1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Is there any poly frame 9mm that recoils as soft as a Hi Power?

Discussion in 'Handguns: Autoloaders' started by Orion8472, Mar 6, 2013.

  1. Orion8472

    Orion8472 New Member

    I was wondering if there are any polymer frame pistols that handle recoil management as well as the Hi Power. Having shot a few, and finding that each of them do quite well, . . . and having shot polymer pistols like the FNP-9, Glock 19, Ruger SR-9, Sprinfield Armory XDM, . . . I detect better recoil management in the Hi Power than them. Is this just going to be the case due to the design of the Hi Power and metal frame, or is there a brand who's polymer frame recoils as well?

    If not, just reply with a "no".
  2. Ankeny

    Ankeny New Member

    Felt recoil is often times pretty subjective. The fit of the gun, bore axis, etc. can all have an effect on the shooter's perception. In my experience, polymer frames have more give and "cushion", thereby reducing the abrupt feeling of being hit in the hand.
  3. bannockburn

    bannockburn Active Member


    I can't really say for sure as I have never really tried a side by side comparison with my Hi-Power and any of my polymer 9mm.s. For me the recoil of the Hi-Power is relatively light given the excellent design and ergonomics at work and its all steel construction. But my Glock 17, Steyr M9, and Ruger SR9c all pretty much exhibit less felt recoil as well, probably due to the physical characteristics of the polymers used in their manufacture.
  4. Wishoot

    Wishoot Active Member

    My CZ SP01 Phantom is pretty soft shooting.
  5. Orion8472

    Orion8472 New Member

    I thought about an SR-9c for carry, actually.
  6. ATLDave

    ATLDave Active Member

    Felt recoil is subjective, as others have said. I find the S&W M&P to be very soft-shooting due to ergonomics that suit me. I have the impression that I can feel the frame flexing slightly at the end of the slide's travel, though I don't know if this is real or illusory.
  7. Wil Terry

    Wil Terry New Member

    AFTER SIXTY YEARS OF SHOOTING I know for a fact now that recoil is 90% between our ears, NOT between our hands. Furthermore, the recoil of every 9MM PARABELLUM pistol I ever shot[ That is pretty much all of 'em..] approximates that of a healthy beer burp. I mean really...C'MON !!
  8. The Lone Haranguer

    The Lone Haranguer New Member

    It's not that there are no differences between individual guns, but 9mm Luger just isn't a heavy-recoiling cartridge to start with.
  9. ATLDave

    ATLDave Active Member

    Of course it's not. But one can shoot a .22 faster than a 9mm because it has even less recoil. And if 9mm recoil were a non-issue, then Steel Challenge shooters wouldn't have comps on their guns in open class.
  10. Stumpknocker

    Stumpknocker New Member

    I have a Bersa BP9cc that handles very well. I like it better than the Glocks, Ruger SR9, and S&W Sigmas I have shot. Not sure how it compares to Hi-power, haven't shot one of those in years.

    ***** yeah, I'm using my phone, big deal *****
  11. 9mmepiphany

    9mmepiphany Moderator

    I've owned 3 Hi-Powers and shot maybe another 3 P-35s, so I feel I have a basis of stating that the S&W M&P9 has milder felt recoil...the M&P40 actually has a bit less felt recoil (action opens later).

    I feel that part of it is visual as the movement of the much lighter Browning slide on the rails in recoil was always a bit disconcerting
  12. Orion8472

    Orion8472 New Member

    Okay, guys. I get what you all are saying. Of the ones I mentioned above in the OP, I thought the SR-9 "felt" the best. I haven't had the priviledge of shooting an M&P9, and would like to.

    I guess I was just really surprised [after having been away from the Hi Power for quite a long time] at the seemingly more manageable recoil it had, . . . even over my steel framed CZ-01.

    I wonder how the CZ FNS-9 would compare?
  13. Gary A

    Gary A Active Member

    My experience is the same, whatever the reason. I do love my Hi Power and I'm really a single-action revolver lover at heart. (I guess, really and increasingly a traditionalist at heart.)
  14. ATLDave

    ATLDave Active Member

    OP, one other thing to consider is that the weight of the recoil spring in the particular pistol can have an effect on percieved recoil. Some people feel a softer spring lowers felt recoil, while others think a stiffer spring does so. Again, it's subjective in many ways, but it may simply be that the HP has a stiffer or softer recoil spring relative to other stuff you're shooting. If the HP is old and has been shot a lot, its spring may have softened a bit, and you may be a soft-spring preferrer. It's possible a different HP wouldn't feel as good, or that another pistol would do just as well for you if you experimented with spring weights.

    There's an interesting blog post on this issue here: http://re-gun.com/2012/02/flatlining-your-gun/
  15. armoredman

    armoredman Active Member

    I could simply chime in and say, yes, my poly framed CZ SP-01 Phantom seems to recoil less than other pistols, but I'd think I'd rather just show you and let you decide.

  16. Girodin

    Girodin New Member

    Felt recoil is subjective. I will say that I find the Steyr M series of guns to be very very soft shooters. I haven't shot it side by side with a hi power. However, it seems to me to be a softer shooter than all the other service sized 9mms I've shot it side by side with (glock, sig, XD, etc). I think the extremely low bore axis may be a big part of the reason for this.

    I have never shot one, but I imagine the Caracal would be similar to the Steyrs.
  17. Orion8472

    Orion8472 New Member

    Good comments guys! :)

    Thanks for the video armoredman.
  18. tuj

    tuj New Member

    I have two 9mm's, a full-steel 5906 and a CZ75-P07 (polymer frame). The P07 definitely has more felt recoil, but through proper grip technique it isn't any harder to tame than the 9mm in the full-steel gun.

    One gun you might try is the PX4; it has a rotating barrel locking mechanism that changes the feel of the recoil. The hi-power has relatively soft recoil because it has a lot of slide mass.
  19. JR24

    JR24 New Member

    For what its worth I think the SR9c has less "felt" recoil than the full size. I think the 9c is similar in recoil to my Hi-Power. Those are my two favorite 9mms to shoot.
  20. Kiln

    Kiln Active Member

    In my experience there isn't a polymer framed gun that recoils as softly as a steel framed gun.

    Steel just seems to absorb recoil better, I'm guessing because of the weight.

Share This Page