98s1lightning said:
I carry a different gun NOT chambered up front, appendix, I'm too worried that no matter how much training, it's too easy to make a mistake on a draw if in a life or death situation when you needed it. I'd rather take the chance on one extra second to rack one then either living the rest of my life with no man parts or ending my own by accident.
The underlying assumption with your current carry method is 1)
you are by yourself and you're not going to have to guide a companion out of harm's way, 2)
your attacker will give you the time needed to draw your weapon and rack the slide, and 3)
you will have both hands free to rack that slide -- and won't be using one of your hands to block a blow from your attacker if he or she has a club or knife.
This discussion assumes that your attacker has a knife, club, or is a brawler; if your attacker has a firearm, your only hope is that something will distract him/her so that you can go for your weapon.
You are rightly concerned about mistakes made during the draw (using appendix carry),
but seem unconcerned about the time and effort required to make your weapon ready for action!
Someone coming at you from 20-21 feet away can be on you before you can draw your weapon and chamber a round, and this assumes you are aware that an attack is coming! (If your attacker has a firearm, he or she already has a nearly insurmountable advantage.
A test! Ask a friend to help you evaluate your response time.
- You start with an empty chamber, and an empty magazine holding only a snap cap or two, with the weapon carried as you described it above.
- Let your friend start from about 20' -22' in front of you, with you starting your draw as soon as he starts to move toward you (as quickly as he can). He can fake a blow, or work to keep you from getting your weapon out and ready for use.
Keep in mind, too, that this isn't really a true test, because YOU already KNOW an attack is coming.
Having a chambered round in a small semi-auto pocket pistol would certainly reduce the "get ready" time considerably, and it would also let you use your weak hand to protect yourself from someone attacking your physically with knife or club.
I'd argue that your current carry practice, cited above, is a bit like having medical insurance from a company that went out of business: its just as good as any other medical insurance UNTIL you need it.