If they're American made, marketed, and sold...then I'd say yeah. Sold in the US is the name of the game, even if the lower is machined in Turkeydurkeystan and the upper in Massachusetts. American sales is the point.So are you counting ARs from companies that dont machine lowers?
But if aero machines 1000 lowers for palmetto they tell the BAFT they manufactured 1000 firearms. Palmetto then uses those lowers to build 1000 rifles and sells them. Palmetto also reports the rifle sales to BAFT. So how many rifles have been produced?If they're American made, marketed, and sold...then I'd say yeah. Sold in the US is the name of the game, even if the lower is machined in Turkeydurkeystan and the upper in Massachusetts. American sales is the point.
You've also never heard of Turkeydurkeystan.But if aero machines 1000 lowers for palmetto they tell the BAFT they manufactured 1000 firearms. Palmetto then uses those lowers to build 1000 rifles and sells them. Palmetto also reports the rifle sales to BAFT. So how many rifles have been produced?
Also I have never heard of a lower manufactured outside of the united states. It might be illegal.
If all ARs, of all makes and calibers, count together as a singular sales number, wouldn't that be true of bolt action rifles? There's a lot of those sold too.
But if aero machines 1000 lowers for palmetto they tell the BAFT they manufactured 1000 firearms. Palmetto then uses those lowers to build 1000 rifles and sells them. Palmetto also reports the rifle sales to BAFT. So how many rifles have been produced?
Also I have never heard of a lower manufactured outside of the united states. It might be illegal.
So, then you're saying only 556 direct impingement AR15s are what counts? ARs just happen to be A semi rifle. Bolt rifle is a bolt rifle. That encompasses alot, whereas AR15s that are only DI and 556 is just the tip of the iceberg. We aren't comparing gas piston ARs vs controlled round feed here. If its platform vs platform, then I'd say bolt action rifles are competition.No, just like all semi auto rifles don't count as ARs
I don't know why this is so difficult to understand.
So, then you're saying only 556 direct impingement AR15s are what counts? ARs just happen to be A semi rifle. Bolt rifle is a bolt rifle. That encompasses alot, whereas AR15s that are only DI and 556 is just the tip of the iceberg. We aren't comparing gas piston ARs vs controlled round feed here. If its platform vs platform, then I'd say bolt action rifles are competition.
I understand just fine. Be fair to the other rifles. If all gas operating systems, calibers, and manufacturers count for the AR15, then bolt rifles of different caliber, feed system, and manufacturer count too. In which case, I'd like to see THAT sales comparison.
It seemed that the ONLY person who tried to come up with real numbers beyond internet "i said so" was including sales figures from companies who do not produce lowers and therefore do not produce AR 15s. The fact that no person has been able to point to any real source for numbers speaks volumes. The OP did not even try to show how it had the highest sales volume. He made an unfounded statement. I know it makes you feel warm and fuzzy to have the most popular rifle and that makes you feel the need to defend it. All I ask for is REAL numbers or this is just another internet lie.Did I miss where somebody was counting manufacture and sales separately and then adding them together??
It seemed that the ONLY person who tried to come up with real numbers beyond internet "i said so" was including sales figures from companies who do not produce lowers and therefore do not produce AR 15s. The fact that no person has been able to point to any real source for numbers speaks volumes. The OP did not even try to show how it had the highest sales volume. He made an unfounded statement. I know it makes you feel warm and fuzzy to have the most popular rifle and that makes you feel the need to defend it. All I ask for is REAL numbers or this is just another internet lie.
The AR-15 platform has been the top selling centerfire rifle in the United States for years
That was my same point with bolt actions. Not all semi autos are ARs, but a bolt action is just that. I think numbers to put with the statement may be helpful evidence for ARs being number one.Now that I have no problem believing. But lumping all AR's together it only seemed fair to lump all rimfire semi-autos together too and I seriously doubt the AR sells more than the semi-auto rimfires. It's sort of an odd way of grouping things either way though. There may be some way of wording the question without just outright excluding rimfires so that the AR's come out on top.
Doubtful that direct impingement ar15s chambered in 556 have outsold bolt rifles of every flavor. Once again, if sales counts include ARs of every chambering and gas operating system, then all feeding systems and chamberings for bolt actions would have to as well for numbers not to be fudged.In that case it's most likely semi auto > bolt. "AR15" wins again
Well, lumping all AR's together is like lumping all Mosin-Nagants together, not all bolt-actions. Lumping all centerfire bolt-action rifles together would be like lumping all gas-operated centerfire semiautos together (mini-14/30, M1 Garand, M1A, Remington 7400, AR-15, BAR, SKS, AK, FNAR, SCAR, Sig 556, AR-180, etc.) rather than just the AR.M700 is a bolt rifle.
XBolt is a bolt rifle.
American is a bolt.
M77 is a bolt.
So on, and so forth. There really isn't a "type" of bolt rifle setting it apart from another. Since straight pull actions aren't made anymore to my knowledge, bolt actions are nominally a singular group based on design. There's several different operating system encompassed when you say "semi auto", which then you'd be right: I'm sure there's more semis sold annually. I'm simply saying, what are the numbers of ARs (gas piston, DI, blowback) of all calibers vs. bolt action rifles?
The reason so many manufacturers make AR's and not, say, Remington M700's, is that the AR design is in the public domain
It just seems it would have made for a better response if the OP had just said AR's are popular and very good rifles and then asked people why that's true. Personally I've seen a lot of them that weren't reliable as some suggest btw.