MUSICALGUNNUT45
Member
- Joined
- Feb 22, 2011
- Messages
- 115
Are there any disadvantages to shooting a 38 out of a 357. Does the small length of freebore effect velocity or acuracy at all.
Yeah I heard of that one too. Personally I don't know why people worry about it. clean your gun and it won't be a problemThe only one I've ever heard is that you get carbon rings around the front of the cylinder that need to be cleaned, or else after a while the .357s won't fit.
+1 on this.I'd say that 99.99% of shooters don't shoot well enough to be able to tell the difference in the accuracy between a .38 and a .357.
I'd say that 99.99% of shooters don't shoot well enough to be able to tell the difference in the accuracy between a .38 and a .357...
Velocity, insignificant. Accuracy depends more on the individual gun, even two consecutively produced identical guns. But the difference is small and will likely only be found by shooting the gun from a rest - either hand held or mechanical - at 25 yards or more. It is of no consequence in a gunfight at the typical ranges at which these take place.Does the small length of freebore effect velocity or acuracy at all.
Most folks assume the problem with .38 Spl carbon rings in a .357 is going to only cause problems loading the longer rounds.needed a crowbar to get the .357 casings out of the chambers, forget about using the ejector rod.
rcmodel has this exactly right. this is the problem i am having with my model 28 i bought recently. i bought it in a dimly lit gunshop and didnt bring a light with me. got it home and gave it a quick clean and off to the range. .38s shot great but .357s shot ok but would not eject at all. i had to push the emptys out with a screwdriver.stopped the .357s at that point. looked at the chambers closely and realized there was 50 years of carbon in there from someone only shooting .38s in it. scrubbed it when i got home and shot it yesterday. 4 chambers eject well, 2 still dont. looks like i have to pull the cylinder and soak it now.Most folks assume the problem with .38 Spl carbon rings in a .357 is going to only cause problems loading the longer rounds.
But thats the least of your worries.
The real problem is, the carbon rings are taking up real estate in the chamber right where the Magnum case needs to be able to expand to full chamber diameter to release the bullet from the case.
If it can't release the bullet cleanly when it fires, pressure can increase well above accepted limits.
And that will make for very hard extraction of the fired cases.
rc