1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

.300 Weatherby too much for deer?

Discussion in 'Rifle Country' started by BayouBocephus, Nov 11, 2008.

  1. BayouBocephus

    BayouBocephus Well-Known Member

    I picked up a 1988 or 1989 Remington 700 Classic in .300 Weatherby and put a 3-9x50 Nikon Buckmaster on it...I love this rifle but everyone I talk to says it is too much for a deer and will destroy it....HELPPP!

  2. grtwhthntr

    grtwhthntr Well-Known Member

    It's certainly more bang than you NEED for a deer, but if you wanna hunt with a howitzer, more power to you! ;)
  3. SoCalShooter

    SoCalShooter Well-Known Member

    Depends on the size of a deer, friend of mine just a week ago shot a small deer at about 200 yards, the round when through rear leg then through the ball joints and out the other side. It definitely has some power and you can hunt a lot of things with it other than deer, I would suggest however getting a good muzzle break on it and you can seriously reduce the recoil.

    You will definitely be able to put a deer down with it.

    5 out of 6 people in our hunting party use a 300 weatherby magnum in the weatherby vanguard platform, great rifles, great round.
  4. WardenWolf

    WardenWolf member

    You may be able to find a lower power load than the standard .300 WebMag that would be more suited for deer. That's been a trend in recent years, as people have begun to realize that the power race has gotten completely ludicrous and shooters increasingly have been looking to dial back their existing guns.
  5. atblis

    atblis Well-Known Member


    It won't destroy meat excessively provided you use the correct bullets.

    Use a well behaved bullet, and all will be well.
  6. Rampant_Colt

    Rampant_Colt Well-Known Member

    save the earth! reload - reload - reload - reload

    When hunting, I've personally never heard the expression "too much gun" ;)

    You may experience more bloodshot meat with that .300 Cannon... Go for a headshot, or [if you reload] whip up some moderate-velocity loads.

    That's what's so nice about the big-bore rounds - you may tailor the loads to suit your needs.

    @ Bocephus - if you don't reload, Remington makes some "Managed Recoil" ammunition, but i'm not 100% sure if it's available in .300 Wby Mag

    sounds like a nice gun!
  7. Al Thompson

    Al Thompson Moderator Staff Member

    Horse manure. If you like the rifle, use it. I'd go with a tough 180 grain bullet myself - lighter and faster may blow up a bit, but a good 180 will work just fine. I've used a .375 H&H quite a few times on deer and smaller critters. :D
  8. BayouBocephus

    BayouBocephus Well-Known Member

    I shot the rifle while sighting in the scope about 10 times(lil over $25)...my shoulder was brusied..what type of muzzle break could I get?
  9. Polish_Pounder

    Polish_Pounder Well-Known Member

    A friend of mine took 2 small whitetails with his last year. Load was a 165 grain ballistic tip compressed load. Both deer were disassembled by 200 yard broadside shoulder shots. On the second deer the off-side shoulder was hanging on by the skin only. +1 on a tough 180 grain bullet. Other than that, it is a very versatile and powerful round. Quite a bit of gun for deer, but not necessarily too much.

  10. WardenWolf

    WardenWolf member

    You can get your gun fitted for a MagnaBrake. That's supposed to cut recoil by 45%.


    You can also invest in a Limbsaver pad for your rifle.
  11. Rampant_Colt

    Rampant_Colt Well-Known Member

    you're gonna get a case of the flinches from that rifle and miss :uhoh:
  12. SoCalShooter

    SoCalShooter Well-Known Member

    My friend had his 300 fitted by BASS PRO I do not know the muzzle break he got but he stated to me that it shot lighter than his 308 encore did now.
  13. Art Eatman

    Art Eatman Administrator Staff Member

    Hard to ruin meat if you don't shoot Bambi in the eating part, I always noticed.

    I never shot at a deer. I always shot at a specific place on a deer, and that place wasn't in the eating part. Neck or heart/lung. Not in the shoulders, backstraps or hams. :D
  14. pbrktrt

    pbrktrt Well-Known Member

    i'm with you Art. if i can't take a good shot and put it between the ribs i won't take it. i use an accurate rifle & a very good scope & shoot year round.i know where the shot is going. i have no problem with the guys that love their 30 mags but the 270 has always done what i've asked of it. there is not a beast alive that will go very far after a double lung shot.
  15. groundhog34

    groundhog34 Well-Known Member

    I shoot a 300 weatherby on occasion at deer when I am hunting at long 200+ yard range or when i do not want the deer to run because of terraine we have some steep hill or small steep mountains in alabama. I shoot for the fro shoulder or heart and find that the 300 make a fist size exit hole but there is not much meat wasted. I use 180 grain.
    Look at the weatherby web site for muzzle breaks I recommend getting one.
  16. Elgin47

    Elgin47 Well-Known Member

    As previously mentioned, it has a lot more to do with your ability to place the bullet where you aim - and aiming in the right place - than it does with what caliber you're using - which usually means shooting something that doesn't cause you to flinch.

    I've had several .300 Weatherby rifles and liked them all - well, most of them - but the laws of physics prove consistently (and sometimes frustratingly) true, so a .300 Weatherby will bump you some, but for me it's a reasonable trade-off because I hunt big mule deer and elk in wide open country where longer shots are the rule rather than the exception - so in this particular application the .300 Weatherby or something similar is appropriate; where it might not be in heavy brush/timber.

    A properly designed and installed muzzle brake is a great help sighting in, but your hunting buddies will not be happy when you touch it off - especially if they are off to the side instead of behind you.

    Disclaimer is I've been around hunting and firearms a long time, but I'm no expert - so my opinions are worth exactly what you paid for them.
  17. Geno

    Geno Well-Known Member

    Great purchase; awesome round! I have taken many, many deer, ram and boar with .300 Weatherby and with .257 Weatherby.

    I only damaged meat once. One ram that I shot at several hundred yards spun as I fired, and the beast took a 150 grain Projectilation H. It blew literally about 10" hole in the beast. I do have photos, but they are too gruesome to post.

    I always try to fire into the ribs (heart/lungs). The bullets seldom have exited the far side of the body. That is to say, usually 100% of the tremendous energy has been transferred to the critter.

    All the same, 100% of my harvests have been 1-shots, instant kills, even to 525 yards. The only reason I purchased my last Weatherby Mark V in .300 Winchester Magnum is the price of Wea. ammunition. Reload and you'll save money.

    Again, awesome, awesome round! You'll be pleased. BTW, Accurate Arms 3100, Reloader 22 and H4831 are all great powders for reloading.

  18. earlthegoat2

    earlthegoat2 Well-Known Member

    Where Im at everyone like to overgun themselves so taking deer with 300 mags is the norm. It doesnt blow the deer apart so go ahead and use it.
  19. LeonCarr

    LeonCarr Well-Known Member

    Better to have and not need than to need and not have :).

    I am seriously considering going the .30 caliber magnum route in the near future, and the .300 "Roy" would be a good choice.

    Just my .02,
    Last edited: Nov 12, 2008
  20. cliffy

    cliffy member


    When a .243 Winchester 100 grain bullet can smother a white-tail deer in ultimate fury, what can a .30 caliber hyper bullet add? More edible meat loss is about all. Provided the heavy recoil doesn't cause one to miss or wound. A .30/06 provides MORE than too much potency for dropping-dead-in-its-tracks any game animal in North America. A more potent .30 caliber can, with a "perfect" hit, turn a beastie inside out. Now that's a trophy! cliffy

Share This Page