1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Poll: Which Rifle

Discussion in 'Rifle Country' started by 68'chevelle, Jul 1, 2007.

  1. 68'chevelle

    68'chevelle Well-Known Member

    Which rifle would you choose?

    M1917 Eddystone
    M1 Garand
    no.4 MK1 Enfield
  2. Alphazulu6

    Alphazulu6 member

    AR-15 Vote for me... but I definitely do not have a "sophisticated opinionated" pallet for service rifles.
  3. DougW

    DougW Well-Known Member

    I have 4 of the 5, so..................
  4. Kaylee

    Kaylee Moderator

    Choose for what?

    An '03 nicely sporterized in the 50's would be my favorite for lookin' on and playing with, followed closely by the M1 and AR. The others.. enh. :)

  5. Srigs

    Srigs Well-Known Member

    An Enfield 2A in 308! :D
  6. Rexster

    Rexster Well-Known Member

    I am a lefty, so that leaves out the bolt rifles, and the ergonomics of the AR15 are truly terrible, the worst of the group, so that leaves the Garand by default. I also happen to really like the Garand and its family and descendants. But then, I, too, have to ask, for what purpose? There is MUCH difference between the .30-06 and the .223/5.56; we are talking apples versus grapes. The AR15 is also in a totally different category of weapon from the bolt rifles, regardless of the cartridge. The Garand is able to perform as a true main battle rifle, and still function as a rapid-fire weapon when shooting-and-moving or shooting-while-moving at close range. Notice I did not use the "a-word" or the even more abhorrent "t-word" here. Given the right task, I might even hold my nose and choose the AR15, but if we are dealing with wide-open possibilities, give me a Garand.
  7. coelacanth

    coelacanth Well-Known Member

    a point of order if I may. . . . .

    Rexster my man, you should really try the old Enfield No.4 before passing judgement on it. Shooting left handed ( on purpose because we are all right handed ) a group of us Enfield nuts were able to sustain a 15 round per minute rate of aimed fire. The target was a white 5 gallon bucket @ about 400 yards. Said target was thoroughly dispatched. We did it just to see if we could and came away from the experience convinced that we were all the proud owners of the finest bolt action battle rifle ever built. BTW - reloads were also performed left handed.
  8. Rexster

    Rexster Well-Known Member

    coelacanth, I agree that the SMLE is not bad at all as a lefty rifle. I will probably get one for myself sooner or later. :)
  9. mukluk

    mukluk Well-Known Member

    Choose for what?

    [​IMG] :evil:
  10. rangerruck

    rangerruck Well-Known Member

    i lke the 1917, since you didn't specify it's usage.
  11. rangerruck

    rangerruck Well-Known Member

    Mukluk.... sinner....
  12. 68'chevelle

    68'chevelle Well-Known Member

    I should say I'm planing on buying a new rifle but don't know which one I want:confused:. Which would you choose?

    M1917 Eddystone
    M1 Garand
    no.4 MK1 Enfield
  13. doubleg

    doubleg Well-Known Member

    I'd take the m1 garand, just because.
  14. RockyMtnTactical

    RockyMtnTactical Well-Known Member

    In general, nothing beats the AR for me. :)
  15. alucard0822

    alucard0822 Well-Known Member

    There are rifles and then there are icons, for me the M1 is at the top of the list.

    The SMLE and AR are both also a blast to shoot, but IMO while not on the list a nice M-14 pattern rifle is probably the most versatile and the mighty mosin is probably the best bang for your buck in mil-surpery
  16. High Planes Drifter

    High Planes Drifter Well-Known Member

    For an adition to the collection and range duty, either an M1903, or an M1, with a slight favor towards the'03. They're getting pricey.
  17. 10-Ring

    10-Ring Well-Known Member

    At this moment, I'd go w/ the Garand -- because its missing from my stable :D
  18. Dirtypacman

    Dirtypacman Well-Known Member

    M1917 Eddystone
    M1 Garand
    no.4 MK1 Enfield

    #1 AR-15 (got one)
    #2 M1 Garand (got one)
    #3 no.4 MK1 Enfield (got one)
    #4/#5 - M1903 or M1917 Eddystone (want them)
  19. mukluk

    mukluk Well-Known Member

    From an availabilty standpoint, the M1917 was produced in the fewest numbers of the rifles you listed and with a large number being sporterized over the years it will be the most difficult to find in decent shape (assuming you are looking for military configuration). They are excellent shooters and thier popularity as a collectable has increased tremendously in the past few years with the prices going nowhere but up. If you plan on gettting all of the rifles on your list at one time or another, I'd highly recommend finding the 1917 first.
  20. 68'chevelle

    68'chevelle Well-Known Member

    I was thinking of getting a M1903 first but now yhat I know that there ain't that many I'm going to buy a M1917 first for sure.

Share This Page