Help me decide


PDA






Stuohn
August 23, 2009, 10:21 PM
So I found out about 5 days ago I will be getting some money at the end of September and have a budget of about $2000 just for handguns (this does not include ammo but, does include extra mags).

As of now I own No handguns but, have already owned a G17, G19, G36, PX4 (9mm & 45).

Now I'm mainly looking for .40 and 38/357. Please no 45 suggestions.

Now here is what I am leaning toward:

1).Springfield EMP .40 + Sp101 3in + Beretta px4 .40

2).Sig p226 Stainless Elite .40 + Sp101 3in+ G23

Any other suggestions?

If you enjoyed reading about "Help me decide" here in TheHighRoad.org archive, you'll LOVE our community. Come join TheHighRoad.org today for the full version!
cchris
August 24, 2009, 01:39 AM
If you're considering carry, the Sig P229 is a good option. I like the .40 for the interchangeability (is that a word?) between the .40 and .357 SIG.

Oro
August 24, 2009, 02:39 AM
I think you have a nice .40 picked out. I have had two .40s, one in a 1911 platform and never loved that. I enjoyed my .40 Glock more. For .40, I'd choose a different platform than 1911or Glock (and that's saying a lot - I love 1911s and do not love, but deeply respect, Glocks). I think a Sig might be a great choice.

As to .38/.357, I have some ideas. I love that cartridge/platform as much as I love 1911s; I think I have about seven or eight of each at the moment. If I could own only ONE .38/.357, it would be one of these (average price for excellent example in quotes):

1) 4" S&W 686, -4 or earlier (1980 to 1996 models). ($450)
2) 3.5" S&W 27 or pre-27, 1948 to 1980 models. ($750)
3) 2.5" S&W 19, any vintage up to 1997,l (for carry) ($500)

I have had Rugers, many other S&Ws, and among about 10 or 12 other models or variations; those models those are the ones that just really speak to me and will never leave the "quiver," so to speak.

If you are happy with a .38 only, I'd recommend a S&W 15/67, 10, or, best of the bunch, a pre-1947 "Military & Police" model or US .38 Special "Victory" model. These can be had for $300 or so. Out of a large body of experience, by far the most inherently accurate gun I have is a 1942 U.S. .38 Special "Victory" model that almost always does one-hole groups. It still has it's WWII Parkerized finish, skimpy grips, fixed sights, and it's still the most accurate handgun I've ever run across - nothing barred. For $300, it will out-shoot guns five and six times the price.

There are many good .38s and .357s. These are just some ideas.

If you enjoyed reading about "Help me decide" here in TheHighRoad.org archive, you'll LOVE our community. Come join TheHighRoad.org today for the full version!