1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

124gr. +P or 147 gr. 9mm

Discussion in 'Handguns: Autoloaders' started by ColtraneM3, Feb 10, 2010.

  1. ColtraneM3

    ColtraneM3 New Member

    I just got a Springfield XDM in 9mm as my first handgun (typically I'm a Sig guy, but I'm too poor for a Sig at the moment, so I went for the next best thing). Now, I'm just going to run no-frills Winchester target rounds at the range for practice, but for home defense I'm a little inexperienced with selecting ammunition.

    If I had my choice in a self defense situation I'd just get my Rem 870 tactical out of the closet, but understanding that I might not be able to or have time to get to my closet, I want to make sure I have something close by that's easily grab-able.

    I did a little browsing and selected a box of Winchester 124gr. +P hollow point rounds over the 147gr. hollow points in the interest of velocity and energy on impact, but I'm curious what everyone else has to say. Do you prefer the lighter, faster rounds or the heavier, slower ones?
  2. rhartwell

    rhartwell New Member

    I use the 147 grain for SD that is what the police in this are used before going to the 40
  3. ColtraneM3

    ColtraneM3 New Member

    I gave serious consideration to the 147, but I read that it has more potential to over penetrate, which concerned me a bit for use in my house...
  4. MK11

    MK11 New Member

    They're both fine. I prefer the 124 grainer myself, partly because it's easier to find training ammo in the same weight. NYPD seems pleased with that load.
  5. Marlin 45 carbine

    Marlin 45 carbine New Member

    I haven't tryed but have loaded some 147gr Rem GS to +P data, have tryed the 124gr GS loaded to +P data for crude expansion tests in stacked wet cardboard and also Longdayjake's 124gr JHP - believe me you don't want to take either anywhere near COM.:eek:
  6. Bill_G

    Bill_G New Member

    i prefer the Rem Golden Saber 147gr. according to brassfetcher it penetrates 12" and expands to .60+. thats good enough for me.

    also....it has a rep for feeding in pistols that wont normally feed HP.
  7. Water-Man

    Water-Man Active Member

    Speer Gold Dot 124gr. +P or 147gr.
  8. 9mmepiphany

    9mmepiphany Moderator

    my department issues the Ranger 127gr +P+ and have been very happy with it's performance.

    i carry it in my personal guns too, but have also had good lucky with the Speer 124gr +P Gold Dots which seem to have a good record too
  9. christcorp

    christcorp New Member

    115 grain Hornady Critical Defense.
  10. carbon9mm

    carbon9mm New Member

    i carry a Model 39 smith. It does like hollow points to well. Tried the Federal EFMJ they are 124+p's and havent had a problem in 100rds fired.
  11. easyg

    easyg New Member

    In a 9mm I prefer fast and light.
    I'll take a 115g or a 124g, even in non +P pressure, over a 147g.
  12. W.E.G.

    W.E.G. Active Member

    Ammo selection for PD's is reliability first, "EXTREME SHOCK" effect second.

    Everybody uses high quality (expensive) hollow-points nowdays.

    Choose whatever works best in your gun.
    If both loads function equally well, you can consider them equally effective.

  13. Deanimator

    Deanimator Active Member

    I have 147gr. Winchester White Box JHPs in both of my 9x19mm guns.
  14. rha600

    rha600 New Member

  15. Kangspec

    Kangspec New Member

    According to Internet test, 9mm 147 gr HST did better job than 124 gr/ 124 gr P+.

    and i have 500 rd of 147gr HST.:evil:
  16. Quoheleth

    Quoheleth Active Member

    I have read in various forii that these bullets are the same construction as the Silver Tips. Anyone confirm or refute that? The price is sure hard to beat: 50 rounds for the same or less money than 20 round boxes of "premium" stuff.

  17. Big Bill

    Big Bill New Member

    I'd go with the 147 gr for HD - better stopping power.

    Q - I heard that too.
  18. MrWesson

    MrWesson New Member

    I use corbon 125gr +p
  19. Dave85

    Dave85 New Member

    I use the Federal 115 gr. +P+ or the Winchester Ranger 127 gr. +P+ simply because my pistol prefers the light to medium weight rounds, and these have a good track record. There are a number of good 124 gr. +P loads that I would also be very comfortable with. I wouldn't mind any of the current top-tier 147 gr. loadings either, as they seem to work quite well, too.

    All the data seems to indicate that, especially between the mid-weight +Ps and the 147 gr. loads, they are really just tweaking different parts of the formula to get essentially the same results. The heavier bullets appear to go through barriers a bit better, the lighter bullets might tend to overpenetrate a bit less…or so they say. In the end, it looks like all top quality 115-127 gr. +P and +P+, and 147 gr. loads do just about as good in the vast majority of scenarios. Which is great, because you can pick what works best in your gun, and not worry whether or not you're missing out on something.
  20. GojuBrian

    GojuBrian New Member

    I use 124gr +p PowRball ammunition. :cool:

Share This Page