Big Bill keps talking me out of the 44.
Sorry for that my friend. I just wanted you to be aware of some of the limitations of the .44 Marlin.
Greyling is correct. If you don't mind the .44 Marlin's slow twist rate of 1:38 then you should get one. However, if recoil is a problem with the .44 Mag, then perhaps you should get a .357 Marlin instead. The twist rate of the Marlin .357 is 1:19, so you don't have to worry about what you shoot in it either.
BTW, Marlin does make the 336 SS which is stainless, and is a 30-30, and looks great. If you need the gun for home defense or self defense in a short range situation, then the .357 1894 Marlin would be a great choice, especially if you use a .357 revolver.
However, if you want a nice hunting gun in stainless steel that you can use for longer range hunting and pass down to your heirs, then perhaps the Marlin 336SS is the way to go.
http://www.marlinfirearms.com/Firearms/centerfire/336SS.asp
Beautiful isn't it? And, It has a 1:10 twist rate.
I have killed everything from deer to elk with my old Winchester 30-30, and like the round for hunting. I wouldn't feel under-gunned with a 30-30 for bear or for a self defense round. But, I'd never shoot one at an intruder inside my home. There would be just too much penetration. And, since recoil isn't a problem for me, I could care less about it in regard to my rifles. BTW, my standard hunting rifle is a .300 WSM.
I'm an old codger who lives in Idaho and have used practically ever caliber out there. We have lots of long range hunting here. I killed my first deer when I was 12 YO with my Winchester 94 (pre 64) 30-30 and hunted exclusively with it till I was 25. So, I'm prejudiced to the 30-30. I still have that old gun.
I wish you the best. I'm sorry if I just clouded the issue for ya. But, I've found it helpful, before I buy a gun, to research it as best as I can before I buy. Then, I'm less likely to be disappointed and won't get rid of the gun in a hurry just because I don't like something about it. And, instead of buying your gun locally and paying two times the price, I'd do some price comparisons. At the very least, knowing the real market value will help you negotiate when you go to buy the gun of your choice.
Thanks - Bill
PS - BTW, IMHO, stainless is harder to keep clean than a regular blued gun.
PPSS - I wouldn't worry so much about the ammo differences. What if you buy a rifle and handgun that uses the same ammo and then they quit making it? The old timers didn't worry that much about it and neither should you. Having a pistol cartridge rifle is a nice concept in theory, but perhaps not so smart in actual practice. Remember that a pistol is what you use to fight your way to your rifle. What sense does that make if your rifle is also a PISTOL?