1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

If the Ak47 Was Never Invented Would the SKS have taken its Place?

Discussion in 'Rifle Country' started by mr..plow, Nov 26, 2008.

  1. mr..plow

    mr..plow Well-Known Member

    Just for the sake of Disscusion...So please lets keep this civil.

    Say Kalishnkov never invented the famous AK47 do you think the SKS would have taken its place? Say with improvements of a higher capacity magazine and or a detachable 30-rd mag model like the SKS-D taken place of the AK?

    Besides the AK varinets have the Russians produced any other guns that were as famous as the SKS or AK?
  2. 762

    762 Member

    I thought the SKS's design was based on the AK47, what am I missing here?
  3. JImbothefiveth

    JImbothefiveth Well-Known Member

    They could have made it take detachable hi-capacity magazines, and a selector switch, but that would be radically different from the SKS many of us here own. Plus, detachable SKS magazines are known for poor reliability.
    I think they would have been inspired by the m-16, and either copied it or made their own fully-automatic weapon.

    There's the Mosin-Nagant.

    SKS came first, but I don't think the AK was based on it.
    I'd say the AK-47 is out of the SKS's class, for war purposes, with the SKS being more similiar to the Garand.
  4. newdude

    newdude Well-Known Member

    Mosins. While the non gun people don't know as much about them, they are still very well known.
    EDIT: oops, beaten to it....:eek:
  5. nwilliams

    nwilliams Well-Known Member

    Last edited: Nov 26, 2008
  6. HorseSoldier

    HorseSoldier Well-Known Member

    Kalashnikov designed the AK as part of a Soviet competition for an assault rifle design using their intermediate power cartridge. So, if Kalashnikov were not in the picture with the AK design, presumably one of his competitors would have gotten the nod instead. (As it was, features from competing designs were incorporated into the production version of the AK, if I remember correctly.)
  7. Ratshooter

    Ratshooter Well-Known Member

    In one of the gun mags I was reading it was mentioned that the SKS was based on the Russian anti-tank rifle. This SKS was just a scaled down version of the ant-tank rifle.

    The SKS was adopted and put in production just in case the AK was a failure.

    I'm just quoting what I read so no nasty rebuttles please.
  8. SDC

    SDC Well-Known Member

    Highly doubtful; the Russians had already adopted the 7.62x39mm round in 1943 (based on an earlier 7.62x41 round), and their design boards were already concentrating on the "assault rifle" (shturmovy vintovka) theme. Here are a couple of their prototype designs from 1944, from S.B. Monetchikov's "History of Russian Assault Rifles".

    Prilutsky bullpup:




    PS. Both the SKS and PTRS were developed around the same time, from an earlier rifle that Simonov had entered in competition against Tokarev's SVT-40; the Russians had already adopted a gas-operated 14.5mm anti-tank rifle (the Rukavishnikov M1939), but couldn't get it into production because it was too complicated, so they went with two designs that worked and were easy to produce; the PTRS and PTRD.
    Last edited: Nov 26, 2008
  9. Timthinker

    Timthinker Well-Known Member

    HorseSoldier is correct that the Soviet design teams had access to a variety of rifle designs, including the German Sturmgewehr 44. With these facts in mind, it seems probable to conclude that something other than an SKS variant might have been produced. While this conclusion is speculation, it is not uninformed speculation. The AK-47 did not spring into existence uninspired by other rifle designs. That is an important fact to recall when discussing hypothetical questions such as the one posed here.

  10. Autopistola

    Autopistola Well-Known Member

    Nice pics, I've never seen those before and they may be the only such pics on the net. I'd like to know more about that bullpup.
    Last edited: Nov 27, 2008
  11. MAKster

    MAKster Well-Known Member

    The SKS would likely have been the standard rifle into the 1950s but would have ultimately been modified or replaced by a rifle that used detachable magazines. Similar to how the Garand with its enbloc clip was replaced by the M-14 with its detachable magazine.
  12. MisterPX

    MisterPX Well-Known Member

    The Simonov was designed and produced BEFORE the AK.
    Like others have said, if MK had died in his tank, some othter designer's rifle would have been adopted.
  13. WardenWolf

    WardenWolf member

    There were some later SKS models that were manufactured with detachable magazines. And some aftermarket stocks that have a pistol grip. Long story short, the SKS could have done everything the AK did. However, the SKS is a bit heavier due to all that furniture. Russia has never been particularly concerned about weight, though. I think the SKS would have most likely been kept and upgraded.
  14. RP88

    RP88 Well-Known Member

    Kalshinov's entry in the competition didn't look anything like the AK-47 we see. Alot of ideas from other competitors with the STG-44 in model mind was what they were aiming for, and thus were incorporated into the final design.

    IMO, something more similar to Kuzmischeva's designs would have come up if MK didn't submit a design.
  15. elmerfudd

    elmerfudd Well-Known Member

    I don't think so. I suspect the production costs would be too high.
  16. -v-

    -v- Well-Known Member

    Very doubtful that the SKS mod.1945 would have been kept around. From the lessons that the Soviets learning from WW2 on the Eastern Front, they knew that what wins engagements was sheer volume of fire. Heck, that's why towards the end they had entire regiments armed with nothing other then automatic weapons so that they could maximize the volume of fire in an engagement. It is highly doubtful that they would have kept a semi-automatic weapon as their standard issue weapon, as in their eyes it was nearly obsolete when it was first issued. That said, it was seen as a good "bridge" rifle from bolt-action & semi-automatic full power rifles to intermediate-powered assault rifles, and thus was kept in circulation, eventually filling the niche of a PDW for non-front line troops. In all likelihood, if Kalashnikov did not design his famous rifle, it would have been an AT, AD, or AS (Avtomat Tokareva, Avtomat Degatyeva, or Avtomat Siminova) that would have taken its place. Bear in mind that the AVS-36 (Automatic rifle Siminov mod. 1936) was the first general-issue Soviet battle rifle, although a 9lb automatic weapon firing the 7.62x54r round proved to be more practical on paper then it did in the hands of (questionably) trained infantry.
  17. jerkface11

    jerkface11 Well-Known Member

    I like the Kuzmischeva
  18. -v-

    -v- Well-Known Member

    While that is true, like I said, the AK-47 or any possible variants thereof that could have taken its place were designed around the lessons of WW2, with an eye towards WW3 being fought in a similar fashion. The general lesson from WW2 was that if a unit was encircled and not quickly rescued by outside forces, it would be quickly destroyed. The entire eastern front, to a large extent, revolved around this tactic of encirclement and elimination of enemy forces, be it the Battle of Stalingrad, Kursk, the defeat of Army Group Center, or the many battles over Kharkov were all at its core encirclement battles. Even the battle of the bulge was nothing more then the rehash of the standard operating procedure of the eastern front which was encircle the enemy and annihilate him.
  19. SDC

    SDC Well-Known Member

    Autopistola, Monetchikov doesn't go into much detail on the Prilutsky design, but he says that it's a gas-operated design, and he shows a stripped view; it looks as if two tabs on the bolt carrier are used to cam the breech-block up and down to lock/unlock the rifle.

  20. Autopistola

    Autopistola Well-Known Member

    Kewl! Looks like the abandoned bastard child of an AK and an SKS.

Share This Page