1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

What would you like to see in a new revolver design?

Discussion in 'Handguns: Revolvers' started by Colt451985, Mar 19, 2013.

  1. Colt451985

    Colt451985 Member

    Say you own a machine shop with 5-axis CNC machining centers, CNC turning centers, Wire EDM, digital optical comparators, NDT, and so on, and you want your company to get into the firearm industry in a big way. Like any good businessman, you need to find a niche. One potential niche that might exist is custom revolvers.

    By "custom revolver," I mean a revolver design that can be personalized and customized by its owner as easily as the AR-15, 1911, Remington 700, and 10/22. I'm not just talking about swapping a factory barrel and a trigger job. I'm talking about making unique weapons with aftermarket barrels, triggers, hammers, and small parts machined from the highest quality materials.

    In other words, the "Ed Brown" or "Wilson Combat" of revolvers.

    I'm interested in what you folks would like to see introduced in the revolver market. I'm especially interested in what gunsmiths would like to see.
  2. Thaddeus Jones

    Thaddeus Jones Well-Known Member

    A break top 7-shot 357. Blue or stainless. Air guaged 4 inch match grade barrel. 5.5lb trigger. Adjustable sights. :)
  3. golden

    golden Well-Known Member

    I WOULD GO FOR A 10 pound double action trigger

    I like the idea of a top break, but I would add a 5 shot in 9m.m. P or .38 Special +P and keep the weight down with an aluminum or polymer frame.

    I want a 10 pound (MAX) double action trigger and concealed or bobbed hammer. Option of a tritium night sight on the front sight post would be great as well and a 3 inch barrel as well.

    Also, get the trigger right with something similar to the PACHMAYR COMPAC Professional grip.

    A convertible .22 LR and .22 Magnum might be an interesting variation.

    One more would be a .32 H&R Magnum 5 shot with the frame and cylinder scaled down to size instead of using a 6 shot gun that is just as big as the 5 shot .38 Specials.

    Use the FEDERAL Hydro Shok bullet made for the .327 magnum and it just might be a perfect pocket gun.

  4. savit260

    savit260 Well-Known Member

    I think a 5 shot 9mm top break the size of a 38 S&W Safety Hammerless made of modern metal with modern sights. Give it a Charter Arms style ejector star for ejecting the rimless cartridge, and I'd bet you'd sell a ton of them.

    The 9mm chambering could make it shorter and maybe a touch skinnier than the orginal Lemon Squeezer Saftey Hammerless and definitly smaller than a J frame.

    Those already exsist in the works of Bowen, Harton, Stroh, Linebaugh, Reeder etc. etc.

    Ruger single actions being one of the favorites to build off of.
  5. jeffmack

    jeffmack Well-Known Member

    I would like to second what Thaddeus wrote about the top-break 7-shot 357. I also wish somebody would start making revolvers with Dan Wesson Pistol Pac style barrels again.
  6. glider1

    glider1 Member

    Something like the Dan Wesson revolvers but with interchangable cylinders and barrels. 1 revolver that you could have a 45c, 44 spec., or 38 spec. cylinders and barrels for in different lengths. I'd be happy with that. Forget the plastic. You could even offer custom bore cylinders and barrels, kinda like a thompson contender. Sell a high quality revolver and then sell cylinders and barrels for it for the next 10 years.
  7. hovercat

    hovercat Well-Known Member

    Eliminate the crane. Push the release button and a flick of the wrist, cylinder pops out the right side. Snap a new one in from the left, without taking the sights off target. No more speedloaders, spare cylinders. Have to have some sort of clip to hold rounds in place.
    The blackpowder guys used to do similar, but I bet it can be done so that the average Joe or Jane can reload with the ease of a Glock.
    That would be my selling point. The reliability and simplicity of a revolver with the easy reload of a semi-auto.
  8. CraigC

    CraigC Well-Known Member

    Custom single actions based on the Old Model Ruger Blackhawk design, made with Freedom Arms level of precision. Every grip frame imaginable, Ruger Bisley, Colt Bisley, SAA/XR3, 1860 Army, etc.. Every top strap configuration imaginable from Ruger flat-top, Colt flat-top, Keith #5, Seyfried #13, dovetail Single Six, pre-war S&W, Colt 2nd generation SAA, etc.. Round, octagon, ovate and ribbed barrels. Various styles of front sight bases including something sculpted like Jim Stroh's, barrel bands, dovetails, Colt flat-top target style sights. Lightweight conversions. Three frame sizes including something comparable to the Single Six in six shot rimfires, .32H&R and .327Fed, plus five shot .38Spl's and .41Spl's. A medium frame like the Old Model .357 in various chamberings, plus five-shot .44Mag's, .45Colt's, .475Cooper, .50GI and .500Spl (.500S&W at .44Spl length). On the large frame, all the usual chamberings plus five-shot .45Colt, .475Linebaugh, .500Linebaugh, .500 S&W 1.4" and .50Spl.
  9. Dlowe167

    Dlowe167 Well-Known Member

    Glider has the idea. But lighter DA trigger. Revolver triggers are some of the worst. Got a Taurus Raging Judge its a mule of a trigger
  10. Piraticalbob

    Piraticalbob Well-Known Member

    Stainless steel top-break in .22LR with a spur trigger. Larger than a NAA mini-revolver, but smaller than a J-Frame. Would make a great backcountry kit gun.
  11. AFDavis11

    AFDavis11 Well-Known Member

    I have a weird niche interest based on a comment I read a few decades ago. I would be interested in an aluminum framed, 4 shot, revolver. One in 45acp or 44 Spec and one in .38 Spec.

    Probably with a high vis front sight.

    To me it would be the ultimate in reliable back-up/deep concealment.
  12. wvtarheel

    wvtarheel New Member

    Interchangeable barrel length revolvers. I believe Dan Wesson did something like this in the 70s. I would love to have a 357 with a 6 inch barrel for target shooting and a snubbie barrel in case I want to carry it.

    I have also heard the rumor, that something about the way the interchangable barrels were constructed, and the way they were threaded, increased accuracy tremendously, a benefit that Wesson did not intend but took full credit for. I heard that talking to some old guys that shot competition in the late 1970s. Apparently when the Dan Wesson revolvers started showing up everyone was looking at them like they were dogs, with all their crazy features (interchangable barrel length) and super heavy frames. Then the Dan Wesson revolvers started winning competitions....

    Just my two cents
  13. Cosmoline

    Cosmoline Well-Known Member

    My dream has always been a Speed Six in .44 Special. A few have been constructed over the years, but never mass produced. But the devil is in the details, and quality revolvers are not easy to make.
  14. oneounceload

    oneounceload member

    As a LH, I would like to see an ambidextrous revolver- think like the semi HK P7 - with cylinder that could open either way for RH or LH shooters with the release in the same vein. It should have swappable barrels so you could lengthen or shorten - think Dan Wesson - and swappable cylinders - think Ruger, in centerfire rounds like 38, 9mm, 40, 45ACP, etc.......
  15. savit260

    savit260 Well-Known Member


    Kind of like saying "Motorcycles handle the worst. Got a H-D Fat Boy and it corners like dump truck." lol

    Give a "good one" a try.
  16. Cosmoline

    Cosmoline Well-Known Member

    I think if you're looking to customize you'd need to explore polymer frames like the LCR. A modular revolver like the old Dan Wesson's, but with the entire cylinder/barrel assembly as a modular upper to the lower with the trigger group, hammer and grip.

    Tough to do right, maybe too tough. But if it could be done it would be pretty sweet.

    BADUNAME2 Well-Known Member

    Webley that works

    A modern top-break .45 ACP, that accepts moonclips. The GI bring-back Webleys have one of the niftiest reloads in the revolver world. Press lever, snap gun down to belt, gun opens and ejects, while you grab another moon. Drop in, snap up, fire. Rinse, repeat. Just make one that works, has a nice trigger, modern sights, etc. Give it just a stud to attach grips to, a la the Super Redhawk, that way people can make any grip they like to put on it.
  18. Colt451985

    Colt451985 Member

    I respectfully disagree. While these gentlemen are true craftsmen, they are limited to modifying mass produced revolvers made by Smith & Wesson, Ruger, Colt, and so on. They generally do not machine their own parts for their revolvers. In comparison, Ed Brown and Wilson Combat machine all of their own parts for their 1911s. I believe there is a niche for an "Ed Brown" or "Wilson Combat" of revolvers that machines all of their own parts for a new revolver design that can be personalized and customized to its users taste, wants, and needs.
  19. theboyscout

    theboyscout Well-Known Member

    I like the idea of one revolver that can shoot the 45c, 44 spec., or 357 (so it can shoot the 357 and 38 spec).
    The other post I thought was good 7-shot 357 or a 7-shot 44
  20. Nickel Plated

    Nickel Plated Well-Known Member

    In theory a 9mm chambering would give you a shorter revolver. In reality, you can only make the revolver so short before the cylinder gap is sitting right over your trigger finger. not a good place for it to be.
    Why do you think all the 9mm revolvers made to date have had essentially 38spl.-length cylinders that are quite a bit longer than they need to be.

Share This Page