Who makes a better cartridge case

Winchester or Starline & why ( your opinion )??

Starline, no contest.
Starline makes the best handgun brass you can get.

Why?
Cause that's just the way it is!

rc

My vote for starline also, bought some .40S&W awhile ago and was very impressed great brass.

I get 5-6 reloads from Starline on mag los before the brass starts contributing to inconsistent EDs over the chrony, WW only 3.

But if I start with new from both the WW is lower than Starline on the 1st firing .

The next lot may be the opposite , but no matter how hard the industry strives for consistency there will be differences in a given alloy .

Totally agree with RC. I perfer Starline for my 44. Mag reloads.

I also like Starline brass best. The primer holes seem to be centered and the same size on all cases and they last a very long time.

Starline.

Another Starline FanBoy here. Just bought 1000 nickle plated .44 mag cases from Graf (.21 cents per). They should last me awhile I'm guessing at 5 reloads each thats about 1 to 2 years with this caliber.

I've got a couple thousand of each in 38 spl & 45 colt.

I don't notice any difference in accuracy or speed (when chrono'd).

And some of each have 15 firings too.

*~*
it's shinier

moved to a new thread