Revolver or Auto, one pick only.

1. S&W 686+ 4 inch
2. S&W 642
3. Ruger Single Six 22lr/magnum

1. Luger P08
2. Colt Woodsman
3. Vintage Browning Hi Power

I am admittedly a fish out of water with a revolver, so I picked auto because that's what I know and not because of capacity, caliber, or any other edginess.

1. G17 MOS
2. G43X MOS
3. Colt Mustang XSP

1. S&W m&P10mm "woods/defense"
2. CZ P10c "range/defense"
3. 1911 "classic"

1. Rock Island 10 mm with 18 round capacity and a long slide 1911 internals
2. Kimber stainless limited II in 45 ACP 1911
3. Ruger Mark II stainless semi-auto 22 lr slab side

Colt Series 70 1911 in .45 ACP
SIG P-226 in 9mm
Ruger Mk III in .22 LR

DW744
Python
K22

I have to go with revolver. (Handguns I own)
1) S&W 69 4.25" 44mag - hunting/woods carry
2) S&W 442 38+p - ccw/defense
3) S&W 686+ 357 - target/home defense

If a plinking 22lr needs to be in the mix then I need to change to semiautomatics.
1) Springfield Arms XDM compact 45acp - woods carry
2) Ruger LCPII 380 - ccw/defense
3) S&W Victory 22lr - plinking

I need to add a 22lr revolver to my collection. A 617 or Single six would be nice. Maybe a Ruger Wrangler as a less expensive option.

Revolver

S&W Model 15 .38 4-inch
S&W Model 15 .38 4-inch
S&W Model 15 .38 2-inch
S&W Model 14 .38.6-inch (Yeah, I'm a cheat.)

Glock 17
Glock 19
Glock 43x

Boring, boring and boring

S&W Model 15-2 38spl 4", Ruger GP100 5" 357 Magnum & Ruger 3 screw Single Six 22lr.

I live a reasonably quiet life on the farm so my love of revolvers wins over my collection of ugly Glocks. You guys are masochists.

My 629-6 5"
686-no dash 4"
66-3 2.5"

S&W 29
S&W 66
S&W 17
I'm all stretched out into the unknown. I dont have the 29 or the 17 yet,... but like some other things.....I was pretty sure I would like it before I ever tried it.

This is basically a what three guns you own you couldn't live without question and it's tough, but I had to weigh my three favorites for revolvers and autos and I asked myself could I live without the autos and the answer was yes and the revolvers no, so for me

1. Redhawk .45 Colt/ACP
2. Charter Arms Bulldog .357 4 inch
3. NAA MiniMaster

This reminds me I need to get that Charter sent back for repair.

1. K22
2. Ruger LCR
3. Old Model Super Blachkawk in 44 magnum

A mid-sized frame 38 or 357 is obviously missing.

Glock 34.5 - carry it or 2nd on list
Glock 22.5 - my other primary carry (I also have a 35.4 that has a 357 Sig barrel, but sticking with three)
Kahr PM9 - pocket gun to go along with the Glock on belt. (I like the Sig 365 better but it is not compatible with all pockets whereas the PM9 is)

Revolver:

As long as I have one in .22lr, 357mag and .44mag I am happy.

Colt "D" frame 38 Special.
Colt "E" frame 38 Special
S&W "K" frame 38 Special

Auto
1. Springfield Armory Ronin Commander .45 cal
2. S&W Shield Plus 9mm
3. Beretta M9- .22

I would not want to be with my S&W revolvers but if I could only keep 3 of a single type, they’d be semi-autos because I wouldn’t go without a Browning International Medalist. It’s the handgun that I enjoy shooting more than any other.

Browning International Medalist
CZ 75 SP-01
CZ 97B

(New) Colt King Cobra 3" - Carry
(1970s) Ruger Super Blackhawk 8" - Hunting
(1971) S&W 27. 5" - Beauty

Revolvers win. More versatility and greater maximum power potential and better accuracy (just me) And they are prettier to boot.

Semi Autos take a close second.
If I were to go their route I'd go.
Glock 19- Carry, etc, etc.
Mid century Colt commercial 1911- Beauty
Glock 40MOS- hunting and blowing $#/÷ up

3" Colt Python
4" Korth Mongoose
5" S&W 460 XVR

SCCY
Bersa
Hi-Point

Actually, I'd choose...

Ruger Mark IV Tactical with suppressor
CZ Czechmate
Wilson Combat Supergrade Commander Special

Revolvers:

Colt New Service in .45 Colt
Colt M357
Colt Officers Model Target in .22 LR

Automatics:

Colt Woodsman
Colt Gold Cup National Match
Colt .25 Auto (I needed something for 3rd place)