1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

XD or Glock 9mm

Discussion in 'Handguns: Autoloaders' started by alwayswithmyp11, Feb 8, 2009.

  1. My CC gun is a Kel Tec P11 and I'd like to get a larger gun for the range as I cannot go to the range with just a Kel Tec lol.

    I'd like to stick with 9mm so I only have to buy one caliber I can stock up on.

    I'm really looking hard at an Springfield XD-9 and Glock 17. They seem to be the most gun for the buck I can find in the $500 and less range.

    Problem is I cannot make up my mind, and I'd like to hear input from people who have owned or own these guns.

    Thanks for your help, and if you have a 9mm your looking to get rid of, email me at loudandlow@gmail.com

    Thanks guys!!!
  2. jc650

    jc650 Well-Known Member

    They are both good guns. No one can tell you for sure because what is comfortable for one person may not be for another. In short handle both and decide from there. Glocks fit me well so thats what I like but those SA's are pretty good too. Good luck.
  3. twoclones

    twoclones Well-Known Member

    When shopping for an auto loader, I picked up a Glock and raised it like I was going to fire it. Then did the same with an XD and that was all I had to know. For me, the XD pointed where I was looking and the Glock pointed way high.

    Buy what feels good in your hand.
  4. 9mmepiphany

    9mmepiphany Moderator

    the grip angle is the most noticeable difference when shooting. some folks just can't get used to one or the other.

    i'm actually most comfortable with the shorter Glock (19 fits my hand better) and the longer XD (tactical balances better)

    additionally the XD has a mag release on both sides of the frame and i find the takedown lever easier to use. if you get the XDm model, it has the interchangeable backstraps and match barrel
  5. louie19

    louie19 Well-Known Member

    Why would you be ashamed of your carry Kel-Tec? If it works for you, just bring it. Plus I would want to practice with whatever gun I carry.

    That being said, if you're looking for a Glock, get a G26. It is the closest in size to your P11 and uses the same ammo. If you want a Glock you can get your pinky on, then get the G19.

    With the XD, you'll introduce the grip safety which doesn't exist on your P11.
  6. viperstarbuck

    viperstarbuck Well-Known Member

    Both are great and fairly similar. It'll depend on preference on things like grip angle and grip safety. Find out which pistol fells better in your hand. I have shot both and carry the Glock, and i would take either anywhere.
  7. possum

    possum Well-Known Member

    they are both great, really it comes down to what ever you like best. my xd has over 12000rds through it, and i couldn't be happier, i have a glock 23, and though it is a fine handgun, i would take the xd over the glock.
  8. phantomak47

    phantomak47 Well-Known Member

    Xd XD Xd XD, compare both of them, you will pick the XD.
  9. Quack

    Quack Well-Known Member

    see if a range near you rent them & try them out. i tried to like the XD 3 different times. sold them because i like my Glocks better.

    that being said, i sold most of my glocks and bought 1911s.
  10. wow6599

    wow6599 Well-Known Member

    IMHO, the S&W M&P9 is a better gun than a Glock or XD, and it's made in America by Americans - not in Austria or Croatia. The M&P line is the only "plastic fantastic" gun line I REALLY like. I also have a Kel-Tec P11 for my CCW, and it a darn good gun for that.
  11. fxstchewy

    fxstchewy Well-Known Member

    I like my XD service for the range but i like my G26 for carry over the XD9 or XDSC9.
  12. stogiegila

    stogiegila Well-Known Member

    I started off wanting a Glock, (G19 to be exact), but once I saw the XD and felt it, and saw all the extras (i.e.grip safety, round indicator etc). I went with the XD. After shooting it for a while, I sold it for the G19. I discovered that I shot the Glock much better. The XD has a lot of muzzle flip, too much so for my liking and the Glock seemed easier to handle and I was shooting much more accurately.

    I later sold the G19 for a G26, which is better suited for my daily carry. I would recommend the G19 to anyone. But if you are trying to decide between the two, I strongly recommend renting each at a range and comparing. The XD felt great in my hand, until I actually shot it. Also the G19 is a gun that can be CCW'd ( I just like the G26 better).
  13. PhillyGlocker

    PhillyGlocker Well-Known Member

    Get a G19 or G26. Don't be lured away to purchase a Glock copy. Get the original.
  14. tbraddy

    tbraddy Active Member

    The best advice given yet: try both and see which one you like the best. The same engineer designed both pistols. I have a most anal friend who just sold his Glock for an XD. He says it fits his hand better, and he feels more comfortable with it. Both are stone reliable, get the one that fits.
  15. tbraddy

    tbraddy Active Member

    And, by all means, practice with your Kel-Tec. Know it well if it's your CCW.
  16. onebigelf

    onebigelf Well-Known Member

    The Glock has a history. There are plenty of years of use, plenty of examples of them shooting hundreds of thousands of rounds. Of all the things that can be said about the XD or the S&W M&P, that isn't one of them.

  17. FreuderLocks

    FreuderLocks Well-Known Member

    I just sold a Glock for an XD, a 9mm, and for accuracy sake (i cant say for reliability yet) I will NEVER go back. Just from my experience shooting out of the box.
    FL=Sold on SA XDM
  18. haha, thanks guys, the posts go


    It's great. Well I took your advise and went and shot them both. I almost threw the G17, hated how it felt in my hand, but the it kicked at least 1/2 as hard as the XD9.

    I did like the way the XD9 felt in my hand better, but hated the kick and my accuracy was better w/ the Glock.

    Couldn't make up my mind, so I tried a Glock 19... I think that's the one!!

    Now... WHO HAS A G19 FOR SALE?!?!?!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  19. Hanafuda

    Hanafuda Well-Known Member

    Don't overlook the Smith M&P. Just sayin'.
  20. WaltherPPK

    WaltherPPK Member

    Both are great guns. But, my suggestion is to try the new XDm in 9mm.

Share This Page