Is this the same gun locker?

[Shrinkmd]

I was perusing Sportsmansguide and saw these two items. Are they identical? One is 20 bucks cheaper...

EX8KW-136985 NAHC Pistol and Rifle Locker http://www.sportsmansguide.com/net/cb/cb.aspx?a=428085

WX2-24522 Do - All™ Pistol and Rifle Locker http://www.sportsmansguide.com/net/cb/cb.aspx?a=242225

I have the Do-All, and the NAHC looks identical, comes with a DVD, 6 lbs...is this another SPG screwup, or a good buy?

 

[Bruce333]

They sure look the same to me. One of them is mounted the opposite of the other in the photos (upside down). If you take that in to account they appear to be identical.

 

[GRB]

It could be the same, as many middlemen type companies will buy from the manufacuer and put their name and price on it, then a retailer like Sportsmansguide sells it to you. Could be that 2 different companies did this - one selling it for less. You can bet the one labelled NAHC (North American Hunting Club?) was not manufactured by the NAHC if that is what NAHC stands for. Its just like when SEARs sold guns, they were made by firearms manufacturers not by Sears. So a Marlin, or Savage was sold as a Sears store brand - J.C. Higgins. In this case chances are the NAHC could not get rid of ones they had in stock, and sold the whole lot to SG, who is reselling those cheaper than the others that are in my eye the same.