What has less recoil than my 17C

Status
Not open for further replies.
J

JBrady555

Member
Joined
Nov 23, 2011
Messages
742
Location
Panama City, FL
Hello all I'm in the market for a new 9mm, in the last few days I've had many posts about CZ, EAA, and RIA. I want my next 9mm to be a accurate gun who's main purpose will be range plinking/competition. I have a serious wrist problem so recoil is a factor even in 9mm. I have narrowed my choices down to a CZ-75, EAA Elite Match Witness, or a Rock Island Tactical 9mm 1911. As you can see they are all heavier steel framed guns as I'm guessing this will give me the lowest recoil. I have not shot none of the three and probably won't before I buy.

Right now my lowest recoiling gun is a Glock 17C which even at 22oz or so is pretty soft shooting since its a compensated 9mm. My question is will one or all of the steel framed 9mm's listed above have lower felt recoil than the 17C that I already own? If they aren't I might look at a glock 34, I could always buy a compensated barrel to get the recoil down. Would this produce lower recoil than the heavy steel guns? I also want my next gun to be a 9mm that can rival the accuracy of the 1911 .45s that I see at the local club, which gun would fit that bill the best? Of course I know it all depends on the shooter but I want to give myself the best chance possible when having "closest to the bullseye" competitions with the 1911 guys. Thanks for any info, the more of these posts I put out, the closer I get to making a final decision.
 
Look around for the heaviest STEEL-framed gun you can find. That'll help with recoil as much or better than a comped-polymer-framed gun (like the 17C.) And you could always find a comped version of those guns, over time.

I doubt you'll notice much difference in recoil in the 34 with a comped barrel and the 17C -- as they've tried to keep the 34 and 17 similar in weight and balance, and the 34 is only .8 of an ounce heavier than the 17.

A Beretta with a comped barrel might be available, since they have an open slide on top.

The heaviest CZs might be an option -- they have heavier models than the base 75B. Look at CZ-USA site for the weight of their various guns. The pricey Tactical Sport is the next step up, and it weighs 2.8 lbs empty; the slightly less-expensive 75B-based Shadow Target is 2.4 lbs, empty. (The Glocks weigh around 1.6 lbs, empty, by comparison.)

You are NOT really limited to 9mm. You can also look at the CZ-97, which is a bigger gun, or the similar Witness Match guns. Find one with the features you like. Look at the Cajun Gun Works website for a great 97B tricked out for bullseye-type shooting.

You have options.
 
Well the Rock Island weighs in at around 39ozs and I just don't think I can pass up the price tag. Plus I can learn to tinker with the 1911 myself possibly opening up a whole new hobby within a hobby.
 
What is your budget? I've found that at a competition level you really have to pay for accuracy.
 
56hawk said:
What is your budget? I've found that at a competition level you really have to pay for accuracy.
Click to expand...
Cheap as possible. I won't/can't spend more that about 650.00 tops and that included transfer fees and all. Really makes the Rock Island Tactical a sweet deal at about 430.00. I could always build it up as I see fit.
 
You might be able to snag an STI Spartan for about that price. The Spartan is made from Rock Island frame and slide (Armscor), but STI internals and fitting. The result is supposedly one of the most accurate 1911s you can get for anywhere near the price.
 
I recently got a CZ75B and love the recoil on it. I'll have to upload the video I got of me practicing drawing and shooting and it shows what little recoil it has.
 
You could also likely find a Colt 1991a1 Commander for Under $650. $500 to $550 is a consistent range for them. They are the models made from 1991 to 2000, first in a dull matte blue then Parkerized. Also known as the "ORM" 1991 since the current models have the same model number "Old Roll Mark" meaning the big "1991A1" on the slide.
 
I sold a 17C to buy a 75b and have never regretted it. Much better ergos, accuracy, and slightly better recoil in my opinion. For you, I'd suggest getting the CZ SP01 which is slightly heavier.
 
IF you shoot a steel-framed pistol with a higher bore axis than your G17c, you'll probably be pleasantly surprised at how your Glock has been handling that recoil!
 
As said above about heavier guns have less percieved recoil.
An additional plus is to have a little more weight "FORWARD". The CZ SPO1 all models have the tac-rail that brings more weight forward. They are well known to competitors for accuracy AND fast follow-up shots due to to the lighter rmuzzle flip. They also have a lower bore axis due to the upswept beavertail.

I shoot the 75B, and my son shoots the SPO1 Shadow. His noticeably has less flip than mine with the same reloads.
 
My Glock 21 seems to handle recoil a lot better than my 70 Series GC. I guess perceived recoil really is subjective, though.
 
From personal experience, I would get a 9mm 1911, like the STI Spartan, I shoot in USPSA matches and don't handload. I have tried the Wilson Combat shock buffers, the do have some effect on felt recoil, but the STI Recoil Master guide rod system is a big help.
 
I'm post #17 and the first guy to mention a S&W 5906?

Ok, so it's an all steel frame. Big plus for recoil absorption. Double sack mag means a wide enough grip that the recoil is disbursed nice and evenly.
All in all, excellent guns, can be found in the $300-350 range used, and will offer ultra-reliable performance in addition to costing much less and having little recoil. that's my recommendation.
 
You might also look into a Glock 17L

Mine is very soft shooting.

attachment.php
 
The Beretta PX4. Some people don't like the looks but Glock is almost universally acknowledged as lacking in the looks department. It feels really good in hand. The Beretta is very soft shooting and smooth. I think for a 9mm range gun it is hard to beat.
 
Hi,

IMHO, if you have a serious wrist problem you probably don't need to be shooting competitions. Casual plinking vs. the amount of shooting and practicing of a competitive shooter are incredibly different! See a competent orthopedic surgeon for a full check out with x-rays and professional opinion.

I simply don't think you want the wrists of an 80 year-old arthritic man, and all the continual pain this might cause, while you are still a young man. IF the good doctor clears you to compete, then enjoy . . . but protect your body! People are living a lot longer today and you'll want to enjoy your life without crippling pain I imagine!

Food for thought.
 
Walt:
I agree with your other comments about the CZs, but am not so sure about any link between bore axis and beavertail design...
Click to expand...

If you agree a proper grip is tight against the beavertail, then check out the beavertail shape on the 75B and compare it to the upswept SPO1. I shoot both.
CZ also brags on this in the gun's description.

It's not a dramatically higher grip, but it is a little higher. The closer to the bore axis the grip is, the less leverage the gun has on the wrist and arm.

I should note that the CZ 75B "STAINLESS" model also has the upswept beavertail. The other models of the B do not.

I personally prefer the 75B because of the added weight up front on the SPO1 models. I have less trouble transitioning from one target to another --and stopping on it--with the lighter front end of the B model. But that's just me. My son can run over me using the Shadow in USPSA. :)

The CZ Tac Sport model is SA in 9mm and 40cal and is available as the "Czechmate" and comes comped with a C-Mor red dot and high cap mags for Action shooting competitions, and can be used as a minor OR major power factor gun.. It's pricey, but ready to run. Wish I had the $$$$.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

R
  • Locked
Recoil of 380 vs 9mm
2 3 4
Replies
85
Views
20K
avgeekjlb
A
M
  • Locked
Glock 17C
Replies
1
Views
410
R&J
R
S
  • Locked
recoil of P220 and Springfield Loaded
Replies
6
Views
606
Darthbauer
D
S
  • Locked
What's the lowest-recoil 9mm pistol?
2 3 4 5
Replies
115
Views
19K
Orion8472
Orion8472
S
  • Locked
Glock 9mm recoil...vs...BHP
Replies
11
Views
955
SX1guy
S
Back
Top