Compact 9mm decision

Status
Not open for further replies.
As between those, one big question is striker vs DA/SA. As I mentioned, I am used to DA/SA, but am not opposed to considering a striker fire.
I also prefere DA/SA pistols with decocker only system because they are always ready to fire and they have a second strike capability which in my opinion is important. For a subcompact pistol in my case it would be one of these:
Walther P99c AS (first option because it can accept 15 rounds P99 magazines with a nice magazine spacer);
HK P2000SK V3 (second option only because of the price. It can also accept P2000 magazines with a nice spacer);
HK P30SK V3 (maybe you can also use P30 magazines with a spacer, I don't know);
Beretta Px4 Compact G.
 
Last edited:
Don't leave out the XD mod 2 if thinking of going a bit smaller. Great shooting sub compact with 13+ 1 capacity with flush mag. Quite impressed with. I have an LC9s and P01 also, but the XD is almost always on my hip. Extremely versatile. Plus love the red fiber optic front sight.
 
high country

One of the reasons I went with the Ruger SR9c is after trying out a number of compact, striker fired 9mm.s I found the Ruger had the best (at least to me), trigger pull right out of the box. Likewise I have had several DA/SA guns in the past and found that SIG and CZ have for the most part some fairly decent triggers on them, especially in the DA mode. The sights on the SR9c and the CZ P01 were also important to me as I found them both to be very easy and quick to acquire and pretty much shot to the POA first time out. You might want to also consider the ergonomics of the pistols you're looking at to see if they feel comfortable in your hand, if they balance properly, and if they're relatively easy and intuitive for you to use.

cGcSMTn.jpg

e8hN1ak.jpg
 
HK P2000SK V3 (second option only because of the price. It can also accept P2000 magazines with a nice spacer);

This. ^

You won't be disappointed.
 
Take a look at the HK P30SK V3. I got one a couple months ago and like it.

The decocker on the rear of the slide is a nice touch. The paddle magazine release takes a bit of getting use to.
 
I was in the same boat. Prefer DA/SA, decockers, and metal frames. But when I looked for a new carry gun, my focuses were slim, points well, and just plain works.
So far the SR9c has fulfilled that.
So don't rule the 'modernized' stuff out. But if you do find something that works just as well in the old preferences, I'll be looking forward to hearing about it. It'll go onto my list of stuff to look at, too.
 
Armored farmer

I immediately liked the ergonomics of the gun when the guy shooting next to me at the range asked me to try it out. Seems he was struggling to get a decent group on paper and wanted to know if it was him or the gun. I put all 5 rounds in the black at 30'. Good enough for me! I also liked the sights, trigger, manual safety, and the 17 round spare mag for home defense/range use.
 
I put all 5 rounds in the black at 30'. Good enough for me! I also liked the sights, trigger, manual safety, and the 17 round spare mag for home defense/range use.

Similar for me. My son bought one. I couldn' miss with it. He got on his 1911kick and was going to trade it. I told him I would give him the trade in value, then he could have the gun back in 30 years.
 
I have a Ruger SR9c, and a S&W Shield. They are kind of two different animals, and not really comparable. I love the Ruger, and with the extended mag it lives in the night stand. Generally I shoot it better. Yesterday I could use the Shield to outshoot the SR9c every time. :) who knows why ?
The Ruger is more of a home protection weapon nowadays, but I have carried it and can conceal it no problem. The Shield is my carry weapon now. No other reason other than size and it allows me more clothing options. Both very dependable.

-Jeff
 
Last edited:
I managed to spend some time in a couple of shops handling some of these numerous options (CZ75, 75 compact, SP9c, Glock 26 and 19, and an 1911 for comparisons sake).

- I still haven't warmed up the feel of polymer framed guns. I get why they are popular, I want to like them, but I have not found one that feels great in my hand. Some feel good (the SR9c for example), but none feel great. I have a medium-large hand, with long fingers, so the narrow, long profile of the CZ and 1911 fit me better. The P89 is a bit of an exception to that with the houge grips, but that is both wide and long, and almost too big. The huge grip on that thing is one of the main reasons that concealing it would be challenging.

- Subcompact is probably out. I want the frame to have enough room for my little finger without it dangling on the end. The extensions for the SR9c or G26 make it feel like an almost full size length grip, but I will never practice with either of those without the extension enough that I would carry them without the extension. Since I will never use it without the extension, I would rather have that real estate be part of the frame rather than a spacer.

- Even though the CZ75B is as big as the P89 on paper, it is no where near the size. The CZ is thin like a 1911. I could probably just about CC a 75b with a thin set of grips installed. I think that the CZ75 compact would conceal nicely on a person of my size (6'1", 200lbs). What a great feeling little gun, it just fits into my hand like it grew there. The compact fit better then the 75b actually.

I am not marking anything off the list yet though. A range near me has a CZ75b (not a compact though), SR9c, glock 19 (just to give subcompact and poly one more go), and a 9mm 1911 (for comparison). I am going to go shoot those to see if that gives me any more clarity, but I am narrowing in on that CZ compact or PCR I think. I want to shoot the 75b without the decocker to see how I feel about that. I lower the hammer on live rounds with the thumb of my shooting hand with the GP fairly often if I cocked it to shoot SA, but then changed my mind, so I am used to doing that safely. I use the decocker on the P89 since it is there, but the DA/SA compact might be an option, I understand that the decocker on the CZ makes the trigger a bit more complicated to smooth out if needed (the trigger being probably the most common complaint about them).

Thanks again everyone for the very helpful input!
 
CZ Compact D, or a it's lighter weight brother the PCR, seem like good options for your criteria as has been said by others.
 
Since you are drifting towards CZ,. There are three basic options in the compact size. The steel framed compact with a safety and no rail. A PCR with alloy frame, no rail and a decocker. Or a P-01, alloy frame, decocker and has a rail. All three are excellent choices.
 
No love for RAMI? I wonder why. I never carried one, is there a problem with the smallest CZ?
 
image.jpg For ccw the P01 or PCR is way to go. The heavier steel 75b compact never made sense to me. I highly recommend a set of Cajun Gun Works thin aluminum grips too. Very slimming for carry.
 
I had a Rami and didn’t care for. Kinda bulky for what it is and only having 10+1. The nail in the coffin though was mags liked to rattle when carrying. Don’t need that kinda noise when carrying.
 
The metal ones certainly aren't cheap. I know you can't find any to hold but a full steel tanfoglio wonder finish large frame compact would be a quality piece to have. I was checking earlier and they are over 500 usd now, mags 30usd each. Only thinking about that now because I brought my 10mm with 40 barrel to the range today. At 7 yards I'm far better with this pistol than any of my carry pistols. Trigger is excellent, sights are excellent. It's clearly heavier than my hk usp 40 compact which is itself no lightweight. But it is all steel...
 
New Ruger Security nine, double stack about the size of a G19 and only $309. Or Ruger E9S, single stack striker for $229. For me, I will stick with my Shield or my oooold 39-2.
 
One thing about the metal framed hammer fired double stack compacts, get them while they're still being made new. Even CZ appears to be drifting into polymer pistol land.

It isn't just CZ. Sig is going there also. I would think the last holdout would be single stack 1911's but now we have Ed Brown testing the market with polymer frames.

http://www.edbrown.com/zev/

The end is near.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top