Best Sporting, Target Shooting and Possible Self Defense Handgun: Episode2 S&W Mountain Gun 45 Colt
- Thread starter Mr.Revolverguy
- Start date
- Status
OP
OP
Mr.Revolverguy
Member
- Joined
- Feb 24, 2007
- Messages
- 1,881
Sexy 10MM with the different grips
They're from Altamont, they're the same as the factory Lett grips Ruger used to put on the 3" guns.
Pat Riot
Contributing Member
@Mr.Revolverguy
Your times with the 625 look better than your times with the 686. Nice!
Thanks for stating the load for the .45 Colt at 900 FPS. That is not a “wimp load”. I shoot a similar load in CAS. 205 grain lead RNFP over 7.7 grains of Universal which mathematically comes out to around 900 FPS. I don’t have a chronograph.
Question; Do you think the weights of the barrels with under lugs make the timing difference better on the 625 over the 686?
I would think with the heavier recoil the 625 would be slower. Your times do not reflect that.
Thanks for the second video. Well done.
Your times with the 625 look better than your times with the 686. Nice!
Thanks for stating the load for the .45 Colt at 900 FPS. That is not a “wimp load”. I shoot a similar load in CAS. 205 grain lead RNFP over 7.7 grains of Universal which mathematically comes out to around 900 FPS. I don’t have a chronograph.
Question; Do you think the weights of the barrels with under lugs make the timing difference better on the 625 over the 686?
I would think with the heavier recoil the 625 would be slower. Your times do not reflect that.
Thanks for the second video. Well done.
OP
OP
Mr.Revolverguy
Member
- Joined
- Feb 24, 2007
- Messages
- 1,881
My time was better with the 625 I really think that is because of how th grips feel in my hand, I really feel at one with it. May sound corny but it just feels more natural, I bet the same grips on the 686 might make me a tad faster and of course I can always use more practice with both. That was really my first time shooting the 625 also by the way.
halfmoonclip
Member
- Joined
- Feb 4, 2011
- Messages
- 2,755
I'd love to find a Mountain Gun in .45 Colt; have some 625s in .45 ACP.
The best Mountain Gun story ever; two Norwegians were skiing to the North Pole with a handdrawn sled; they kept everything light. They were stalked for two days by a polar bear; when the moment of truth came, one guy killed the bear with a .44 Mountain Gun, while the other took pictures of the event.
There would have been no second place trophy in that deal.
Moon
The best Mountain Gun story ever; two Norwegians were skiing to the North Pole with a handdrawn sled; they kept everything light. They were stalked for two days by a polar bear; when the moment of truth came, one guy killed the bear with a .44 Mountain Gun, while the other took pictures of the event.
There would have been no second place trophy in that deal.
Moon
RJM52
Member
- Joined
- Mar 6, 2006
- Messages
- 225
The Mountain Gun Series from S&W has to be the best thing they ever came up with for an "all-around" handgun. Balance is perfect, the round butt frame can be made to fit all sizes of hands...
My favorite is the .41 Magnum but to me the the best all-around caliber for the series is the .45 ACP. I've owned three of them and made the mistake of selling off the last one after buying a 5" 625-7 PC.
The 625 MG will run standard .45 ACP, +P and .45 Super. I spoke to one of the tecs at Buffalo Bore who said they have a bunch of customers who shoot the Super in their 625s. He also does in his gun. Since these loads run a 255 grain hardcast over 1000 fps whatelse does one need for the woods...
Bob
My favorite is the .41 Magnum but to me the the best all-around caliber for the series is the .45 ACP. I've owned three of them and made the mistake of selling off the last one after buying a 5" 625-7 PC.
The 625 MG will run standard .45 ACP, +P and .45 Super. I spoke to one of the tecs at Buffalo Bore who said they have a bunch of customers who shoot the Super in their 625s. He also does in his gun. Since these loads run a 255 grain hardcast over 1000 fps whatelse does one need for the woods...
Bob
Mr. Mosin
Member
- Joined
- Jun 26, 2019
- Messages
- 2,109
Something without moon clips, with cartridges that can be loaded singly of necessary.
halfmoonclip
Member
- Joined
- Feb 4, 2011
- Messages
- 2,755
Hey RMJ52, the .45 Super has a longer cartridge, yes? How does that work; regular .45 ACPs need moon clips to work?
How does the 625 MG differ from the regular 625? I'm a big 625 fan, but it's a new one to me.
Thnx,
Moon
How does the 625 MG differ from the regular 625? I'm a big 625 fan, but it's a new one to me.
Thnx,
Moon
OP
OP
Mr.Revolverguy
Member
- Joined
- Feb 24, 2007
- Messages
- 1,881
45 super is the same length cartridge http://www.dayattherange.com/?p=5966 Here is what Starline brass has to say about their 45 Super cases. “45 Super* is the same externally as the 45 Auto, but has a thicker web, denser grain structure in the metal, and special heat treat process that enhances the durability of the case. Similar internal capacity as the 45 Auto.
RJM52
Member
- Joined
- Mar 6, 2006
- Messages
- 225
Mr. Mosin...both .45 ACP/Super and .45 Auto Rim can be loaded singly if needed. With the ACP and Super cases one would just pull them out one at a time...
As to the Mountain Gun...it has a tapered barrel vs. the 1989 which has a full underlug...much better balance to me...
As to the Mountain Gun...it has a tapered barrel vs. the 1989 which has a full underlug...much better balance to me...
Mr. Mosin
Member
- Joined
- Jun 26, 2019
- Messages
- 2,109
You missed my point.
On the other hand - there's the Inuit..they keep weight down my packing a .22 magnum rifle & yes - they take polar bear with it. :O
Inuits have big (frozen) ones that clang - or would if they weren't frozen.
I. on the other hand, don't clang - I pack a S&W M69 snub & just shake my head in wonder at those crazy Inuit..
Vern Humphrey
Member
No. The .45 Colt has a huge advantage in case capacity.
In the millisecond before the bullet starts to move, the gas expands to fill the case, which allows more powder to be burned safely in a large case than in a small case. Then as the bullet starts to move, the larger volume of powder produces more gas and drives the bullet faster than a small volume case could with safety.
I think a number of us did...
I believe Mr. Moisin was alluding to the idea that in a stressful situation, one should be able to extract empty cases from a double action revolver and reload with cartridges.
Not something I would attempt to do.
Kevin
phonesysphonesys
Member
I have a MG in .44 mag. It has become my field gun. It doesn't matter what the weather is it can't be hurt. I can load it up or down. Shot some Buffalo Bore hard cast in it man are the hot!
For me, both the 45 ACP and 45 Colt get it done at 0 to 50 yards.
I practice a lot at 100 yards with a 45 ACP to make sure I can get it done at 50. When I hit the clay pigeon on the berm at 100, I’m proud because it’s not easy.
I always get it done at 100 yards with the 45 Colt. When I hit the clay pigeon on the berm, I expected to hit it. 6” or 4” Mountain gun, the expectation is still the same.
I practice a lot at 100 yards with a 45 ACP to make sure I can get it done at 50. When I hit the clay pigeon on the berm at 100, I’m proud because it’s not easy.
I always get it done at 100 yards with the 45 Colt. When I hit the clay pigeon on the berm, I expected to hit it. 6” or 4” Mountain gun, the expectation is still the same.
- Status
