[Brad5192]

I would like to know what you all think.

[wvshooter]

Now that is a delicious question. I'm assuming you have one or more cc guns already. I have some revolvers but I've never used one for cc. I do think they are totally acceptable for self defense and this is just one man's opinion but I think a revolver has more intrinsic beauty than any semi auto. Wait a minute. I forgot about those beautiful 1911's.

[MCgunner]

Autos are generally easier to tote and carry reloads for, but I do like revolvers. I have both and alternate carry. My primary carry auto is a DAO which keeps the manual of arms similar, just draw and squeeze.

This week I've been carrying the little .38. Last week it was the 9. Next week will depend on my mood, I guess. :D

[oneounceload]

Gotta get the popcorn ready for this.... :D

Folks who prefer revolvers are generally talking about a small j-frame or similar that fits in a pocket....not all, just most

semi fans will tout the extra capacity and somewhat "slim, flat" lines

One thing to consider - how many flat, box-like contours do you have on your body versus rounded shapes and curves? Hiding a revolver can sometimes be easier from that standpoint.

Ma ny folks will also alternate between several guns and both styles....

[kludge]

Yes, a revolver or semi-auto would be best for ccw. :uhoh:

.

You will never settle this question here. Try a few and get one you like.

1) Fit
2) Ease of use
3) Quality and reliability
4) Practice

[MCgunner]

Yeah, I never figured out the vitriol over this subject. Some guys are REAL adamant about their choice of platform, though, and it ain't just the 1911 fanatics. I find myself arguing both sides on these threads. But, then, I just like to argue. :D

[jad0110]

Didn't we just do one of these like, last week?

Seriously though, one should carry what works best for them. It ain't about revolver or auto. It's just that simple. Granted, figuring out what works best can be time consuming, but also fun and expensive - an excellent way to build your own mini-arsenal and overtake your sock/underwear drawer with holsters! :evil:

For me, I like J Frames for pocket carry. For IWB, my 1911 is very comfortable to carry since it is so slim, but I prefer carrying the slightly less comfortable S&W Model 15 (either a 2" or a 4") because I shoot them better than anything else.

YMMV.

[CoRoMo]

Both... if you can.

I primarily carry a P11 everyday/everywhere. I'd like to add a small revolver as backup, but I haven't gotten around to it yet. I will always prefer the auto as the primary, simply due to capacity.

[OurSafeHome.net]

Depends on what I am wearing...

Sometimes just a J frame.
Sometimes just the 1911.

When going to Miami, both!

[gunlaw]

use what you will carry everyday. a large frame revolver or a large frame semi auto gets tiresome. a small,convienient or light weight sidearem of eithertype is more likley to be with you when you may need it. it is very easy to get complaciant and leave the roscoe at home when going out for a minor errand in a "the good hood". just make sure that it is of sufficient caliber and power and always have a good exit strategy

[MedWheeler]

Yes.

[QUICK_DRAW_McGRAW]

carry both, just depends on what i feel like carrying that day.

[wnycollector]

I am comfortable carrying either platform. I find that my J frame revolver ends up IWB most off the time when its warm. It the winter/colder months my service sized pistols (SIG P220, CZ40B or P226) see more belt time. When I do anything in the "great out of doors" (hike, camp, canoe, or fish) a Ruger Security six snub is ALWAYS on my side.

My primary carry auto is a DAO which keeps the manual of arms similar, just draw and squeeze.


All of my pistols are DA/SA so the same as my DA revolvers. I think this is real important if you switch up your CCW.

[Mad Magyar]

The only time I strap on a revolver is in dead-winter with a shoulder rig. Otherwise, I'm just not very good with the dreaded "cylinder bulge". :eek:

[Madcap_Magician]

Say Brad, I need a reply to your trade offer... check your PMs. It's going to a dealer Monday otherwise.

[TheProf]

Carry both. Use a j-frame as your primary. (For 99.999% reliability and guaranteed "bang" per trigger pull, its hard to beat a revolver. It may give you "first shot" advantage. You can fire from a coat pocket, you can fire at contact range, and the weapon will be ok.)

Use a semi-auto for back-up. Carry multiple magazines for your semi-auto.

[weisse52]

YES, Sometimes a 1911, sometimes a J frame, sometimes both.


Americans talk .45, shoot 9mm, and carry .38.........


Carry what works for you!

[Pistol Toter]

:rolleyes:Depends on where's I'm a going and what I perceive maybe needed. Primary is an SP101 with a reload but if I think I might need the extra firepower; :what: I carry a Glock 21 with two reloads. That's a bunch a shooten, there'd be brass everywheres. :)

[iblong]

Hard to beat the concealability of a J frame for normal every day carry,I would prefer to carry my 1911 or even my M&P but I cant allways pull that off durring my normall work /bussiness day.Weekends I can and even then my airweight is allways with me.
So J frame 100% of the time and autos some days.Mabe not the best choice but a pretty good one.At least Im never unarmed and I do mean never.
Bob.

[HoosierQ]

I alternate my CCW from a S&W 642 (revolver) and a S&W M&P 9c (semi). 642 for "toss it in the coat pocket" carry and the M&P for holstered IWB carry.

[sidheshooter]

I think CoRoMo was the first to say "both"... that's a winner idea, if you're serious (or need to be serious) about daily carry.

If you're a "hedge your bets" dilettante like me, a 3" J-frame will do nicely for EDC.

Of course, so will a Kahr PM9...

Glad to be of help in this decision!
:D

[searcher451]

There's no right answer here; you have to make the call yourself, based on which gun feels the most comfortable in your hand and best fits your eye. You want a gun that will be 100% reliable 100% of the time, and that has to factor into your decision as well. I've carried a Walther PPK/S for years. It's the right gun for me, but it may not be the right gun for you. That's a call that, ultimately, that only you can make.

[c919]

Niether.... Both..... Mateba.

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/7/75/MatebaAutoRevolver6in.jpg

[sohcgt2]

Everytime I see one of these posts I get excited thinking someone is offering to buy me a new gun. What are you most comfortable handling Brad?

[verdun59]

weisse52,
The "Americans talk .45, shoot 9mm and carry .38" is the most accurate thing I've read today. However it might be argued that the .38 is really .380.
Either way you are on the money ..........

[Doug S]

Glock 26 is my favorite CCW handgun, and the one I would want most if I ever had to use my CCW. That said, my S&W 642 feels very nice in my pocket, and lately it's the one I've been carrying the most.

The benefit of an autoloader IMO is ammo capacity, and fast reloads. If I had to choose between the two I mentioned, I'd go with the Glock for the reasons mentioned above, plus it is much easier to shoot quickly and accurately than the lightweight snub.

[texas bulldog]

i'm with kludge:
Yes, a revolver or semi-auto would be best for ccw.

i don't think either is "best". it's about which one is the best system for you. that includes not just the platform, but the caliber, capacity, ergonomics, carry method, etc. what do you shoot well that you can carry consistently? that's what's "best".