1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Combat Carbine: 357, 44, 5.56, 7.62x39?

Discussion in 'Rifle Country' started by Glamdring, Aug 1, 2003.


Combat Carbine: What caliber?

  1. 357 Mag (lever, pump)

    5 vote(s)
  2. 44 Mag (lever, auto)

    8 vote(s)
  3. 5.56 (AR, Mini14, etc)

    47 vote(s)
  4. 7.62x39 (SKS, AK, Mini30, etc)

    48 vote(s)
  5. Other?

    9 vote(s)
  1. Glamdring

    Glamdring Well-Known Member

    What is your pic and why?
  2. priv8ter

    priv8ter Well-Known Member

    First one

    And everyone who voted so far agrees with me!

    I voted for the .357, because it takes the same kind of ammo as my revolver...just makes sence, and it will get the job done out to 75-100yards.
  3. Coot

    Coot Well-Known Member

    5.56...hey, it's good enough for our military isn't it?
  4. Dorrin79

    Dorrin79 Well-Known Member


    of course, a Yugo SKS isn't really a carbine, despite its caliber.
  5. enichols

    enichols Well-Known Member

    OH gawd, I smell yet another caliber war brewing on this thread.
  6. Preacherman

    Preacherman Well-Known Member

    You left out "all of the above". I have carbine-style weapons (semi-auto and lever-action) in all of these calibers, and would feel very comfortable in using any of them for self-defence, given adequate ammunition.
  7. BDM

    BDM Well-Known Member

    5.56 is very effective if used within its paramaters 200 yds and under,I live in a city so having a rifle I can shoot left or right handed,easy to service,maintain and carry and is very lethal if the operator does his or her part is the way to go with a defensive carbine,If I have to take a longer shot or shoot through cars or walls Ill dig out the M14.
  8. Warner

    Warner Well-Known Member

    "Combat" says no levers for me. Camping maybe, but not combat. I'd go for a mag fed piece to get me on a level playing field at least. I'd much prefer an overwhelming advantage. :D

    I won't choose the 5.56 due to the lack of any current malf-proof, rock-solid and reliable carbine/ magazine combination.

    With today's huge supply of 7.62X39 AK's, their steel mags and ammo everywhere, they would be my choice.......if the 7.62X51 was un-available to me. The SKS limits my rounds, and is too heavy with no benefit over the AK... IMO.
  9. Felonious Monk

    Felonious Monk Well-Known Member

    None of the Above.

    9mm carbine stoked with Hirtenberger +P+ or 9mm NATO.
  10. Sunray

    Sunray Well-Known Member

    "...SKS isn't really a carbine..." Um, what would you call it? An AK isn't a carbine either. Of all of these the SKS is the only "combat carbine". Neither are any of the others listed. Strictly speaking, a carbine is a short version of the current issue rifle in the same calibre intended for cavalry use. This definition changed slightly with the M1 Carbine, meant to be issued to troops who would have normally used a pistol. Now they call anything with a shorter barrel a carbine.
    Combat? You want a proper rifle or just close the hatch and use the co-ax.
    Last edited: Aug 1, 2003
  11. Dorrin79

    Dorrin79 Well-Known Member

    I suppose I was referring to the fact that a Yugo SKS is almost as large and heavy as an M1 Garand.

    Seems silly to refer to it as a carbine.

  12. meathammer

    meathammer Well-Known Member

    I voted other.

    My choice: M-16/AR-15 chambered in .458 Socom, with suppressed 16" barrel.

    Why? Powerful and very cool. I want one. :D
  13. s&w 24

    s&w 24 Well-Known Member

    I had to vote other. A carbine stikes me as something that you carry when a rifle is too heavy/bulky but you might need something bigger than a pistol.

    Personaly I'm looking into a 357 max carbine because I shoot mostly 357 mag but I would probably pick a scout type rifle over a pistol caliber or intermidiate caliber cartrige because it is just about as portable and more powerful than the others listed

    On the other hand if I were to pick a carbine to have a carbine it would be an M-1 (30 cal) or a 10 mm carbine because for what there asked to do they will do the job the best.
  14. Futo Inu

    Futo Inu member

    First, who/what are we fighting?
  15. Dr.Rob

    Dr.Rob Moderator Staff Member

    I can't imagine an American cop pulling an AK out of his patrol car, but we can all hope, right?

    There are plenty of carbine length AK's out there, In 5.56x45, 5.45x39 and 7.62x39.

    Stone simple, few parts robust magazines. Sights could be better, but a Kobra solves that for most.

    And hey why did you leave off the M-1 carbine? It's still in use in Israel as a cop/militia rifle (seen frequently on CNN)
  16. telomerase

    telomerase Well-Known Member

    What's a Kobra?

    >AK sights could be better, but a Kobra solves that for most.

    Pardon my ignorance, but what kind of sight is this? (And is there any way to fit an AK with a ghost ring?)
  17. Glamdring

    Glamdring Well-Known Member

    Dr.Rob: I only included calibers I am thinking about. The 30 carbine is to weak for me.

    I am leaning towards a 44 or 7.62x39. I like the 7.62x39 cartridge, but I still haven't found a carbine in that caliber that I like.
  18. 4v50 Gary

    4v50 Gary Moderator Staff Member

    .223. More use to it than the 7.62 x 39mm.
  19. WonderNine

    WonderNine member

    In a carbine I'd go with the 7.62 X 39 MAYBE....in a 20" barrel I'd go with 5.56 X 45.

    Of course one can make the argument you can carry more rounds with the .223 even if you have to use a carbine.
  20. Edward429451

    Edward429451 member

    You said combat carbine, so I'm choosing from the list of options and chose 5.56 for its prevelant mags/ammo, and its hi cap, and semi auto.

    The 44 semi auto would outclass a 5.56 for urban usage but not with a 4 round mag.

    How come no 22LR / 22 Mag on the list? You didn't really define the type of combat. If its gurilla warfare a 22LR could be useful. Shoot & scoot.

Share This Page