1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Are Hawkbills versatile ?

Discussion in 'Non-Firearm Weapons' started by krupparms, May 22, 2014.

  1. krupparms

    krupparms Well-Known Member

    How versatile are hawkbill knives? Do they make decent self defense knives? Or are they just a knife for cutting cord & rope ect. Are they useful for anything else? Would you use one for S.D.?
  2. Yo Mama

    Yo Mama Well-Known Member

    Sorry but I'm not looking to use a knife for sd, a gun is with me everywhere I go. With a backup mag, depending on the gun it's roughly 16ish rounds. If I need a knife after using all my rounds, I'm in some doodoo.

    A knife maeks you get way to close to an attacker, and at that point it doesn't matter the shape of the blade. If you are truly looking at getting a blade with the mindset of sd, I'd get fixed blade so you don't have to worry about fine motor movement.
  3. GLOOB

    GLOOB Well-Known Member

    I agree. And yet, this subforum is called non-firearm weapons.

    Too bad there's not a subforum simply for knives.
  4. krupparms

    krupparms Well-Known Member

    That's why this was posted here. I to would use a firearm instead of a knife. Firearms cannot be carried someplaces knives can. I was woundering what others thought of this style of knife. As the increased interest in them shows. I.E.the Krimbits, Spyderco Hawkbills ect.
  5. Sam Cade

    Sam Cade Member

    For very small knives a blade with a lot of forward curve is a way of getting more cutting edge into a given length with the added benefit of preventing the medium being cut from sliding away from the edge.

    The disadvantage is obvious in that the extreme drop of the tip makes stabbing either difficult or impossible.

    You can see how lying supine with an assailant in full mount (hereafter to be known as The Zimmerman Position) it would be more advantageous to administer stabs than offer a back scratching. ;)
  6. Sam Cade

    Sam Cade Member

    Y'know,a knife specific subforum would probably draw more traffic than Non-firearm weapons.

    Maybe "Knives and Blades" being separate.

    I'll float it in Staff.
  7. krupparms

    krupparms Well-Known Member

    I agree! A knife subforum would be nice as they predominant this one. There are so many S.D.items & styles out there. But Gun &Knives seem to be the top 2 items discussed. I agree with your point about stabbing. That is why I asked this question. These knives seem to be becomeing more popular. I am certainly seeing more of them. The Krimbits for one & the Spyderco matriarch 2, civilian ect. Are they a serious knife for what they are S.D.? Or just a fad.
  8. WestKentucky

    WestKentucky Well-Known Member

    Pretty versatile for the hawk. For SD I can't see one being useful.
  9. rcmodel

    rcmodel Member in memoriam

    They are sure hard to sharpen using conventional methods too!

    The inside curve is in all the wrong places.

  10. Sam Cade

    Sam Cade Member

    A forward recurve is the optimal blade shape for maximum efficacy on a cut into flexible, unsupported medium.

    The real question is, "Do you want/need your knife to do anything else?"

  11. krupparms

    krupparms Well-Known Member

    A friend who was a army Ranger & I decided to try some experiments with some hawkbill knives. We used a cardboard box about 4'long & about 12"×14" size. We both took turns We put our backs against the floor & the other person held the box. We used his Spyderco Tasman & a Spyderco Harpy . The object was to see if we could inflect a decent stab wound to the box! But only from the bottom or side! Also slashing wounds! Both of us were able to inflect stab wounds & slashing wounds. We found that as you stabbed into the box, that by rotating your hand as you thrust into the box, we could produce some significant stab wounds! Slashing was also possible & effective. This was by no means a scientific test. But it is interesting & something I will be testing more about. I do think other designs work much better & willnot depend on one for S.D.! That Mayerco looks like it would work.
  12. krupparms

    krupparms Well-Known Member

    I decided to try Spyderco's BYRD line. I know most here believe the hawkbill knives to be just a line cutting tool & not for SD. I am seeing a trend to use them as SD knives. I picked up a BYRD CROSSBILL HAWKBILL KNIFE
    It had to be ordered so I should have it by next week & will let you know about it. If I can get someone who knows how to add pictures to my post I will do so.
  13. CWL

    CWL Well-Known Member

    I've been using my Spydie Tasman Salt for 9+ years now as a chore knife & EDC. The design is useful and reliable, as it always presents a point & cutting surface towards the task at hand. Hawkbills naturally keep cutting into the object with draw cuts due to the downwards-turning edge, while standard blade profiles have a tendency to want to work itself out unless you keep applying pressure. The hawkbill wants to stay inside the object, which is useful if your hands slip due to tiredness or weather.

    It can handle SD applications if you know what you're doing. Don't plan on going for major organs, but my Spydie ought to easily pierce 1-2", which would be the type of control & distraction stabs I'd use with my knife. It certainly will cut & rip. (I'd still prefer 12ga.)

    Sharpening? Easy with a rod or Sharpmaker, just draw the blade down the sharpener same as you would a standard profile knife.
  14. kBob

    kBob Well-Known Member

    My Mom carried a long bolster Barlow hawk bill in the late 1960's both for general use and with an eye toward SD. Of course we had few experts in those days to tell us that slashing is ineffective.

    I knew a guy at that time that toted around a "linoleum knife" which was a fixed hawk bill. It very efficiently opened someone from ear to ear from the front one evening and that assault stopped right there, thank you very much.

    Taking your time with a round file or steel worked to sharpen hawk bills and I would bet one of the round ceramic sticks could dress one up right nice.

  15. krupparms

    krupparms Well-Known Member

    I have a old Case linoleum Hawkbill that was my dad's. It was the first one I had ever seen. Dad always kept it sharp & said it would cut someone up bad if you used it for S.D.! He never used it for that reason or carried it.
  16. Fred Fuller

    Fred Fuller Moderator Emeritus

  17. krupparms

    krupparms Well-Known Member

    Thanks for that link Fred! I was looking at some knife pictures online the other night and saw a picture of about 16 knives & saw something that looked alot like those talons. But none were marked. Now I know what they were. That was a great article along with a pretty cool knife! I also saw some BYRD knives that had been modified by people to work in the same manner! I will look around for a copy of that Talon though!
  18. mdauben

    mdauben Well-Known Member

    I know that Spyderco (Civilian one-handed folder) and Al Mar (Backup 2 fixed blade) make "hawksbill" style knives specifically for SD use. I believe the thinking behind these blades is that an untrained fighter will normally tend to slash with a knife, and these curved blades tend to make nasty, debilitating cuts when used this way. I've tried such blades slashing against plastic bottles, carboard boxes, and heavy denim and they do seem to work well in that mode.
  19. Zeke/PA

    Zeke/PA Well-Known Member

    I use my Spyderco to sharpen a hawkbill gardening knife. Not a razor edge of course but it's adequate.
  20. JShirley

    JShirley Administrator Staff Member

Share This Page