1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

For range shooting 4" or 6"

Discussion in 'Handguns: Revolvers' started by Center fire, Jul 10, 2014.

  1. Center fire

    Center fire Well-Known Member

    I was looking at the Ruger GP100 today while at the indoor range. They have both the 4" and 6" models. I am thinking about adding a 357 to my collection. Since this will be for recreational purpose only which of the two barrel lengths would you recommend? My target distances are as follows:

    5 to 15 yds 15%
    25 yds 50%
    30 to 50 yds 25%
    Beyond 50 yds 10%
  2. lionken07

    lionken07 Well-Known Member

    If it's a range only gun I'd say go with the 6". I shoot a bit better with the 6 incher and you get just a bit more power :)
  3. content

    content Well-Known Member

    I prefer my S&W 586 6" to all others in .357.
    I would recommend the S&W 617 6" .22 as well....similar feel and balance, also great to start out with at the range.
    Gets me warmed up and saves money because I use less .357 to get on target at longer ranges.
  4. Paul7

    Paul7 Well-Known Member

    6" isn't as loud either.
  5. murf

    murf Well-Known Member

    whichever one feels better and balances in your hand better. to me, sight radius doesn't matter much.

  6. BCRider

    BCRider Well-Known Member

    It sure sounds like you're doing primarily traditional bullseye style shooting. So a 6" would be hands down the way to go. And a longer barrel would not be amiss at all.

    If at some point you move towards action style shooting and competition then a 3 to 4 inch would be the way to go.
  7. rswartsell

    rswartsell Well-Known Member

    I was thinking in line with the previous posts. THEN I thought, what age is the shooter? If we are talking about a range gun we don't need to be thinking about developing maximum velocity. If we are talking about aging eyes ( a "law of physics" development, not an eye disease ), then it may actually be more difficult to focus on the longer sight radius.

    I am a "senior" shooter who finds that about 5" is the optimum for my current eyesight.

    All shooters are at the mercy of father time. Just how old a man are you?
  8. ExMachina

    ExMachina Well-Known Member

    My experience would agree that balance is the most important quality in a range/target gun.

    Sight radius only comes into play mostly at longer ranges (100 yards+)
  9. Center fire

    Center fire Well-Known Member

    I'm in my mid 50s. Most of my guns are autos with 5" barrels. I do have one revolver a Dan Wesson 44 with an 8" barrel. It's a beast and fun to shoot, but 100 rounds is where I stop as fatigue takes over and my shot groupings begin to suffer.
  10. ColtPythonElite

    ColtPythonElite Well-Known Member

    I have several 4" and 6" sets.....Past 25 yards or shooting very small targets, I pick the sixers every time.
  11. bannockburn

    bannockburn Well-Known Member

    I had a Colt Trooper Mk.V with a 6" barrel that felt perfectly balanced to me, compared to 4" barreled Model 686 or GP100. For me not it's not so much the sight radius but more like the overall balance and handling between different guns with various barrel lengths.
  12. chicharrones

    chicharrones Well-Known Member

    With 85% of your planned shooting being 25 yards or greater, I'd usually pick the 6" GP100.

    It is not a light gun and the full underlug on 6" of barrel adds to the feeling of weight due to being muzzle heavy. So, definitely hold both of them side by side to see what you prefer.

    Also be sure to see if one offers a clearer view of the front sight compared to the other. Unfortunately, my eyes have gotten to the point where handgun sights aren't in focus for any barrel length so there is no advantage to a longer sight radius. I'm slowly but surely going the red dot route which means at this point in my life I'd probably pick the 4" GP100 and mount a red dot on it. :D
  13. buck460XVR

    buck460XVR Well-Known Member

    Not only will a 6'' gun give you a longer sight radius, it will also recoil less than a comparable 4'' gun. I have 4'', 5'' and 6'' .357s and find there is little difference in balance once one develops the muscles in the arms/wrist to shoot them.
  14. Legionnaire

    Legionnaire Well-Known Member

    Range only? 6-inch. Range and field carry? 4-inch.

  15. BCRider

    BCRider Well-Known Member

    You've got a DW .44 already?

    Assuming you reload for it what about making up some reduced power loads? That should remove much of the fatigue and hand shakiness that comes from beating yourself up over a longer session. Work on getting your bullseye loads down closer to .44Spl like speeds or even milder if the gun will shoot them accurately enough.

    Or if you find the gun is a little muzzle heavy with the long barrel switch to a shorter one. Or do you not have the barrel "kit"?

    On the other hand if you simply NEED to buy another revolver I sure won't hold you back.... :D
  16. Vodoun da Vinci

    Vodoun da Vinci Well-Known Member

    When I shoot my Dan Wesson .357 for punching paper at the range it always sports it's 6" barrel. When practicing "Move and Shoot" outside it's always the 2 1/2" barrel.

    I do like my 6" barrels for target range shooting but I do little of it.

  17. Arkansas Paul

    Arkansas Paul Well-Known Member

    If you're 100% sure it will be for range use only I agree with getting the 6".

    If you were going to add HD or SD to the mix I would go 4".
  18. diyj98

    diyj98 Well-Known Member

    6" longer sight radius and as others have said, less muzzle blast.
  19. Center fire

    Center fire Well-Known Member

    @BCRider I've had the DW since around 1992. It's my only revolver. I like my autos, but I love the revolver. I want another :D and I like the versatility of the 357.
  20. Center fire

    Center fire Well-Known Member

    I like to thank everyone for the replies. I'm leaning towards the 6" configuration as this will be a target gun. I have autos for HD purposes if the need ever arises.

Share This Page