1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Home Defense Choice Pro & Cons

Discussion in 'General Gun Discussions' started by LaEscopeta, Jul 26, 2005.

  1. LaEscopeta

    LaEscopeta Well-Known Member

    After numerous threads debating which is the best home defense firearm, perhaps a summary would be useful?

    I am no expert; I am here to learn from people that are. I’ve listed the pro and cons below based on my understanding what I’ve read and heard here and elsewhere. I’m sure I don’t have all the factors and I’m sure I have some incorrect ones. I’m also pretty sure we will get postings fixing those problems.

    This comparison is primarily for home defense situations; limited number of threatening people in your home, at short range, situations that are over when you stop the threatening people, chase them away, or the police arrive. We are not talking about self defense outside the home, neighborhood defense, riots, SHTF, police or military situations, where the threat may be at a distance, or where many people may come at you from different directions, or over a long period of time, or where you have to go stop the threat first. But I have listed a few auxiliary factors for each firearm type, that relate to non-home defense uses.

    1. Small, light weight, easy to store and carry.
    2. Lots of places to practice.
    3. Low power handguns may be quieter.
    1. Harder than long arms to hit the target.
    2. Low power handguns have limited stopping power; more than one hit may be required.
    3. High power handguns have difficult to control recoil.
    4. High power semi-automatics have to be held firmly to reduce recoil induced miss-feeds.
    5. High power rounds may over penetrate through the target and/or walls.
    6. Usually more expensive than similar quality shotguns.
    7. Regulated, controlled, restricted in many places.
    Auxiliary factors:
    - Generally only useful for defense and stationary target shooting; limited or no hunting use.
    - Longer range then shotguns (if you can hit the target.)
    - Semi-automatics have large ammo capacity and are quick to reload.

    1. Generally easiest to aim (point.)
    2. Can fire a variety of ammo types, to fit different purposes.
    3. Can be loaded with one shot stopping ability (at in-the-home ranges.)
    4. Usually cheaper than similar quality handguns.
    5. Pellets not deadly for very far beyond effective aiming range (especially after the pellets go through something.)
    6. Not regulated, controlled, or restricted in most places.
    1. Long, heavy, difficult to maneuver (shorter barrel ones less so.)
    2. Some shotguns have excessive recoil with some loadings.
    3. Can be very loud (especially with shorter barrels and powerful loadings.)
    4. Slugs likely to over penetrate through the target and/or walls.
    Auxiliary factors:
    - Wide variety of hunting & target shooting uses.
    - Short range only.
    - Most models have limited ammo capacity and are slow to reload.

    1. Better stopping ability than handguns.
    2. Easier to aim than handguns.
    3. Generally less regulation, control, and restrictions than handguns.
    1. Long, difficult to maneuver (carbines less so.)
    2. Many types of rifle rounds are likely to go through the target and several walls.
    3. Most rifle bullets are deadly for a long distance beyond effective aiming range.
    Auxiliary factors:
    - Variety of hunting & target shooting uses.
    - Effective at long range.
    - Removable magazine and clip fed rifles are quick to reload; some have large ammo capacity.
  2. No_Brakes23

    No_Brakes23 Well-Known Member

    I have to disagree with this:
    Unless you are talking about magnum loads, I think the frame of the pistol makes more difference. Every single person that has fired my wife's SIG P232 (.380ACP) and my 1911 (.45ACP) says they feel the 1911 is FAR easier to control. The little SIG is just too light for even the .380, whereas "old slabsides" soaks up a lot of the felt recoil.

    Overall though, good list.
  3. GEM

    GEM Well-Known Member

    Training is more important than the gun.

    A well trained person with a SW Model 10 and 6 rounds is better off than an untrained person with some gun chosen out of technobabble debate.

    A trained person can handle most of the common firearms well. I would rather have my training and a Sig 232 in 380, then no training and a tricked out Benelli shotgun in a home defense situation.

    Just my opinion after reading endless gun discussions. In fact, in many classes the instructors get annoyed with the technobabble from folks who can't hit the target.
  4. Control Group

    Control Group Well-Known Member

    Sure, but a well trained person with a good pump-action shotgun is, at least arguably, better off than a well trained person with that SW Model 10. Just because proficiency is more important than technology doesn't mean that you can't have a discussion about technology. I mean, a well-trained person with an English longbow is more dangerous than an untrained person with an M16, but we can still talk about whether the M16 is a better platform for ground pounders than an English longbow.

    And if the discussion is a precursor to selecting training for home defense, I don't see anything wrong with deciding the platform to train for before going through training. After all, what's the first question everyone asks when someone posts about what first gun to get? "What are you going to use it for?"
  5. El Tejon

    El Tejon Well-Known Member

    The weapon matters very little; you matter very much.

    Let your software guide your hardware selection choices. :)
  6. CAS700850

    CAS700850 Well-Known Member

    And thus, the best weapon to have in a defensive situation is the weapon you are most effective with, be it handgun, rifle, or shotgun.
  7. WT

    WT Well-Known Member

    No one on TFL is an expert in home defense.

    Each person has to decide what is best for themselves given the particular circumstances.
  8. Bobo

    Bobo Well-Known Member

    Whatever you can have at arm's reach at all times!

    Something you can and will carry from room to room all the time.
    Could be something different at night while in bed, but if you move to "another room" during the night take it with you or have something there also.

    Murphy's law says, "a home invasion will happen at the exact time you are unarmed".
  9. hompac

    hompac Member

    Get Serious For Home Defense

    In my opinion for what it's worth, a nice short scattergun would deter any intruder. And if the intruder is persistent IT WOULD STOP HIM or HER (I'm not prejudiced.) Don't worry about ruining the walls, just protect yourself. Just the "bang" will scare the hell out of anyone.
  10. 22-rimfire

    22-rimfire Well-Known Member

    Pretty good list. Best home defense gun is what you already have and can shoot well out to at least the 25 foot target distance. I was wondering what you consider "high power vs low power" in handguns?
  11. LaEscopeta

    LaEscopeta Well-Known Member

    I would arbitrarily set a .38 police special or 9 mm parabellum as about the middle of the handgun power range; low power would be less than that and high power more. IMHO, YMMV, etc.
  12. entropy

    entropy Well-Known Member

    Training is the key. Whichever weapon you choose, practice with it, both at the range and in your home. (Obviously unloaded or with snap caps/dummy rounds) DOn't forget all the other preparations you can do to avoid having to ever test your training; lock the doors and windows at night, (obvious, but many burglaries/robberies start with an unlocked door) create barriers to entry, (motion/timed lights, landscaping) safe area(s) with communications(old deactivated cell phones can still call 911, I keep one for just that purpose, plus usually have the current one handy), and a plan if these fail. Pick whichever weapons best suit your needs, and practice, practice, practice.
  13. Control Group

    Control Group Well-Known Member

    Isn't that exactly the question he's trying to collect information on?
  14. entropy

    entropy Well-Known Member

    El Tejon stated what I meant much more succinctly. The weapon matters much less than training and mindset. La Escopeta laid out the pros and cons of each type rather nicely, but in the end is still the one to make the decision as to which type.

    I'll reprhase; Whichever type you pick, training and mindset will make it much more effective. ;)
  15. Vern Humphrey

    Vern Humphrey Well-Known Member

    The best gun to HAVE is the one you have with you. That's the pistol you routinely wear around the house.

    The best gun to USE is the shotgun.

    Have both. If circumstances allow you to choose which one to use, choose the shotgun.
  16. Black Majik

    Black Majik Well-Known Member

    For purely home defense? I personally would rule out the rifle. Biggest reason is overpenetration.

    Now, the shotgun is probably the best for home defense. Best power delivery at short ranges, and lets face it... the chances of having a full blown shootout in your house are pretty slim. I'd even be comfortable with the standard 4 round magazine for pump/auto shotguns.

    The handgun. Its nice to have around when the shotgun isn't nearby. The sidearm is to fight your way to the long gun. Even then, having a pistol at hand I wouldn't feel underarmed. Again... no need for high capacity magazines. Just something you can reliably hit your target with. And a pistol that is reliable.

    My home defense set up is Remington 870 12 ga. w. a Colt Government. Simple, yet reliable.
  17. CDignition

    CDignition Well-Known Member

    In my opinion, a shotgun is the worst weapon for home defense....just think of a 12 gauge 00 buck round...

    1) they are always high powered,

    2) kick like hell,

    3) make a ton of noise,

    4) can be hard to reload quickly (unless the gun is an auto),

    5) are harder for women to control and use, even with decent training,

    6) they shoot pellets over a large area, especially at intermediate ranges, so these pellets that Dont hit the BG are going somewhere else,

    7) are bulky

    Im sure there is a retort for every thing I have written here, but this is my opinion, and the reasons I dont use one for HD.
  18. entropy

    entropy Well-Known Member


    1. Tactical low powered 00Buck. Or Aguila Mini-Shells.

    2. See response #1

    3. " ""

    4. You rarely need to shoot repeatedly with one.

    5. Ask female LEO's. Or Loral I. Delaney, a noted trapshooter in this area. Or my 11 year old son.

    6. 1" of spread per foot of distance, roughly. How far away can you engage in your house? :eek:

    7. Only for concealment. And before you even think of the 'they'll grab the barrel' copout, consider this;"They say you can’t use a rifle or shotgun indoors because a bad guy will grab the barrel. Yeah? Well, he better hang on, ‘cause I’m gonna light him up and it’ll definitely be an "E" ticket ride." -Clint Smith.
  19. pax

    pax Well-Known Member

    In my opinion and experience, it is dang near impossible to safely keep a long gun accessible enough for home defense in a household with children.

  20. SteveS

    SteveS Well-Known Member

    I agree with Pax. I'd certianly like the option of a shotgun or carbine, but I haven't found a way to store it so that I could get to it quickly. The pistol works great it my home because it is what I have the most practice with and the same holds true for my wife. She isn't as interested in a rifle or a shotgun, so they aren't the best choice. I'd rather have something that we could both use.

Share This Page