[nyc71]

I'm looking into a single action Ruger in 45lc, which one is a better choice between the Ruger Blackhawk & the Vaquero?
Thanks in advance.

[bergmen]

I'm looking into a single action Ruger in 45lc, which one is a better choice between the Ruger Blackhawk & the Vaquero?
Thanks in advance.

Vaqueros have fixed sights while the Blackhawks (and Bisleys) have adjustable. I always prefer adjustable sights for revolvers unless they are snubby defensive concealed carry weapons.

I have had Blackhawks (both my sons have .45 Colt blackhawks) and I have a .45 Colt Bisley with rosewood grips:

http://inlinethumb32.webshots.com/47519/2628941370053667879S600x600Q85.jpg

Dan

[CTS1911]

Blackhawk

[Doubting Thomas]

Have both; the Convertible Blackhawk is definitely more practical as a field gun--and a bit lighter. I bought the SS NM Vaq because it was purty. Adjustable sights are awfully useful, and there's not much downside to them.

If the NM Flattop, now a limited production Lipsey's item, becomes a regular production gun, that would be my new pick. As it is I have just about enough guns.

[Lawdawg45]

"Which revolver to buy"

nyc71, it depends on what it will be used for. The adjustable sights on the Blackhawk make it a preferred hunting weapon, but the Vaquero is a more period correct gun for CAS. Be advised though, the new model Vaquero is not rated for hot ammo like the old model and Blackhawk are!

LD45

[nyc71]

It for range fun only.


"They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety"- Benjamin Franklin

[wheelgunslinger]

Range fun= Vaquero for me. I much prefer an old style single action for plinking.

[303tom]

Ruger !

[MachIVshooter]

Given that the new Vaq can't take hot loads, I'd have to go for the Blackhawk. The new Vaquero does nothing for me. Without the ability to handle heavy loads, I'd rather have a Uberti than a Vaquero. Much nicer gun, IMO.

Ruger !

They're both Rugers

[Smokey in PHX]

Ruger Blackhawk

[Vern Humphrey]

The great advantage of the Blackhawk is adjustable sights. You will find if you switch ammo, your revolver will shot to a different point of impact. So with non-adjustable sights, you need to try different brands and loads and when you find one that shoots to the sights, stick with it.

With adjustable sights, a couple of clicks on the sight will put you on for any ammo your revolver can digest.

[W.E.G.]

Older sixguns did not have adjustable sights.

If you are going for the retro experience, the adjustable sights don't belong.

I have several of each format.

[Hondo 60]

The new model Vaquero has a smaller frame than the new model Blackhawk.
I have short fingers & found the Blackhawk was just a bit too big for me to comfortably handle one-handed.
So if you have small hands or short fingers a Vaquero may be the better choice for you.

And +1 to what W.E.G. said - older sixguns did not have adjustable sights.