Slight end shake in S&W revolver


PDA






Deaf Smith
November 8, 2014, 09:45 AM
It's not a huge deal, just a little end shake.

What are the remedies for end shake in a S&W revolver (K frame?)

I know a shim can be put on the front of the cylinder crane but are there other ways?

Thanks,

Deaf

If you enjoyed reading about "Slight end shake in S&W revolver" here in TheHighRoad.org archive, you'll LOVE our community. Come join TheHighRoad.org today for the full version!
au_prospector
November 8, 2014, 09:58 AM
And they shoot just fine, both are very very accurate.

They both shake a little side to side and slightly front and back on lockup.
I have picked up a few other K and L frame S&W and tried to shake them at lockup and they all seem to do it. I have assumed all along this is normal for S&W...

Dont know why. I have a Colt Det Sp and it doesnt shake at all.

Driftwood Johnson
November 8, 2014, 10:47 AM
Howdy

A little bit of endshake is normal in a S&W revolver. I just grabbed a few old ones and relatively new ones, all showed a little bit of endshake. Do you know how to measure end shake? Push the cylinder all the way forward and insert the biggest feeler gauge that will fit. Then push the cylinder all the way back and again insert the biggest feeler gauge that will fit. Subtract the big one from the little one, that will tell you how much endshake you have. I encountered anywhere from .002 to .006 in my quick test. I have some very old Smiths, I will try the test on them when I get a chance.

As far as a little bit of rotational slop when the cylinder is at battery, again, completely normal. I have not quantified it yet, but a little bit is normal. That's why the forcing cone is there.

Yes, there are other ways than shims to minimize endshake, but they are going to involve a gunsmith. Frankly, I have lost count of how many Smiths I own and I have never been concerned with endshake unless it was extreme. Same with rotational slop. If there is too much of either, I don't buy it.

BCRider
November 11, 2014, 04:12 PM
Mine share end shakes similar to what DJ found. My Model 28 arrived with more than that. Something in the order of .010. That one I did make up and install a .008 brass washer in the ejector assembly like it should be to reduce the total to something that was still felt but was hard to measure. You can find brass shim stock at model airplane or model railroad hobby shops. Or you can order up a washer shim kit from the usual gun smithing suppliers.

MrBorland
November 11, 2014, 06:00 PM
I know a shim can be put on the front of the cylinder crane but are there other ways?

A gunsmith can use a yoke stretcher, then ream out the ID back to spec.

A little fore/aft play isn't atypical for a S&W. I'm no gunsmith, but if endshake is enough to do something about, it'll be affecting the action, IME. If a 0.002" shim fixes it, that's the easiest route for the do-it-yourselfer. If you need more than 2 shims, it may be time for a 'smith to do his magic.

jad0110
November 11, 2014, 06:14 PM
I have assumed all along this is normal for S&W...

Dont know why. I have a Colt Det Sp and it doesnt shake at all.

Yep, its normal for a S&W. Actually, in a S&W action you need just a little end shake for it to function properly, like at least .001.

Some Colts (like the Detective Special, Diamond Backs and the Python) should have absolutely NO end shake whatsoever. Other Colts (like the Trooper and King Cobra I believe) don't have such a strict requirement.

If you enjoyed reading about "Slight end shake in S&W revolver" here in TheHighRoad.org archive, you'll LOVE our community. Come join TheHighRoad.org today for the full version!