1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Molon Lave TV

Discussion in 'General Gun Discussions' started by AtoZ, Jun 29, 2003.

  1. AtoZ

    AtoZ Member

    Sorry if I got the spelling wrong. Just noticed the Discovery channel has a two hour show tonight at 9:00 ET on the battle at Thermopylea where Leonidus so succinctly stated how many of us feel. Will be interesting to see how that part is portrayed. Hope some of y'all catch it, too.
  2. Brian Maffei

    Brian Maffei Well-Known Member

    Came here to post the same thing.:)
  3. MonkeyMan

    MonkeyMan Well-Known Member

    No mention of Molon Labe. They did tell the tale of the Spartan that made the comment about "fighting in the shade" when he was told that the Persian archers were so numerous their arrows would darken the sun. Still, not too bad.
  4. Mal H

    Mal H Administrator

    I thought it was pretty good and historically accurate. It showed that the Spartans weren't the good guys all the time. They were very effective and ruthless slave holders for the most part. But when push came to shove, they never bent in their resolution. It's impossible to say with any certainty at all, but we might be speaking a different language today (or at least we would have some different root words) if it weren't for the Spartans (and Thebans and Thespians).

    I was surprised they didn't mention the Molon Labe bit also, I thought maybe I had missed it during a fridge raid or something. After all, the saying is inscribed on Leonidas' statue at Thermopylae so it is certainly considered an important part of the event.
  5. OF

    OF Well-Known Member

    It is a little weird that they didn't mention it... Makes you wonder.

    - Gabe
  6. veloce851

    veloce851 Well-Known Member

    I saw about 2/3rds of it last night.
    I've never studdied the historical accounts so I'm not sure how accurate they were.
    There were some subjects they felt compelled to cover that I wonder about the accuracy.
    I didn't see any mention of Molon Labe
  7. Dave P

    Dave P Well-Known Member

    I lost interest about 1/2 way thru. Of course I also noted the rampant homosexuality encouraged by the Spartan leadership :barf: :barf:
  8. AtoZ

    AtoZ Member

    I can't believe they didn't mention it. I also thought I must of missed it.

    Mal H, have you read What If? Fascinating book that deals with the thought you were touching on. Military historians pondering how minor changes at critical turning points might have changed history. One of'em is the battle of Salamis, which followed Thermopylea. Good stuff that really makes ya think.
  9. only1asterisk

    only1asterisk member

    I too thought I must have missed it. It would appear to be a major omission to commit by oversight.

  10. MicroBalrog

    MicroBalrog member

    And that's wrong?

    Different culture. Homosexuality was perfectly acceptable back than.
  11. Mal H

    Mal H Administrator

    Very true. Guess we better not tell about Alexander the Great or Julius Caesar.
  12. mattd

    mattd Well-Known Member

  13. gun-fucious

    gun-fucious Well-Known Member

    oversight? alot of the show was an interview with Steven Pressman
    They must of cut it out.

    it was a good show but it seemed like they stretched 45 minutes of footage to fill the 2 hours. I must of seen that shot of the back lit spartan by the fire about 6 times
  14. Dr.Rob

    Dr.Rob Moderator Staff Member

    Several things were missing and strangely mis-stated.

    Sparta was an Oligarchy, with an appointed king. No where else in Greece were you more equal than in Sparta. Even women could own property (which was NOT true in Athens) and claim citizenship. They didn't mention the Pelopnesian wars at all (in which Athens and Sparta were enemies.. nor did it mention Sparta's part in The Illiad... which names the Gates of Fire as the Death place of Heracles--remember Helen was the wife of Menelaus--King of Sparta) Usually this sort of colorful background is mentioned in Discovery shows.

    Of course it din't pay to be a Helot. Also, in many paintings and historical data I've seen the Spartans wore thier crests from side to side, rather than front to back (though they did seem to show Lenoidas' helmet like that) And I also thought Leonidas had made the "fight in the shade" comment.

    The Spartan "experiment" in Military Culture only lasted a few hundred years but has had far reaching consequences. Overall I thought the show was pretty good.

    Molon Labe.

Share This Page