I thought the S&W 1006 (that series) were supposedly the tank or best. If you do the tricks to the Witness, 1911's and Glocks what is the strongest?
Trying to figure if the G20 is the strongest but know little about the internals. I wish I had a 1006 to take tear one of each down side by side and see. Slide mass, guide rod and how it anchors, frame, etc...
If you enjoyed reading about "Different 10mm's and strength" here in TheHighRoad.org archive, you'll LOVE our community. Come join TheHighRoad.org today for the full version!
August 2, 2012, 08:14 PM
I think the Glocks have stood up the best over the years, though I've never heard a bad word about the S&W 3rd gen pistols.
The 1911 as a platform, maybe not every individual manufacturer's model, but at least the original Colt's Delta Elite, showed some durability issues with the caliber. That very likely was growing pains associated with a manufacturer chambering a newer, higher performance round than was previously able to fit in their platform, than overall 1911 incompatibility with 10mm.
Some Witnesses had some cracking issues early on as well, but the design has been changed, and I don't believe it still happens. I think other 1911 makers have had better luck with 10mm in the 1911, probably by way of Colt's trial and error.
August 2, 2012, 08:15 PM
I think the Smith's are probably the strongest. Glock, is the only other platform that has proven it will work. There have simply been too many problems with the 1911's and especially the EAA's to consider them.
To say which is better, Glock or Smith is hard to say. My gut feeling is to say the Smith because of the steel frame. But on the other hand Glock has many 9mm pistols with a round count of near, or over 300,000 rounds. I don't know of any other 9mm's that can make that claim regardless of frame material.
I cannot afford the ammo to wear out either. I have a Glock 20 that has served me well. Some day I'd not mind a 1006 if I ever run up on a good deal when funds are available.
August 2, 2012, 08:18 PM
I read a 1911 will give up the ghost in the 10-15k range of full-power 10mm. I don't know how many many Match has on it but a good amount and still looks new. I'm waiting to see which one of my 10's has an issue first.
August 2, 2012, 08:37 PM
Bren Ten?? ;)
August 2, 2012, 08:40 PM
I read a 1911 will give up the ghost in the 10-15k range of full-power 10mm.Well, if it does, it won't be a Colt. Mine were all full power loads, dating back to 1989.
August 2, 2012, 08:53 PM
Tanfoglio's have 10mm problems like Glock has 40S&W problems...
August 2, 2012, 09:13 PM
The Glock 20 was designed as a 10mm gun from the get go, and the 21(Glocks full size .45ACP gun) was designed off of it. 1911's were designed to be .45 ACP guns, and probably most other 10mm's were designed off other caliber frames.
I was never a big Glock fan, but I wanted a really good, functional, and practical to use for things other than just target shooting 10mm, and I though the G20SF was the best choice so that is what I went with. No regrets, and oddly enough it has become my favorite gun, and I never would of thought that before I bought it, as I have 1911's, CZ75, several shotguns, and rifles that I'm found of, but I love my Glock and the 10mm round.
I'm sure there are other good 10mm guns out there, but rest assure the Glock 10mm guns are very good, and functional as a SD/hunting gun. I'm just wondering when we are go to see them in Gen 4 Glocks.
I was shooting in a USPSA Match back in the 90s and one of the local Game Wardens brought a S&W 1006 10mm. As soon as he fired the first shot, I knew he was shooting full power ammo. The first stage of the match involved the first shot hitting a 50 yard Pepper Popper. When he hit that popper it sounded like BOOMCLANGSLAP :). After he finished the stage and while the RO inspected the popper for damage, myself and about six other people asked him what kind of ammo he was shooting. It was factory Norma 170 Grain JHP at 1400 fps. Except for the recent Doubletap and Buffalo Bore offerings, the Norma stuff is some of the hottest 10mm ammo ever factory loaded. Even with the double action first shot and the 238 Power Factor ammo, he still came in 7th out of 27 shooters and won 1st Unclassified.
S&W 1006...good guns.
Just my .02,
August 3, 2012, 12:09 AM
Guide rod installed in slide
Guide rod installed in frame with slide removed
I put this together a while back and the 800lb Club only has one:
These are your Elite suppliers for real 10mm ammo:
- Underwood Ammo
- Underwood Ammo
- Buffalo Bore
- Underwood Ammo
- Buffalo Bore
- Right To Bear Ammo
- Trident Ammo
- Parabellum Research Ammo
- Reed's Ammo
- MAC Ammo
- Grizzly Cartridge Company
- HPR Ammo
- Thunderbird Cartridge Company
- Precision Cartridge Company
- Atomic Ammunition
If Elite Ammo starts 10mm again they will be added.
August 3, 2012, 12:14 AM
I haven't really ever been attracted to S&W autos, but when I caught the 10mm bug last week, and I saw this fine weapon on sale...I'm very proud to own this gun.
August 3, 2012, 12:17 AM
Nice shots! Let me see what I have for a scale (nice one BTW!). How is the wiggle on the end of the guide rod? I see it has a nipple (LOL) where it clips in. Can you rock it? The Match stock rod you could move it around and it didn't give you the full 270 degrees of surface area the cone does. The cone rod is solid and gives 270 degrees of support.
In that area the huge lug of the Match is much thicker than the 1006.
August 3, 2012, 12:30 AM
When the guide rod is just in the frame there isn't a whole lot of movement in its channel, but installing the guide rod into the slide can be a little harrowing. There is just a teeny tiny ledge on the barrel where it sits, and the spring is under incredible tension. You could really hurt yourself by launching the guide rod into yourself or an unsuspecting bystander.
Funny story, I decided early last week to get a 10mm. I knew a place selling a Witness 10mm used. I'm a fan of CZs, so a 10mm Tanfoglio (Witness) was my first choice by a mile. I even had a poll running on this site to see if I could be talked out of it. The poll respondents spoke very highly of the 1006, but I figured it wouldn't be practical or affordable to get one. The auction sites have them going for around what I could buy a new Colt Delta Elite. Well, to make a long story short. Gun store "A" no longer had the Witness. I was close to buying one on Gallery of Guns and/or Bud's Gunshop. I walked into gun shop B and was half talking myself into buying a Polly Witness in 10mm when I saw the 1006 for cheaper than the Witness or a new Glock 20. I couldn't get my wallet out fast enough!
August 3, 2012, 12:52 AM
I call your cheap scale with an even cheaper one :)
Don't have anything that will go high enough to weigh the full assembled Match. The frame went past zero BTW.
August 3, 2012, 12:55 AM
I wish Swampfox was still around. That guy made some great 10mm ammo. Unfortunately he passed a little while back.
August 3, 2012, 01:00 AM
The Match is 1/4" shorter. It looks like the frame may weigh more than the 1006?
That deal you got on the 1006 was nuts!
August 3, 2012, 01:01 AM
Yes he did for sure!
August 3, 2012, 02:39 AM
Well, the LAR grizzly was far and away the strongest 10mm, but they're also not a normal size gun; The same platform was used for .45 Win Mag and .50 AE.
In a duty gun, the S&W 10XX are the toughest.
August 3, 2012, 06:53 AM
I own a Glock Gen2 model 20 and a Smith 1006; both bought in the early '90s. Both have been fired extensively since purchase and both have held up extremely well. Being my favorite cartridge to load, and my favorite to shoot, "extensively" means ten of thousands of rounds each. Right now I don't have access to my round-count data.
Basically I've had no problems with either gun but I do prefer the G20 mainly because it's current production.
Although out of production, parts for the 1006 are still available as well as magazines. The only replacement part I've ever had to install on the 1006 was a set of grips S&W supplied shortly after purchase because of reported grip breakage incidents. The G20's frame internals were upgraded about ten years ago at Glock's suggestion. I never experienced any kind of performance or safety issues.
August 3, 2012, 11:24 AM
EAA Witness Hunter is a big beefy gun that stands up well to the 10mm cartridge - but its not a duty size gun either.
August 3, 2012, 11:38 AM
But what ammo do you use that lives up to the guns potential. From what i have read, that is the main problem for those who don't reload. The stock stuff in stores really dosen't do the gun justice.
August 3, 2012, 11:39 AM
Yup my Hunter is pretty darn stout. With the heavier spring in it and flat bottom firing pin block it shoots the hottest 10mm to a boring level.