I know plenty of people that can shoot great with a scope, but can’t hit something past 50 yard with iron sights.
Iron-sights would be my only weakness in this scenario. My eyes suck for shooting irons, so I don’t
I know MY effective range with either cartridge is EXCEPTIONALLY limited by mil-spec ammo and iron sights.
In my first response in this thread, I pointed out my limited ability with irons, which I remain to protest here, but pointed to ONE simple parameter change which easily doubles what I would expect for my “effective range”.
Just take a 20” AR to the range and see how good you can shoot using the same standards we’ve listed in this topic, Army, or Marine Corps.
Achieving 500 feels a lot more like a “standard expectation” rather than a “maximum limit.” It’s easy to screw up if a guy doesn’t know a trigger from a tire iron, but that doesn’t strike me as meeting the “skilled shooter” criteria the OP pointed out.
That's actually kind of the point with military qualifications. They aren't to make you skilled they are to prove that you are proficient. Add into that the fact the military teaches everyone from rabid anti-gunners who have never touched a gun before to kids who were basically born with a gun in their hand and can shoot the sack off a gnat at a 1,000 yards plus and you quickly see that the military's effective max range range is far from absolute but basically a minimum standard.
I can verify that many of the people in my particular unit made 500+ hits on bad guys overseas shooting M855 out of M4's with Eotech sights and that several of us who were DM's made hits at 800+ shooting M262 out of MK12's with Leopold 3.5x10 scopes so it is certainly possible, though not necessarily easy, to actually make hits on actual humans from field expedient conditions at more than 500 yards using 5.56.
Now ,with both of those statements in mind, it is easy to conclude that a skilled marksman can easily exceed that minimum standard.
I don't expect someone that barely qualifies as a Marksman to hit a 500 meter (or farther) target with any degree of accuracy.
1) It’s sensible that the worst shooters would struggle to hit the 500yrd targets, but can they pass the qualification without hitting at all at 500? In other words, is success at the shorter range enough to get to Marksman qual without any points from the 500yrd line?
2) What actually happens when a shooter fails to qualify as Marksman?
Iron-sights would be my only weakness in this scenario. My eyes suck for shooting irons,
Two questions spurred from this - both of which I assume two things 1) Google fu can answer, but 2) you fellas likely know off of the top of your heads and can answer more quickly and directly:
1) It’s sensible that the worst shooters would struggle to hit the 500yrd targets, but can they pass the qualification without hitting at all at 500? In other words, is success at the shorter range enough to get to Marksman qual without any points from the 500yrd line?
2) What actually happens when a shooter fails to qualify as Marksman?
And as an NCO/trainer, I had to work with soldiers that did not qualify. Some of them were lucky to hit 23 or 24 out of 40 targets. If they could not qualify, it was up to the company commander and higher on what to do with the individual. If I was told to keep working with the solder, then I did until they qualified or the chain of command decided enough was enough. Most of the time I could get them to qualify as marksman.
I also served time as being a remedial trainer. My typical score was 39 and I had gone through SDM and gunfighter schools, giving a lot more trigger time than a typical soldier. I would tell particularly poor students what a CO can do if they don't qualify: bar to reenlist, separation etc. The very last student I coached before separating was my company commander. He was scoring 11 out of 40 at the rifle range. I remember standing next to a few NCO trainers contemplating what would happen to an infantry CO that couldn't qualify.
I was always jealous of your DMs getting actual acopes. The SDMR we had in the Army probably shot as well as the Mk12 (didnt look as cool though) but we got issued ACOGs. While the ACOG is a great bombproof optic, it really hamstrung the capabilities of the rifle/ammo.
Two questions spurred from this - both of which I assume two things 1) Google fu can answer, but 2) you fellas likely know off of the top of your heads and can answer more quickly and directly:
1) It’s sensible that the worst shooters would struggle to hit the 500yrd targets, but can they pass the qualification without hitting at all at 500? In other words, is success at the shorter range enough to get to Marksman qual without any points from the 500yrd line?
2) What actually happens when a shooter fails to qualify as Marksman?
Most Marines have very little trouble at the 500. This is due to the fact that they are firing from the prone position, which is the most stable.
Where most of them drop points is at the 200. Some from the kneeling and most from the standing.
The rapid fire is 10 round, two magazines, with 30 seconds to fire. The dog target is used. At the 200 it’s fired from the sitting position and the prone at 300. You start from a standing position and move to your shooting position on the command to fire. If you don’t get a good shooting position, you can drop some points.
There’s a lot of things I was able to do when I was younger. I can still do most of them, but some not just as good. Getting older has its advantages and disadvantages.^^^ This was my experience, qualified expert. All in the black at 500 yds, but that was back in the 80’s.
At 62 years old, eyes aren’t what they used to be. Farsighted so need some correction, have settled on a compromise. If I use lenses that give a crisp front sight picture then I can’t see the target, so I accept a slightly fuzzy front sight and I can still see the targets. Works great out to 300 yds. Beyond that luck plays a big part! Even managed to hit 1 out of 3 at 400 yds with my Mosin.
I remember standing next to a few NCO trainers contemplating what would happen to an infantry CO that couldn't qualify.
My question is how did he became a CO?
Qualifying marksman ain’t that hard.