AR, no question
I just watched a report on the AR15 on the Mclerr news hour :banghead: (or whatever his name is on PBS) they did their best to make the rifle look like junk.
I was laughing the whole time. There had no stats, interviewed only one soldier who had used it, and a minor figure who worked on the original AR10 with Stoner. This is typical of those who attack the rifle, they bring up 40 year old data and don't want to look at how things have changed.
The fact is, the Army's own data shows that 89% of users have never experienced a weapons failure, thats as good a rate as any rifle today, especially considering what they are put through in Iraq and Afganistan.
IMHO, the AR15 is one of the best combat rifles in the world, I have a CMMG AR15 M4 with an Eotech 557.x4fts and I wouldn't trade it for any tactical rifle in the world. What the critics miss is this, the AR15 is alot like the Chevy 350, they are the most upgradeble rifle in the world, there are an almost an unlimited amount of options available for it.
If you want more knockdown power, you can upgrade it to a .308 or 6.8mm SPC, if you want longer range, add a 24" bull barrel and some 79gr rounds and knock stuff over at 600 yrds+. You want a piston weapon so it performs like the AK, no problem buy one with a piston kit off the shelf from Ruger or H&K, or, upgrade your existing rifle with kits from AA or CMMG. Want an advanced tactical weapon? Add any number of optics like Eotech, Aimpoint, or ACOG and you have any combat option available, want accessories, add a quad rail front grip and put literally ANYTHING you want on the front of your rifle. In addition to all that, even in the 16" barreled M4 version I have, its accuracy is far superior to most other combat platforms, most notable the AK which is notoriously in accurate, and it’s light weight and easy to lug around all day if you have to.
What it comes down to is, some people just look for things to complain about. Yes, the AR does have its issues, but so does EVERY combat weapon on the planet. The Pentagon is now toying with the idea of upgrading to the 6.8 SPC upper (84% more ballistic energy at the muzzle) and a piston driven system (cleaner longer running rifle), with those upgrades, the AR15 would be, hands down, the best combat weapon in the world
Just my .02!
For the record, I have both an AR and an AK, if the SHTF or I have an home invasion, it’s the AR coming out, no question about it.