1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Rate your bolt gun.

Discussion in 'Rifle Country' started by Kachok, Jul 31, 2012.

  1. Kachok

    Kachok Well-Known Member

    I thought it would be fun to make a comparison of the bolt guns we have used over the years, score what you did and did not like about yours on a scale of 1-10

    Savage 110 270 win
    Action 5 very clunky but no grit.
    Egronomics 6 Light, compact and handy but never liked the feel in my hands that much. Kind of a bland stock.
    Accuracy 9 Sub-MOA with cheap factory fodder, hard to ask much more then that from a stock lightweight rifle. This was my only Savage that was not picky about bullet selection.
    Trigger 9 The Accutrigger is near the top of the heap, light pull, easily adjustable, no creep, I just don't like the darn inner "blade".
    Reliability 10 Perfect, not one seconds worth of trouble.
    Other 8 Very good finish on the steel for a cheap rifle, great recoil pad, but I hate the internal magazine with a passion!
    Comments: Typical Savage (I have owned 6) very rough around the edges but highly reliable and accurate.

    Remington 700 ADL Synthetic 7mm Rem Mag
    Action 6 Gritty stroke but engaged well.
    Egronomics 5 Cheap flexi plastic stock but it gripped well and fit my pretty good.
    Accuracy 8 Best out of the box Remington I ever owned at the range.
    Trigger 8 The X-Mark was not half bad, presently surprised.
    Reliablity 0 Started rusting the day I took it out of the plastic, after 6mo I questioned if it was still safe to use.
    Other 7 Factory Limbsaver was a nice touch, handled well for a 26" barrel, but poor fit and finish.
    Comments: The corrosion issue was my last straw with Remington, I won't be buying another one..

    Tikka T3 Stainless 6.5x55
    Action 10 the smoothest in the business bar none.
    Egronomics 9 nice and slim with just enough curves, but no synthetic can ever be a ten in my book even a good synthetic.
    Accuracy 10 one hole groups at 100yds it does not get any better then that, shoots everything really well even the cheap stuff.
    Trigger 10 adjustable to 2lbs, no grit whatsoever and breaks clean as glass with zero creep, what more could you ask for?
    Reliability 10 not a single issue.
    Other 7 Factory recoil pad SUCKS, long action bolt even on short action cartrages, and while I am griping a 24" tube would be nice on high speed cartrages (25-06, 270 win) Good Looking gun in stainless, and it comes with rings.
    Comments: Perfect little deer gun; light, handy, no kick, accurate as all getup, and drops them where they stand.

    Winchester 70 Featherweight 308
    Action 10 Super smooth, great feel and it is a CRF!
    Egronomics 10 I cannot say enough about how well designed the Featherweight stock is. Very grippy feel to it.
    Accuracy 7 1 MOA with one type of factory ammo, but others were bad, very picky, have not tried handloads yet stay tuned.
    Trigger 8 Would be a 10 except you have to take the rifle apart to adjust it. No creep or grit
    Reliability 10 It is pretty new but no hint of an issue yet.
    Other 10 Fantastic recoil pad, best internal magazine in the business and it holds five rounds instead of three.
    Comments: Fantastic looking rifle, nice wood with just enough character, top notch fit and finish.
  2. HOOfan_1

    HOOfan_1 Well-Known Member

    Remington 700 BDL .30-06 Circa 1979
    Action 10 - as smooth as greased butter
    Ergonomics 10 - I can't complain
    Accuracy 7 - it is about 2.5-3 MOA, at least before I used Wipe-out bore cleaner...might be better now. Killed a deer at 300 yards so accurate enough.
    Trigger 7- Kind of stiff
    Reliability 10- has never failed to go bang...has never failed to eject spent rounds with authority, has never failed to feed. 33+ years old and not a speck of rust.
    Other 10- It has no recoil pad...just a plastic butt plate I don't need a recoil pad for hunting and I think it looks better this way. The gun is one of the most beautiful I own, right along with its 1100 brother.
    Comment -It was my grandfather's gun, he never got to shoot it in the field. I got its first deer this past season.

    CZ 550 Varmint Laminated Stock
    Action 7- fairly smooth, but the claw doesn't engage the rounds feeding from the magazine...essentially it is a push feed, which is fine, it was designed to drop rounds in the chamber....bolt also rides over the last round in the chamber and causes a jam. Does not eject brass with authority
    Accuracy 10- .5 MOA and below, most accurate rifle I own. I can easily blow off a tennis ball sized groundhog head at 200 yards.
    Trigger 10-Really nice standard trigger...ultra light single set trigger...surprise break city.
    Reliability 7-hasn't failed to go bang, but the feeding and ejecting issues although not a big deal for varmint hunting are kind of frustrating.
    Other 10-beautiful gun, apart from the feeding and ejecting issues, fit and finish are top notch.
    Comment-I might get around to contacting CZ about the issues...but I might ignore them if they want me to send the gun in...I am not sending it with my $700 Bushnell scope.

    Savage 340 .30-30
    Action 7- Not too bad, but it is totally closed...and the opening is too small to eject unfired spitzer bullets. Has had some feeding issues, CLP in the magazine fixed that
    Accuracy 7 - 2-3 MOA has killed deer at 160 yards though.
    Trigger 7- nothing special
    Reliability 8- Goes bang, over 30 years old and rust free
    Other 7-Not too pretty, and requires an odd scope mount

    Savage 340 .225

    Except for accuracy, same as above. I haven't shot it on the range, but pierced both ears of a groundhog at 350 yards with it. Had some neck separations in it...gunsmith eventually ruined it by rechambering it crooked.

    Mauser k98 Sporterized 8x57
    Action 9- More worn in, and thus a bit smoother than the CZ, no feeding or ejecting issues which I know of
    Accuracy 7- 2-3 MOA...has killed deer at 200 yards
    Trigger 7-Nothing special
    Reliability 10-Goes boom, is over 60 years old and no rust
    Other 10- Was a post war Spanish k98 clone...gunsmith ruined the barrel during sporterization and replaced with a Nazi proof mark barrel. Beautiful gun.
  3. meanmrmustard

    meanmrmustard Well-Known Member

    Interarms Mini Mark X .223 Remington
    Action 8- Play in it like any Mauser action, but reliable.
    Ergonomics 8- would be 10, but I'm not partial to the safety.
    Accuracy 10- most accurate rifle I've owned.
    Trigger 8- clean break, wee heavy at four pounds, but it shoots ragged holes.
    Reliability 10- shoots anything lighter than mid 60s grain pills the same, feeds perfectly, no FTFs.
    Other 10- light enough for one handed carry, long enough barrel for accurate off hand shooting, and does tremendous damage to deer and yotes inside 200 yards.

    Winchester M70 Sporter 30/06

    7s all down the line. This gun is meh, and was given to me. I in turn, have recently gifted it to my father, who'd give it 10s.
  4. stubbicatt

    stubbicatt Well-Known Member

    CZ550. I haven't had the feeding problems you describe. Mine is 308, and it feeds very reliably.

    I did have one 10 round CZ magazine which did not work properly. It was exchanged for one which does.
  5. Arkansas Paul

    Arkansas Paul Well-Known Member

    I have limited experience with bolt actions, but have had good ones when I did.

    Weatherby Vanguard .30-06
    Action: 7 Smooth enough.
    Ergonomics: 6 The factory synthetic stock is a little on the blocky side.
    Accuracy: 10 The target that came with it was one hole. I have produced this myself on occasion. Very accurate with a wide variety of bullet weights and loads.
    Trigger: 8 Pretty good. User adjustable.
    Reliability: 10 100%
    Other: 7 My only complaints are that it's a little on the heavy side and I would rather have a detachable magazine.
    Bottom line: An absolute bargain at $390

    Ruger M77 (tang safety) .243
    Action: 8 Great. Very smooth.
    Ergonomics: 9.5 Love it. It's wood and blue and it doesn't get any better than that.
    Accuracy: 10 MOA
    Trigger: 8.5 Very nice.
    Reliability: 10 Hasn't failed yet.
    Other: 9 Love the weight and looks. Would like a detachable mag, but hey, you can't have it all.
  6. jim243

    jim243 Well-Known Member

    This could be a long post.

    Bushmaster Varminter (223) = 8
    PROs: 24 inch flutted barrel, NM chamber, two stage trigger, non-chrome heavy profile barrel, free floated handguard, Sub-MOA accuracy (0.330).
    CONs: Heavy rifle, not a field gun too long.


    Remington 7600 CDL (30-06) = 9
    PROs: Fit and finish excelent, flawless operation, likes factory ammo as well as handloads, accuracy 1.5 MOA, carbine length 18 1/2 inch, excelent open sights.

    CONs: Difficult to find the right scope for it.


    Savage Model 10 (243) = 9.5
    PROs: Light weight (except for the stock), short action, accuracy 0.50 MOA, excelent recoil and recoil pad, easy to hunt with, outstanding Accutrigger no creep and breaks at 2.5 lbs.

    CONs: Internal magazine 4 rounds.


    Savage Model 11 GBT (223) = 10
    PROs: Accuracy of 0.230 MOA, 20 inch non-chromed bull barrel, excelent chamber - throat and rifling, thumbhole stock, Accutrigger set to 1.5 lbs, clean break with no creep.

    CONs: Internal magazine (4 rounds), heavy rifle with laminated stock.


    Savage Model 111 (270 Win) = 8.5
    PROs: Light weight weather proof stock, 22 inch non-chromed barrel, external mags, excelent field gun, accuracy with commercial ammo 1.0 MOA, fit and finish good.

    CONs: Plain looking.


    Well I could keep going on but this would be tooooooo long a post

    Marlin 336c (35 Remington) = 9
    Ruger 10/22 (22 LR) 22 inch stainless rifle = 10
    Bushmaster C-15 Super Lite (223) M4 carbine = 10
    Ruger Mini-30 (7.62x39) = 7
    Marlin tube feed 22 Mag = 9
    Yugo SKS (7.62x39) = 8

    Good Shooting to all.
  7. adelbridge

    adelbridge Well-Known Member

    Browning A-Bolt II Stainless Stalker w Boss

    Trigger 9, adjustable to 3 lbs with no creep but I wish it would go a hair lower but too much to ask from a stock trigger

    Stock 9 comes factory glass bedded and perfect free float

    Action 10, smooth as anything out there

    Accuracy 9, sub MOA gun all day but not sure if the Boss does anything besides muzzle breaking

    Gun is a solid 9 out of ten and about as good as it gets from an off the shelf rifle. Wish it was made in USA.
  8. One_Jackal

    One_Jackal member

    Mosin - Nagant M31/90

    Shoddy construction
    uglier than sin
    weighs 9lb
    I don't care if I tear it up
    fairly accurate
    cheap ammo
  9. Texaszach

    Texaszach Well-Known Member

    Browning a-bolt in .30-06 = 9
    Would have given a 10 if it had a soft recoil pad rather than hard rubber.
    But since it is for hunting I don't mind it when in the field.

    Weatherby vanguard in 243 = 8.5
    I love this gun and it fits me very well. I just wish it had a nicer synthetic stock but it is completely functional so I can't complain.
    If I were to recommend a bolt to someone it's probably this model. Great gun for the price. 399 plus tax is hard to beat for the quality.

    Stevens 200 in 270 win = 7.5
    Accurate as heck and shoots at least descent with anything I've put through it.
    I had to upgrade the trigger but now it's a sweet shooter.
    The steel blueing is sub-par but gets the job done.
    I'll get an aftermarket stock eventually and it'll make it an even nicer hunting rig.
    Great value for 250 bucks plus the 80 dollar trigger!
  10. Kachok

    Kachok Well-Known Member

    Is your Vanguard a series II or the old school Vanguard?
  11. meanmrmustard

    meanmrmustard Well-Known Member

    Hey Jim, pretty gutsy! First rifle rated in a "rate your bolt rifle" thread is a semi.
  12. gp911

    gp911 Well-Known Member

    Moisin-Nagant M44

    Action 6 - Well, it opens and shuts. Doesn't need a 2 x 4 to open the action after a few rounds like some Mosins.
    Ergonomics 7 - Ill-fitting stock with sharp edges and short length of pull plus the kinda-secret safety that requires some serious strength to engage.
    Accuracy 7 - @ 4 moa, hard to tell given the huge fireball though...
    Trigger 7 - Tough. Period.
    Reliability 10 - Always goes bang, and that bayonet is solid enough to do the job.
    Other 10 - For 89 dollars, it cannot be beat. They're $200 now, for once I got in early and got a good deal. Love it.
    Comment - Maybe the last of the cool C & R milsurp rifles?
  13. meanmrmustard

    meanmrmustard Well-Known Member

    Oh, forgot another (feel bad) that I have.

    Smchmidt-Rubin K31 7.5x55 Swiss

    Action 8- still, after owning for a month now, forget its straight pull.
    Ergos 6- heavy, cumbersome, sexy!
    Accuracy 9- pie plate death so far at 300 with irons
    Trigger 10- the best trigger I own, that isn't after market. It's better than those too.
    Reliability 10- come on, it's a BA.
    Other 10- it was beat to hell, stock looked to be chewed upon by an angry beaver, but the bluing, steel, action, bore were all prime. Three days redoing the stock and touch bluing, I have a one of a kind, made for me piece of history, that shoots awesome to boot. It will be in my tree stand come Nov.
  14. WoodchuckAssassin

    WoodchuckAssassin Well-Known Member

    Remington 511-X .22 Scoremaster

    Classically built, beautiful esthetics
    Pin at back of bolt extends when loaded (sort of an early loaded chamber indicator)
    Open sights (just in case)
    It’s a .22, so you can shoot it all day for practically nothing
    So far…none found.

    Remington 788 in 22-250

    Notoriously accurate
    Economical to buy
    Like the 511-X, it has open sights
    Has box magazine (I prefer it, but many will have a different opinion)
    Short action
    Prone to breakage (though I’ve never seen it)
    Unreliable safety (again, not something I’ve experienced)
    Low resale value
    Birch stock instead of walnut (I do prefer walnut)

    All and all, I’m happy with the tradeoffs on both.
  15. 303tom

    303tom member

    All of them ? I don`t have that much time & I don`t type that well, so I will respectfully decline, thanks for asking...................
  16. fireman 9731

    fireman 9731 Well-Known Member

    CZ 527 carbine:
    Action: 8. Mini Mauser style, crf, seems like it was built around the 7.62x39 cartridge. A little rough but it has smoothed out. The way the bolt works there isn't a lot of. Clearance for some scopes.
    Ergonomics: 10. Best handling rifle I have ever laid my hands on.
    Stock: 9 decent walnut with good checkering. Recoil pad is a little too grippy.
    Trigger: 10. Set trigger is great. Regular trigger is great.
    Accuracy:9 I haven't really stretched her legs yet, but groups with cheap steel cased ammo at a hundred yards are close to one inch with a fixed 2x scope. I'm sure hand loads will shrink them.
    Reliability: 7 it has had some feeding issues all due to the magazine I think. I called cz and they wanted me to send the whole rifle in but I didn't want to so I tweaked the mag some and it has been 99% since then.
    Other: it has really good iron sights too. The only con is that magazines are fifty bucks a pop.
  17. -USSR-

    -USSR- Member

    Chinese Type 53
    Action: 9 smoothest Mosin bolt I've ever touched
    Ergonomics: 5 reach from trigger to buttplate is akward and short
    Stock: 3 battered and bruised from BEING USED
    Trigger: 9 best stock Mosin trigger I've ever used
    Accuracy: 5 so far nothing crazy impressive. Hits exactly where I aim though.
    Reliability: 10 it's a Mosin action, I will always fire!
    Other: cheap ammo, cheap rifle, if I can't shoot it or set it on fire I can stab it!

    Mosin Nagant 91/30
    Action: 7 bolt needs more breaking in.
    Ergonomics: 9 with a newer style stock and Bolt it's almost perfect
    Stock: 10 Boyds stock improved reach and comfort
    Trigger: 10 Timney trigger perfected any trigger woes
    Accuracy: 9 sub MOA at 100 yds is good in my book
    Reliability: 10 as said before, a Mosin will rarely fail.
    Other: with a few modern tweaks the Mosin becomes a much better rifle.
  18. Snag

    Snag Well-Known Member

    Ruger M77 Featherweight .243 (Tang Safety)
    Action: 8 Smooth, fast.
    Ergonomics: 10 Fits me perfectly, snaps to the shoulder extremely well.
    Accuracy: 10 It will put holes on top of each other if you do your part.
    Trigger: 9 Glass rod comes to mind.
    Reliability: 9.5 Had some FTF a few years ago, bolt needed thorough cleaning.
    Other: 10 Tang safety ftw, it's right there by your thumb and it has nothing to do with the bolt.
  19. Texaszach

    Texaszach Well-Known Member

    Hey kachok I've got an old school vannie but it's a green synthetic
  20. Is this a centerfire only list? I have several bolt action rimfires.

    Savage 110 30.06
    Action - 6 Very workable but not smooth enough to write home about.
    Ergonomics - 7.5 since I swapped the stock for a Bell & Carlson after the original walnut warped. Now it's light, with a great recoil pad and a solid feel. It was solid but heavy.
    Accuracy - 7 It doesn't have the AT so that limits the accuracy somewhat but I've shot .5 MOA groups at 100 yards with it. Definitely a deer killer.
    Trigger - 5 Nothing to crow about but it gets the job done.
    Reliability - 9.5 I've never had a problem except for the stock warping
    Other - I wish it had the AT. I keep thinking I'll sell this one and get one that does have the AT. But I sure can't beat the price I paid for this rifle. $200 used is hard to beat for what I got.

    Savage 12 LRPV .223
    Action - 10 Left feed, right bolt is a great design for a single shot. I can see where to toss another round in and I can catch brass as it ejects. Plus it is just plain smooth for a push feed. I know that's a problem for some people but I like it.
    Ergonomics - 8.5 Everything about how it feels is fabulous except for the weight involved. This is NOT a brush gun.
    Accuracy - 10 If I told you what it will do you wouldn't believe me so I won't bother.
    Trigger - 10 The target AT is head and shoulders better than the regular AT or the middle grade AT. It will adjust down to ounces but the bolt won't close without kicking the sear block if you go that low. Still it will got plenty low to make the rifle seem like you're just thinking the trigger to engage.
    Reliability - 8.5 Sometimes the brass won't eject well but that's a minor hassle for what this gun is designed to do.
    Other - Overall this gun is in a league of it's own for stock rifles. It's long and it's heavy but it shoots like a dream and does all a varmint gun is supposed to do.

    I can rate my rimfire bolt rifles if you want to hear them. I have a bunch of them.

Share This Page