Are BP substitutes very popular at shoots ? In the field ? Are there any reliable breakdowns/statistics as to what % of “black powder” shooters use real BP and what % use substitutes ?
I compete in North South Skirmish Association with Civil War era guns including artillery. Our competition rules do not allow the use of any substitute. AFAIK, we are one of the largest, nongovernmental organized consumers of black powder in the US in terms of quantity used. Most reenactor units use black powder, but they aren't picky about quality as all they want is a bang and smoke. We are interested in accuracy with live rounds on target. SASS guys can use subs and since they're an analogue to 3gun, accuracy isn't on the top of their list. So as such, there are grades of black powder, just as there are for smokeless. Ranked in order from very best to crap-
1)Swiss (very consistent, minimal fouling)
2)Old Eysnford (Goex product) (almost as good as Swiss)
3) regular Schutzen and Goex (decent stuff for 90% of bp shooting, hunting and plinking)
4) Goex reenactor grade (crap suitable only for blanks)
(There are some others but they fit in about in the #3 area of the rankings. Serious target shooters and those after accuracy are using Swiss and Old E almost exclusively)
Our usage spans revolvers, rifled muskets, smoothbore muskets, carbines, repeaters (Henry, Spencer), cannon and mortars. Back Creek is located at the exit to our main range in Winchester, VA.