CorrosionX


PDA






Quickloader
October 14, 2003, 06:34 AM
How are your experiences using CorrosionX as a lubricant?

How does it perform compared to other lubricants regarding longevity, cold- and warm-weather performance etc.?

Quickloader

If you enjoyed reading about "CorrosionX" here in TheHighRoad.org archive, you'll LOVE our community. Come join TheHighRoad.org today for the full version!
Al Thompson
October 14, 2003, 08:03 AM
Works very well as a rust cure/preventative. I'm leery of using it as a lube - that wasn't what it was designed for...

Sort of expensive for that too. :)

Quickloader
October 14, 2003, 08:19 AM
Thanks Al

Regarding the infos given on the CorrosionX site

www.corrosionx.com

they market the product as lubricant to. :)

Quickloader

CMcDermott
October 16, 2003, 12:54 AM
I used it on my Bullseye guns, a Ruger MkII and a Kimber Polymer Gold Match. It's really too thin and is blown off too easily; the VERY thin coating that is left is easily gunked up. I think that it works better as a cleaner/preservative than as a lubricant. I still use it to clean my guns, letting a fouled barrel soak for a day or two makes it much easier to get clean; whether it's lead, copper or just powder residue.

Al Thompson
October 16, 2003, 08:59 PM
Well, 3in1 oil advertises that it's OK for guns too. :) I tend to want to stay with stuff designed strictly for guns.. Breakfree, Tetra, Eezox, etc., etc...

AUTIGER04
October 16, 2003, 10:03 PM
Hey I use 3 in 1 oil.:D

Quickloader
October 17, 2003, 03:17 AM
Thanks for the input!

Al,
I see your point, even WD40 claims to be a gun lube... ;)

CMcDermott,
which lube(s) do you prefer?

CorrosionX recommend their SpeedX for a high end gun lubricant, in addition to the "regular" resp. "For Guns"- formula, FWIW.

For lubrication and corrosion protection esp., how compares CorrosionX to FP-10, any experiences?

Quickloader

Al Thompson
October 17, 2003, 09:03 AM
Hey Quick, my bad - welcome to THR! I didn't catch the new member status. :)

IMHO, your asking a pretty tough question. To get a real answer, one would have to test a couple guns very throughly and extensivly for differences to show them selves. Frankly, it would take a bunch of rounds to get enough wear to make measuring possible. Second, you'd need at least one gun (same brand) for each lube. That would be pricy. :)

That's another reason I use stuff designed for guns, not all purpose hydrocarbons. :D

Quickloader
October 17, 2003, 04:14 PM
Hey Al,
You’re most welcome, thanks!

You did figure this out by my peculiar inquiry, I suppose? :D
But in fact you got me there, wouldn't mind to have some of the nicer guns in pairs for testing lubes, do you know a sponsor? :D

Being kind of a lube geek, like most here I suppose, I'm constantly interested in this topic, albeit I have to admit that experimenting with different lubes can have its downsides, too.
In this context I think one isn't doing anything wrong sticking with something that works for him, like 3in1 Oil for AUTIGER04 :)

Anyway, I just ordered some FP-10 and CorrosionX, so let's see!

Quickloader

sm
October 17, 2003, 04:37 PM
I gotta agree with Al.

Now I did some T&E at one time, 20/20 hindsight I wish I hadn't.I could have bought a gun, holsters, ammo...etc. I mean the gun specified stuff I'd always used for close to 40 years never failed I think it depends one's enviroment , me for instance I'm not around salt water...I do have to be concerned with humidity in summer. Winters can be cold and wet. RIG worked since a pup.

Heck I'll tell you how much I worry , I gave all of my lubes and solvents away I had won, collected and had been given to me. Umm, oops, I didn't leave myself any. I ordered a 1/2 gallon and a buddy took it for a project. I ran by my gunsmiths, "hey I'm stealing this bit of lube and the half bottle of solvent". That's all I have at the moment. I did find the small tub of RIG Grease ...been using it since I was a wee brat.

Al Thompson
October 17, 2003, 05:17 PM
You did figure this out by my peculiar inquiry, I suppose?

:D - nope. Look under your name on the left side of the screen - it tells how many posts you have.

Quickloader
October 17, 2003, 05:38 PM
Al,
that's the other way to notice it :p

re1973,
I basically agree with you and Al, but once in a while I get bitten by the vampire and try something new, but as stated above, I had the incident's I wish I hadn't!

Thanks for your statements, guys! :)

CMcDermott
October 17, 2003, 10:03 PM
Quickloader

Right now I am using up a bottle of good old RemOil, it still works well. In the future I plan on trying Militec-1 (http://www.militec-1.com/), supposed to be a "dry-lube" that doesn't collect dust or powder residue and gunk up the gun. Seems to be working in the middle East for the troops stationed there.

Quickloader
October 18, 2003, 02:14 AM
CMcDermott

I just stopped using Militec-1.

It worked fine for me as a lubricant on moving parts and on sear contacts it did an exceptional job in some guns; after using it a while there was indeed some reduction in barrel fouling noticeable; I would never use it anymore for corrosion protection, especially not in an environment where this would be a concern.

After considering the pros and cons I found about the product, I don’ trust the manufacturer’s claims any longer; I too would stay away from the heat-applying procedure, in my opinion it bears more dangers than it would do any good.

Quickloader

George Hill
April 30, 2004, 09:17 PM
I just got a bottle of CorrosionX. As a lube, it seems to be just fine. Pretty slick in my opinion. In fact, this stuff seems to be slicker than Militec1 (oil and grease) and many other lubes. A 4 ounce bottle is pretty big, and you use so little of it, I suspect this stuff should last a long time.
Works great as a cleaner - tested that out today.
Works great as a lube - tested that out already today.
According to product literature, it is evidently awesome at preventing corrosion too...
As far as gumming up... I didn't get any of that today and I was trying. Testing done in windy dusty conditions that pretty much gum up everything.
It smells different. It feels different.

I like it.

Dave Markowitz
April 30, 2004, 09:52 PM
While I have no experience with CorrosionX let me weigh in on two other products mentioned in this thread.

First, FP-10. I've used this for awhile and it's an outstanding lubricant, a decent cleaner, and from what I've read, works well to prevent corrosion. It's a better cleaner than BreakFree CLP, IME, but I still prefer Hoppe's for cleaning. I don't live in an especially humid area so I've never really had rust problems on my guns, no matter what I coat them with. I just ordered another bottle of FP-10 from Midway.

I got a free sample of Militec-1 oil and grease. Both are very good lubes. They are not intended as corrosion protection AFAIK, and the oil has performed poorly in such a role in one or two tests reports I've read. Interesting note, though: Benchmade Knives specifically recommends Militec-1 oil to lubricate their folding knives. It works really well in this role, since after it dries out it doesn't act like a magnet for pocket lint.

I look forward to seeing a detailed review of CorrosionX.

M2 Carbine
May 1, 2004, 12:12 AM
For what it's worth Petroleum Helicopters uses CX on the helicopters flying in the Gulf of Mexico. ( they would buy something else if there was anything that worked better )
That salt air is hard on machinery.

As far as a gun lube it seems to work OK.

The only thing that worries me about it is the possibility of it killing a primer because it seems to penetrate so well.
I never had it happen but I'm careful to keep it away from the back of the loaded round.

If you enjoyed reading about "CorrosionX" here in TheHighRoad.org archive, you'll LOVE our community. Come join TheHighRoad.org today for the full version!