jason41987
member
- Joined
- Apr 10, 2012
- Messages
- 1,293
out of curiosity i was wondering if its possible for someone to convert a cap and ball, either an 1851, 1860, or remington 1858 to 357 magnum?.. i dont mean the removable cartridge conversions you see where you take the cylinder out, but im referring to the conversions ive seen where there is a cutout machines to the side of the frame and a loading gate installed, then a cylinder fitted to the frame with a fixed base pin
my question is, would there be enough cylinder length (im sure there is since they convert these to 45lc which has the same COAL), and enough strength in the frame itself to handle a .357 mag?... obviously both a cylinder and a barrel would need to be made...
looking at the .36 caliber cylinder, the ball is .375 diameter, almost identicle to the base diameter of the .357 magnum, it would need only a very slight work to make the chambers large enough, but im not sure if theres enough "meat" between the chambers to do this... so perhaps it would have to be a new cylinder on a .44 caliber frame?... and i do believe theres enough "meat" in the 1858 frame to do this, its atleast as sturdy as an 1873 colt frame and these handle .357 magnum all day... of course, id only consider such a conversion on a replica revolver made of modern metallurgy
so... doable?... and i know someone will just completely miss the point and tell me to buy a new double action revolver, or even an 1873.. but i like the looks of the old conversion revolvers between the civil war and 1870s and it would be nice to have the availability and versatility of .357 magnum ammo to go with it
my question is, would there be enough cylinder length (im sure there is since they convert these to 45lc which has the same COAL), and enough strength in the frame itself to handle a .357 mag?... obviously both a cylinder and a barrel would need to be made...
looking at the .36 caliber cylinder, the ball is .375 diameter, almost identicle to the base diameter of the .357 magnum, it would need only a very slight work to make the chambers large enough, but im not sure if theres enough "meat" between the chambers to do this... so perhaps it would have to be a new cylinder on a .44 caliber frame?... and i do believe theres enough "meat" in the 1858 frame to do this, its atleast as sturdy as an 1873 colt frame and these handle .357 magnum all day... of course, id only consider such a conversion on a replica revolver made of modern metallurgy
so... doable?... and i know someone will just completely miss the point and tell me to buy a new double action revolver, or even an 1873.. but i like the looks of the old conversion revolvers between the civil war and 1870s and it would be nice to have the availability and versatility of .357 magnum ammo to go with it