tip off trying to pry something WAY to big, so I ground the blade to where it looks just like a rescue now.

So I don't see a reason to pay more for anything else if what I have does the job very well, unless it's just personal preference.

If you enjoyed reading about "spyderco or benchmade" here in TheHighRoad.org archive, you'll LOVE our community. Come join TheHighRoad.org today for the full version!