1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

3" GP100 vs. 3" Sp101

Discussion in 'Handguns: Revolvers' started by cookekdjr, Dec 17, 2005.


Which 3" revolver, gp100 or sp101?

  1. gp100 (pleae explain your choice below)

    45 vote(s)
  2. sp101 (pleae explain your choice below)

    36 vote(s)
  1. cookekdjr

    cookekdjr Well-Known Member

    Trying to decide between a 3" sp101 and 3" gp100 for home defense, ccw and light trail gun.
    I love both guns, and recall they both fit my hand well. I don't live near a gun store with both guns in stock anymore, so now I'm guessing which one fits my hand best. Can't remember specifics, just remember both fit me well.
    The sp101 speedloaders fit my 342pd (my "always, everywhere" gun). The gp100 holds one extra round. Sp101 is lighter and easier to carry on the hip i guess.
    Which do your recommend I get, and why? I've read numerous reviews (icluding Mr. Camp's impressions of both-great job Mr. Camp), and I fired an sp101 years ago (2") and enjoyed it.
    What do you think?

  2. MCgunner

    MCgunner Well-Known Member

    SP101, light on the hip afield. Why worry over an extra round?

    The GP100 does have adjustable sites. But, I'd rather have the more rugged fixed system and just try ammo until you find what works with it. The one advantage to the GP, though, if you like to shoot a lot of .38s, you can adjust the elevation. That might be imprortant to you as an outdoor gun. If so, I'd change the vote. ;)
  3. MillCreek

    MillCreek Well-Known Member

    Having owned both models, and noting your usability requirements for carry and as a trail gun, I vote for the lighter weight and slightly smaller SP-101. The reduced size and weight will make it easier to carry concealed or on the trail. The one less extra round for these purposes do not concern me overly much. I figure that if my problem has not been solved by five rounds of .357 125 grain JHP, it is time to go to Plan B, which is either run away, duck for cover and reload or use the revolver as a club!
  4. fisherman66

    fisherman66 Well-Known Member

    *If* CCW is a consideration the SP101 is the best choice. For other tasks, the GP100 is the better choice (marginally).

    I went with the GP100, but my line of work puts me in government and school buildings, so CCW is not an option.

    A good holster and belt make the GP's weight a non-issue when field carrying. JMO.
  5. Sulaco

    Sulaco Well-Known Member

    I own an SP101 3" and went with it over a larger 6 shot revolver because I will be carrying it concealed a good bit of the time. I also do not have a smaller pocket carry J-frame like you have. If I did and could afford to keep both, I would get a 4" GP100 and have the best of both worlds. If you already have the 342PD, go with the GP but get a longer barrel. Thank me later.

  6. Gary A

    Gary A Well-Known Member

    I have both and love both. Looking at all your uses/requirements I voted for the SP101 also. Both are 3 inch, both have fixed sights. For home defense the GP is superior, IMO. For shooting stiff loads, the GP is superior, IMO. But for CCW and "light" trail use, I would choose the SP. The SP does all three things you want well enough and carries easier and more discreetly than the GP. Ultimately, you may well want both. I did and am very happy.
  7. grimjaw

    grimjaw Well-Known Member

    I voted SP101 because it's somewhat easier to conceal. But why sacrifice? Those guns are priced well, get both! I have a GP100 4", and should have a SP101 3" in .38 Special soon.

  8. Pilot

    Pilot Well-Known Member

    If I'm going to get a 3 inch its going to be with the smaller framed SP101. If I'm going 4 inch, I want the GP100.
  9. Dollar An Hour

    Dollar An Hour Well-Known Member

    Not in 3".

    I'd say get the SP if CCW is part of the equation. I love my 3" GP for it's balance and the way it feels in the hand, but not for it's CC ability.
  10. MCgunner

    MCgunner Well-Known Member

    Mmm, yeah, I'd get a 4" GP.
  11. OSS

    OSS Active Member

    I think it depends a lot on how the gun feels in your hand. I held both the SP and the GP, and I went with the GP because it fit my hand like a glove while the SP was too small and uncomfortable in my hands. I won't be concealing very often and I will be spending a lot of time at the range, so the GP was the better option for me.
  12. cookekdjr

    cookekdjr Well-Known Member

    And the winner is...

    Bought a gp100 w/3" barrel today.
    I'm already saving for the sp101 to go with it...............:D
    Thanks to all who replied,
  13. Skipper

    Skipper Well-Known Member

    I've had both. Both great, but my 3" SP101 is the hands down winner for ME.
    In fact, except for hunting, this may be my very favorite revolver.
  14. cookekdjr

    cookekdjr Well-Known Member

    I'm already picking out guns to sell to finance an sp101.
    I don't know why I didn't buy one before.
  15. Big Mike

    Big Mike Well-Known Member

    I find my 3" GP100 to be balanced. Mike
  16. Surefire

    Surefire Well-Known Member

    double post
  17. Surefire

    Surefire Well-Known Member

    If it was me, I'd get both.

    The SP 101 is easier to conceal, especially in weight (doesn't drag the belt down as much).

    The GP 100 is a lot easier on the shooter with the heavies (180-200 grain bullets ). The GP 100 gives mild to moderate recoil with every single .357 magnum load I've tried. Put these same heavier loads in an SP, and IMO it is uncomfortable. The GP also balances better for me.

    Each revolver is an excellent choice, but they fill slightly different niches IMO.

    If I had to pick just one, I'd give the nod to the GP.
  18. gunfan

    gunfan Well-Known Member

    Since I already have a 4" GP100, The SP101 would be the one I'd opt to obtain! :)

  19. adaman04

    adaman04 Well-Known Member

    This is literally one of the hardest decisions ever. No joke, I sat here and looked at the poll for over 5 mins. I voted the SP101, because they just look so sexy in Badger grips and for your intended use, I think it would be a good choice.

    Heck, either gun will serve you well. The GP100 has 1 extra round and is a bigger frame, which means less felt recoil. It isn't overly bulky and would also be a good choice. Less concealable if that is your thing, but a fine gun none the less.

  20. gunfan

    gunfan Well-Known Member

    Whatever you do...

    do not sell your .32 Magnum! You'll regret it! :what: :uhoh:


Share This Page