1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Ruger lcr vs.Vintage j-frame

Discussion in 'Handguns: Revolvers' started by jimbo555, Mar 17, 2012.

  1. jimbo555

    jimbo555 Well-Known Member

    I used to own a very nice model 60 no dash and a no dash model 37.In a weak moment I let them both go to my son and daughter.Should I go for the new technology in the Ruger lcr or shop for another vintage Smith j-frame?
  2. firesky101

    firesky101 Well-Known Member

    I went lcr, but hard to go wrong with those options
  3. sidheshooter

    sidheshooter Well-Known Member

    Funny you should be asking. I rented an LCR at my local range and, while recognizing it as a true advance in revolver design (especially the sweet trigger), I really didn't enjoy it much. It's hard to describe, but it's like there is an S-shaped recoil shockwave that passes through the gun each time it goes off; maybe the frame flexion bothered me.

    By contrast, I was just fondling a vintage 37 3" that is the lightweight twin to my 36-1 today. I'm trying to decide between that one, and another one at a different LGS with the shorter 1 7/8 barrel.

    While I know that the 37s will also be unpleasant to shoot with serious loads, either one will at least be unpleasant in an old familiar way. Plus, the 2" at least, is definitely smaller than the LCR, and that's sort of the point of a flyweight .38. I'm thinking "Barami hip grip errand running gun" for my purposes.

    On the other hand, lots of happy LCR owners to be found both here and elsewhere; far be it for me to begrudge them their choice.
  4. skt239

    skt239 Well-Known Member

    +1. However, if you have not already, give the LCR's trigger a few pulls at the LGS if they have one. I personally like everything about the LCR but the trigger. If you're a J-frame guy, you might not like the trigger on the LCR; in my opinion they are two different animals.

    The LCR also has some big grips. I've tried both the oversized ones and the smaller boot grip, both seemed like they might be a bit bulky and grabby in the pocket. I like my to keep everything as slim and smooth as possible when I pocket carry.

    I don't know if you have considered the S&W Airweights, they are reasonable priced, well made and perfect for carry. They are also rated for +P as many of the vintage revolvers are not. +P capabilities might not be something you are concerned about (I'm not) but it's nice to have the option. The weight is not an issue either; at 15oz they are both easy to carry and shoot.

  5. Gordon

    Gordon Well-Known Member

    "3 " Model 37" Oh MY !
  6. sidheshooter

    sidheshooter Well-Known Member

    ^^^I know, right? (as the kids nowadays say) Plus, it is absolutely minty. They want 5 bills though...

    I told 'em I'd sleep on it.
  7. F-111 John

    F-111 John Well-Known Member

    I'm a softie for Model 60 no dashes.

  8. dscampbell

    dscampbell Well-Known Member

    I am sticking with my model 36. My EDC since 1972.
  9. jimbo555

    jimbo555 Well-Known Member

    Thanks for the replys.I'm going to give the lcr a try.Next question is 38 or 357!;)
  10. shootniron

    shootniron Well-Known Member

    .357...has a little more weight and the option of .357 if your feeling froggy.
  11. Hondo 60

    Hondo 60 Well-Known Member

    My vote is for vintage!
    Gimme steel, wood & leather anytime.

  12. ArchAngelCD

    ArchAngelCD Well-Known Member

    I went with the M442 and carry it daily. Before you decide you might want to take a look at the S&W Bodyguard 38 too. I like it a little better than the LCR.
  13. J frame....
  14. PabloJ

    PabloJ Well-Known Member

    What is remarkable is that short-barreled Six-shot Colt revolver with alloy frame is same as S&W 37. It was not +P rated buy one would not want to shoot those in small light revolver and extra velocity isn't really needed. I have never been a Colt guy, but the old Colt is superior to both guns you have mentioned.
  15. jimbo555

    jimbo555 Well-Known Member

    Pablo I do have a 1993 detective special but it doesnt work as a pocket gun.But your right an agent or cobra would!
  16. Geezer Glide

    Geezer Glide Well-Known Member

    I have fired a friend's LCR and I like the way it shoots and I really like the trigger. Someday, I will probably get one if I can find some small grips for pocket carry. However, nothing beats the looks of an older J frame.
  17. The Lone Haranguer

    The Lone Haranguer Well-Known Member

    If you put better shaped grips on the J-Smith (factory grips on older ones leave you little to hold onto), you will have functionally very similar revolvers.
  18. DocRx

    DocRx Well-Known Member

    I tried both the S&W Airweights and the Ruger LCR several times. Ended up with the Ruger KLCR 357/38. It has the option of 357mag., 38spl., or 38spl.+P., is lightweight (can carry pocket, IWB or OWB), concealabilty, Ruger Quality-reliable, very accurate even at longer distances, has a "sweet" trigger, and fairly priced. JMHO. Take care and be safe.
  19. easyg

    easyg Well-Known Member

    I once carried this...


    but I now carry this...


    Ruger has a real winner with the LCR.
  20. Guillermo

    Guillermo member

    Vintage J Frame is a diminishing resource.

    You can always buy a LCR

Share This Page