1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Comanche .357 Magnum?

Discussion in 'Handguns: Revolvers' started by Magnum.35744, Jan 29, 2008.

  1. Magnum.35744

    Magnum.35744 Well-Known Member

    Hello everyone:),

    Now I know that this particular will get some negative feedback from other users on this thread. And I just wanted to point out in advance that I am somewhat aware of its poor quality, and other aspects. I was just here to clarify if this would be a decent choice for a cheap truck gun. Or even when walking through the swamps and not being afraid to loose this horrid pistol behind. As I would my other prized pieces. It's fairly cheap and could come in handy for a woods bumming gun. Any thoughts would be appreciated. Here's the gun in mind...

    http://www.gunbroker.com/Auction/ViewItem.asp?Item=91070058 :eek:...:p

    P.S. Remember that I'm only looking for a very cheap and low cost gun. Nothing fancy so I'm not so self conscious or would loose nights of sleep over the lost of this revolver;).

    Take care:D.
  2. BlkHawk73

    BlkHawk73 Well-Known Member

    Only one I've ever hand first-hand experience with failed. Locked up tight and required a good amount of work to get it back in operation again. Unless you're carrying it with no intentions or expectations of ever requiring it to be used defensively go for it. Otherwise, do yourself a favor and find something better. If you DO need it and it fails...was it worth skimping on?
    A decent quality gun, even used is a better option. For a little bit mor you can buy a decent holster that'll hold the gun securely. heck even a lanyard isn't a bad idea if you're worried about losing it.
    Losing it...that can come back to haunt you too. Suppose it is dropped and picked up by someone less than lawful...

    Looking at the auction...$300? You CAN buy a MUCH better gun for that price that'll serve you much better.
  3. Shawnee

    Shawnee member

    $300 will get you a used Ruger Blackhawk so, if there is some logic in spending the same $300 on this Commanche, it sure eludes me.
    Am always willing to be enlightened though !

  4. Gator

    Gator Well-Known Member


    I wouldn't buy it just because that seller sounds like a jerk: "PLEASE DO NOT BID UNLESS YOU ALREADY HAVE A SIGNED FFL..." But if you really want one, here's one for less.
  5. SASS#23149

    SASS#23149 Well-Known Member

    Many more and better options out there for 300 bucks.Used ruger revolvers,and even some 'smiths.
    By the time you pay shipping and transfer fees it's a bad deal all the way around,imho.
  6. 19-3Ben

    19-3Ben Well-Known Member


    Used Taurus would even be better if your sole criteria is that it must be cheap.
  7. markk

    markk Well-Known Member

    I paid $250 for one brand new from a shop. While it works just fine I wish I had spent more and bought something else...
  8. ryanl

    ryanl Well-Known Member

    Dont have any first hand experience with them, but the Rossi's are relatively cheap. And if im not mistaken taurus is making some/all of their models now. So at least its backed by the Taurus warranty. But personally, i would not by a cheap gun period, know matter what its intended purpose. If i only had $300 i would find something used from a reliable manufacturer like ruger or s&w, or save money until i had enough to get one. Good luck.
  9. Beatnik

    Beatnik Well-Known Member

    I bought my stainless 4" GP100 used for $300. It was a police trainer, so it was probably kicked around a lot, but it's still rock solid.
    Hit some gun shows. See what you can find in name brand before committing to something you're not sure about.
  10. Jim March

    Jim March Well-Known Member

    Utter. Total. Junk. Period.

    Search for posts by me on the Comanche for a much funnier re-statement of the same thing.
  11. bestseller92

    bestseller92 Well-Known Member

    I bought a Llama Comanche III .357 new in 1985, for $179. I used it for years and then sold it to my brother. He still has it. It's a good gun; or, at least the one I/we had/have was.
  12. 98C5

    98C5 Well-Known Member

  13. bannockburn

    bannockburn Well-Known Member

    CDNN likewise had all sorts of used S&Ws in .38 Special and .357 Mag from $299 to $349.
  14. Magnum.35744

    Magnum.35744 Well-Known Member

    Thanks everyone for the replies :). To be honest with you all I never did take a peek at the price :eek:. Just thought to myself hey aren’t those cheap guns:p? Only to my demise it is 300 bucks:what:. I think you’re all right and I'll find me a nice Ruger. And save up. Thanks again, take care;)!
  15. Moonclip

    Moonclip Well-Known Member

    I believe the Llama Commanche III is a different gun. I bought one used in 2006 for $160 to keep my Llama .44mag company and it has been fine.
  16. Jim March

    Jim March Well-Known Member

    The European Comanches were low-grade guns but usually work.

    The current Argentine Comanches are vaguely gun-like objects carved out of blown-up British motorcycle cylinders by trained monkeys being weaned from their sad methamphetamine addictions while on roller coasters. "Ghastly" only begins to describe the horror of these objects.

    You couldn't pay me to light one off unless said test involved a bench vice and 100yds of 30lb test fishing line. That strength would be needed to overcome the trigger pull.
  17. rlt7272

    rlt7272 Active Member

    Well I am going to chime in here and give a different experence. I picked up a Llama Comanche .357 on Saturday for $100. At that price I felt comfortable give the gun a chance. It was in great condition but looked like it had be shot farily ofter and not cleaned regularlly.

    Took it to the range Saturday evening and to much suprise it fired and functioned flawlessly. Infact, this is a great shooting gun. Very accurate and fun to shoot. Now when I say it was accurate, what I mean is that it shot better than the knot heads in the lanes on either side of me who were doing good to get consecutive shots on paper much less in one general area.

    So for me the Llama Comanche ranks up there with the Hi-Point Carbine as one of those guns that are getting more of a bad rap than they deserve just because some gun snob thinks that everyone should drink their coolaid and fall into line with only the major manufactures.

    In fact I have had good experiences with several "low budget" guns:

    Heritage (Rough Rider)
    Rossi (rifles and pistols)
    and now LLama

    These are all guns that alot of gun experts would not touch.
  18. Jamesmb

    Jamesmb Well-Known Member

    Yes you will find ALOT of MISINFORMATION on the highroad by very OPINIONATED so called EXPERTS. It abounds.
  19. hags

    hags Well-Known Member

    How does that statement constitute sounding like a jerk?

    I have had some experience with these revolvers. Better to buy a proven USED gun than an unknown of lesser quality. Let's just leave it at that.
  20. Jim March

    Jim March Well-Known Member

    I handled several at the Reno NRA gunshow a few years back. You'd think they'd have brought good ones to that sort of venue. The ones I saw were flat-out ghastly, both cosmetically and as shooters - endshake was present and over the top, alignment was poor, trigger feel was junk.

    Again: that was their best effort, I would assume?

Share This Page