[Hypnogator]

Right now on CBS's "60 Minutes" -- the story of Patrick Miller in the Jessica Lynch ambush/rescue story.

In the first couple of minutes they point out how the military lied when portraying Jessica Lynch as the heroine of this incident.

Great stuff!

[444]

Be sure and give us a summary of what was said. I can't get regular network TV. I have an older Direct TV system without the local channels. I saw it advertised, but I can't get it.:(

[Hypnogator]

OK, 444

Salient points: Patrick Miller was in a vehicle following the one in which Jessica Lynch was riding. Her vehicle was hit, and they all began taking fire. Miller's vehicle became disabled, so he ran towards an Iraqui dump truck, to see if he could start it and use it to extract his comrades. On the way, he spotted Iraquis setting up a mortar position. Realizing his comrades would be wiped out if they got mortars into action, he opened fire when one of them started to drop a round into the tube. Although he didn't qualify with his weapon previously, he hit the Iraqui with his first shot. Good thing -- his weapon jammed. He had to use the bolt assist to chamber each round from then on. He continued to fire until he was overrun and captured.

Original stories of Jessica Lynch's heroism (untrue, she was injured and under her vehicle) were based on intercepts of Iraqui communications describing a "heroic blonde American who shot many Iraquis before being shot and stabbed to death." The best guess was that they were referring to a blonde male SP4 who died fighting off Iraquis as described. (I didn't get his name -- sorry.)

Miller's commander put him in for a Silver Star, which we was awarded. Again, original reports attributed his actions to an "unknown American soldier who was killed during the ambush." He joked with his comrades in the Ft Carson motor pool that he wasn't going to work anymore because he was dead -- the newspaper said so.

Very good piece. 60 Minutes isn't one of my favorite shows, but they seem to have gotten it right, this time. PFC Miller doesn't consider himself a hero. I do, and everyone else who knows the story (including everyone who watched 60 Minutes tonight) should.

[jimpeel]

http://www.thehighroad.org/showthread.php?s=&threadid=42598

What ever happened to the thing about doing something for this guy?

[444]

Right, I had heard the story several times before. I wanted to see if 60 Minutes told the same story and to see how 60 Minutes treated the story.
It sounds like they gave the story the justice it deserved.

[w4rma]

Private First Class Patrick Miller is, IMHO, a true American hero. Both Miller and Private First Class Jessica Lynch are both honorable and brave Americans. I have absolutely nothing but respect for Miller and Lynch. The way that the Bush misadministration has mistreated them and others like them who are still in Iraq fighting for America is, IMHO, nothing short of dishonorable and is disrespectful. These heros deserve much better.

Jessica Lynch Says Military Manipulated Her Story
…
PALESTINE, W. Va. -- Former prisoner of war Jessica Lynch has accused the military of using her capture and dramatic nighttime rescue to sway public support for the war in Iraq.Lynch said she's bothered by the military's portrayal of her ordeal in Iraq. She said the U.S. military manipulated the story of her dramatic rescue -- and shouldn't have filmed it in the first place.
…
The 20-year-old private told ABC's Diane Sawyer in a "Primetime" interview to air Tuesday that there was no reason for her rescue from an Iraqi hospital to be filmed.

In an excerpt reported Friday in the New York Daily News, Lynch said, "They used me as a way to symbolize all this stuff. It's wrong."
…
http://www.theomahachannel.com/news/2619087/detail.html

Lynch criticizes military portrayal
http://www.usatoday.com/news/nation/2003-11-07-lynch-laments_x.htm

Jessica Lynch Criticizes U.S. Accounts of Her Ordeal

In her first public statements since her rescue in Iraq, Jessica Lynch criticized the military for exaggerating accounts of her rescue and re-casting her ordeal as a patriotic fable.

Asked by the ABC News anchor Diane Sawyer if the military's portrayal of the rescue bothered her, Ms. Lynch said: "Yeah, it does. It does that they used me as a way to symbolize all this stuff. Yeah, it's wrong," according to a partial transcript of the interview to be broadcast on Tuesday.
…
http://www.nytimes.com/2003/11/07/national/07LYNC.html

Corps Voters
…
Discontented enlisted men and women have a separate set of provocations...The war in Iraq is already brutal enough day-to-day: Soldiers spend their days in hundred-plus degree heat, being shot at, peering anxiously into the distance, trying to pick out anyone likely to drive through a barricade with a car stuffed with explosives or whip a rifle out from under his robes and start shooting. They are facing an enemy who is not easily identifiable; when they are too aggressive, they are criticized by the press, and when they are not aggressive enough, they are reprimanded by their superiors, if they don't end up dead. … "They feel overused, and under-appreciated, particularly in the enlisted ranks," Wilson said. Christopher Parker, a former Army captain and a political scientist at the University of California-Santa Barbara, put it to me more bluntly: "What we're seeing now is almost unprecedented, this widespread sense among people in the military that they're being jacked around."

… "There's a sense from everyone I talk to, even down at the unit level, that whoever planned this war simply had no idea what we were getting into," a retired Army captain told me.

Troops have been charged a dollar a minute to call home, newspapers have reported, and soldiers have to buy calling cards from Iraqi kiosks. Tens of thousands of troops have been sent to Iraq with flak jackets from the Vietnam era which, unlike the modern Kevlar, can't stop rounds from the Kalashnikov rifles typically fired by the Iraqi enemy. The Pentagon, looking to trim costs last spring, floated a plan to eliminate the pay benefits soldiers got for serving in so-called "hostile areas"; after a loud outcry from the ranks, they killed the plan. Some injured reservists were billed for food they were served while in the hospital. And veterans' groups are up in arms over the concurrent receipt issue, a military regulation which mandates that no retired soldier receiving his pension from the Department of Defense can also qualify for disability. As veterans' groups have pointed out, retired soldiers (who have more legitimate per capita disability claims than any other group of federal workers) are the only group of employees in the civil service who are barred from drawing simultaneous pensions and disability payments. …
…
… There was great skepticism among many officers that Iraq was the right "next target" in the war on terrorism, and an emerging doubt that Rumsfeld and his lieutenants really knew what they were doing. …

… "What I've seen throughout the officer corps is a real pendulum swing over the last three or four months, from being pro-Bush to anti-Bush," Vandergriff said … Retired Gen. Anthony Zinni … last month called the administration's policy a "brain fart." …
http://www.washingtonmonthly.com/features/2003/0311.wallace-wells.html

[jimpeel]

Miller is a hero; Lynch is an ungrateful Twit.