Does anyone have any experience with mag springs that have weakened to where there gun would not feed. I keep hearing about not leaving mags filled, or not loading and unloading mags, but I have never had a problem. How about you guys.
Rembrandt
My son has had numerous problems with Beretta 9mm magazine springs on his military side arm....issued ones are junk. Sent him new high performance ones from Brownells. You'd think our service men and women deserve better.
Usually the first symptom of a weak mag spring is the slide lock stops working on the last shot.weakened to where there gun would not feed.
Stop listening to those peopleI keep hearing about not leaving mags filled,
If the springs were made from high quality spring steel and correctly tempered you won't have any problems. The issues you are hearing about are almost always due to manufacturers that are using junk springs that are poorly made. With a quality spring leaving it compressed (within its working limits) will not cause it to lose tension. Another problem is double stack hi cap mags which unfortunately will place the spring in an overcompressed state to get the last couple of rounds in. These springs will fail if left fully loaded because they're being forced to perform beyond the limits of the spring. If you download them by two rounds most will last as long as a good single stack spring made from quality steel. I would always rather have a reliable mag with less rounds than one with a few more rounds that will have a short service life. Any time you have to use a loading tool and a lot of effort to insert the last few rounds then your spring is almost certainly being compressed beyond reason.
...It is almost incredible how many years people survived with those crummy 6 round revolvers and 7 round 1911s.
No, actually this is more about marketing than progress. But I see where you're coming from.
Another problem is double stack hi cap mags which unfortunately will place the spring in an overcompressed state to get the last couple of rounds in.
These springs will fail if left fully loaded because they're being forced to perform beyond the limits of the spring.
...You've got that about 75% correct. The damage is done at the time of over compression, not by leaving the mag loaded. The damage gets progressively worse with each over compression event, but leaving it over compressed should do no more damage that pushing it that far in the first place...