Telling wife how many guns you actually own

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Oct 27, 2008
Messages
32
Location
Somewhere, over the rainbow...
Hi there, Highroaders!

It's been awhile, but I recently had an issue with the wife I imagine a few of you here have dealt with, and I'd like to know what came about. What follows is the backstory to why I'm asking this question; if you'd like to just read the question *SKIP TO THE END*!!!!

I got married about a year ago to my college sweetheart, and due to my being in the military, my wife and I currently reside in a foreign country that prohibits gun ownership. As much as it stinks to not get to really shoot for a few years (no, qualification once in a blue moon doesn't count!), we're in a country my wife loves so I've got some encouragement. However, a man's got his passions, so early in my arrival I got in contact with a gun dealer I've done a little business with in the past and he is holding any guns I order on Gunbroker until I get out of the service (O what a glorious day that will be!!!) and return CONUS.

Without saying the exact number, let's just say I'm in my mid twenties and I own more than a couple a guns, which my wife knows. However, because we were together in college for over a year and my guns were stored at home, she doesn't know the EXACT number that I own. I originally thought that due to a lack of inquiry on her part, she was good with only knowing as much as she knew (silence is consent!). I told her about my deal with the FFL, and that I was going to pick up a few new toys from time to time while we're here. She then gets into her wanting me to tell her whenever I get a new gun, and that's where the issue starts. Here's why:

1. In the past, she's seen me buy guns and not said a word. Not one. Hell, she's even been on the range with me when I've bought a new gun, and then shot it with me in addition to the 3 or 4 I already brought with me.

2. We have separate finances, and had no issues with it as a couple. Mind you, with her looking for and finally starting a new job after 7 months of unemployment, with me being the primary breadwinner I've assumed all family costs. I bought our first car, pay for the insurance, buy all the food, put clothes on our backs, pay her college debt, and give her money for literally anything she needs without a single complaint. I do this because it's the right thing to do, and it's not something I wave in her face as a guilt trip because I want to see her succeed and be happy.

3. Because we have separate finances, we've always had the "buy what you want as long as we take care of mutual expenses" mantra, and it works. It also goes both ways. She could literally come home in a brand new Lamborghini, and as long as she paid cash for it and didn't put a burden on us, my only question would be, "can you take me for a ride in it?"

All that being said, I asked her why she wants to know when I buy a new gun but not any other inanimate object, and she said, "because I didn't grow up with guns, and they make me uncomfortable." With me coming from a philosophy background in college,her statement was not sustaining critical inquiry from the husband half of the equation. I pushed the point that guns are inanimate objects just like a lot of the other things I bring home that she doesn't ask to know about, so again, why have you relegated them to special status?

Her response: "They're dangerous, and they make me uncomfortable."

Me, with her implicit assumption about the inherent nature of wholly inanimate objects aside: "statistically speaking, and according to Center for Disease Control statistics, the cars we own are more dangerous than guns. The alcohol we consume on a regular basis helps to end more lives a year than both guns and cars combined. The occasional cigar you've seen me smoke will assist in killing more people then all of the above. All that being said, is it really fair that you've attached such special significance to guns, something you've long known I have a passion for?

Her, now in tears:"You're placing guns before me. You make me feel like I can't trust you because you don't want to tell me when you buy a gun. If it makes me feel comfortable, why does it matter?"

At this point, we've reached an impasse, so we agreed to disagree for a few months. Yes, I kept buying guns that she didn't know about during this time. When it finally comes up again in another argument, I tell her that one of the reasons I do not think me telling her is necessary, besides all the ones I've already mentioned, is because I do not see how the exact number of guns that I own has any actual bearing on how dangerous it is within our home. If she believes that 3 guns are dangerous, and she knows I already have that many, then does our home get exponentially more dangerous if that number becomes 30, or 300? No. Second, if the "they're dangerous" reasoning is rejected, the only plausible reason she'd need to know how many guns I have is CONTROL. However, we've already agreed that as long as our mutual expenses are paid for, our money is our money and she has no logical basis to influence how many guns I buy. Of course, me bringing all this up only leads to more tears and her admittance that her view is based on feeling, but that she can't be comfortable in our home unless she knows.

So, like most married guys, I had to accept that her feelings and comfortability matter more to me than sustainable logic, so I've apologized and agreed to tell her the number. However, besides telling her that I disagree with her reasoning, she needed to understand the absolute trust that she'll be the first girlfriend or wife (to include my own mother) I've ever met who knows the true expense of her boyfriend's/husband's hobbies and doesn't make it a control issue. Whether or not this holds true remains to to be experience(proof is in the whiskey!).

THE QUESTION: If you're spouse wanted to know whenever you bought a new gun for the reasons my wife stated, even if you've agreed to have separate checking accounts as long as mutual expenses are paid for, you make sure all needs are provided for, and you give to the other person liberally, would you also provide this information?
 
She said:
"because I didn't grow up with guns, and they make me uncomfortable."
and
"They're dangerous, and they make me uncomfortable."
Then the kicker
You're placing guns before me. You make me feel like I can't trust you because you don't want to tell me when you buy a gun. If it makes me feel comfortable, why does it matter?"
Game over, she has drawn the line in the sand. Your next move defines what the rest of your life will look like on many levels. Sometimes the juice ain't worth the squeeze. Good luck
 
Make her comfortable. Take her shooting as much as she will go. A relationship with even the slightest bit of secrecy will implode eventually.
 
Your wife has been influenced to believing that guns are inherently dangerous, and because of that has a skewed perception of them. I don't believe that it is entirely unfounded for her to want to know an exact number. If I were to share a house with someone who was a collector I think I too would want some assurances. Such as security of such objects and safety of the user. As your wife, I believe you must bring her into your world. This means total honesty, let the chips fall where they may. Your relationship to your wife cannot prosper in the shroud of secrecy. You should be able to express your excitement to her when you score a new rifle, and she should be able to express pleasure in seeing you enjoy your passion. She has been shown one side of firearms, let her see the other. Show her the shooting sports world so she can see that there is a much larger world of sport than flipping it sideways Gangsta style. Reassure her with the security aspect of having things locked up so that she may have piece of mind. Lastly, find her one to call her own ,"of her choosing", and remember that you share her world too.

You cannot simultaneously share a life with someone, while living separate lives.
 
Make her comfortable. Take her shooting as much as she will go. A relationship with even the slightest bit of secrecy will implode eventually.

I think this is a great suggestion. As someone who didn't grow up around guns, I had a certain fear of them until I shot one a couple times.
 
It is always risky to ask for, give, or TAKE marital advice from strangers, especially those who are passionate about something, and especially over the 'net.

But, hey, it's free, right? ;)

My take on it is indeed a little like the "line in the sand" comment. What you do right now sets how your life will be from now on. If this is going to be a PROBLEM let it be one NOW, face it, deal with it, and move past it one way or the other. It only gets worse and harder later and comes with more collateral damage.

What would I do, and what have I done? Something like this:

"Sweetheart, this is part of what I do and part of me being me. I have no desire to keep anything from you and will tell you anything you have a desire to know about me. I'm not going to stop doing what I do or being me the way I am, so only ask me about my interests if you actually care about them and want to enjoy my enthusiasm for them. Don't ask so that you can have a lever over me to try to change me or stop me from doing what I love to do. It won't happen and will only cause both of us a lot of pain and sadness.

I am never going to put "things" over you in my heart, and part of why I love you is that I don't believe you would put "things" over me in your heart either. Decide today if this issue is important enough to you to wedge us apart. Tell me that now. If it is -- if you cannot be happy with me being me this way -- I need to know that. Otherwise, this needs to be the last time you ask me to give up something I'm passionate about. A good spouse encourages his or her partner in their pursuits of happiness. I promise to do that for you, I want you to promise to do that for me.
"


Then follows the "pregnant silence" where you will know -- pretty instantly -- how it is going to be.

Unfortunately, while what you discover in that next moment might be very good, it also might be very bad. If her reply is a squirm, a dodge, or a refutation of your points, then you know something very sad and dark about your relationship, and you'll need to think very hard about what you should do about that. Decades are spent in many couples' lives in great pain over the kinds of grasping, controlling, fear and bitterness that now threatens yours. You two either need to completely excise this tumor now or you will feel the pain of it constantly for your whole married lives.
 
First, I never like the 'guns are just inanimate objects.' That is way too narrow of an argument and one that will not resinate with someone who is anti. They understand it cannot shoot itself. They are not stupid.

Second, guns are worth money. You can die. She needs to know what they are worth in case you die. Thats why my wife knows. I have a list with costs and values that I update a couple of times a year. I also have an FFL guy that is one of my best friends in the world. I have a couple marked that I want to keep in the family. The rest she can dispose of as she pleases. But she has to know what they are worth.
 
If she didn't grow up with them then she just doesn't know.
Do tell her anytime you buy one, that's just common marriage sense.
The biggest key factor in my mind is,
EDUCATION IS PARAMOUNT!!!!!!!
Teach the woman you vowed to love.
Then it can be a combined lifestyle.
And not one that's secluded to the shadows.

My 2 cents
 
I'm also wondering why this didn't come out before the marriage. Did you attend pre marital counseling? Was she afraid that it would be an issue? I've learned quickly that most mistakes married men make, occur at the beginning of the marriage. then we are reminded of them every day after that ... :)
 
the foundation of marriage is trust and communication. Both are needed in this case.
Word.

The debate isn't over things, per se, and I suggest strongly that you don't let it go there because that cheapens the discussion. The debate is more likely, at its core, about your sense of values (with guns as representative of those values) and her sense of values (with communications and compromise being representative of those values). If you each can find a way to truly and honestly respect each others values, this too shall pass. If you can't both find a way to respect each others' values, then y'all need to figure out where to go from there.
 
One more thought to throw in here;
Is the hobby taking too much time away from her? While she may be presenting it to be about the guns, this very well could have more to do with the time spent on hobbies and away from her. I have dealt with this personally. In similar occurrences, a divide would be drawn between me and my wife over my hobbies. The reality of it wasn't what the hobby was, even though it was portrayed that way, but the amount of time spent on them away from the family.
 
She was shooting with you and watched you buying guns, so she CANT have been "anti" oder even "uncomfortable with guns" in the past.

Since she in "uncomfortable" NOW the question is:

What changed her mind? Ask her.
 
a long time ago when the first safe was about at overflow I made the mistake of showing a couple girls I thought were gonna be around long term the inner sanctim reloading room and safe... they both were not so against them at first bit I did get the "why so many" "do you really need so many" to which my response was "they were here long before you and will be here long after you are gone" - that has been a constant and consistent part of me and likely a big reason I am single...

just like the new audi commercial of the doberhuahua talks- compromise is seldom right!

Personally I would be scared as hell if I were you right now... its ending before your eyes...
 
Sam1911

And many other have given you some excellent advise. Hindsight is 20/20, this should have been determined before marriage, of course, but it is what it is.
Deal with it and get the confrontation out of the way ASAP. No doubt the more she shoots the more comfortable she will be but in your present situation that is out of the question. I do believe Sam has put you on the right track until range time is available.
 
When my wife and I first married, I was just beginning my career in Management for a non-profit. Non-profit can equate to not the best pay. I was also previously married and paying about $1000 a month to support my 2 wonderful children.

My new bride was wanting the new house and everything included. She had every right to want that. Every woman dreams of that whenthey get married. We were living in a duplex and fighting the VA for my compensation.

Anywhoo, while saving for a down payment on a future house, I went out and bought a M91/30 for.......$80!!!! Heck yeah! Who can pass that deal up. Of course, we didn't talk about it and it got ugly.

My actions sent her a message and it scared her. We didn't have much money. We had talked about our mutual goal of buying a house. She was making sacrifices, but i wasn't.

Actions do speak louder than words. My actions told her that I had no interest in her happiness if it interferes with my hobby.

I have learned alot these past few years and my marriage is stronger than ever. We talk about EVERytHING

Moral of the story, actions speak louder than words. Peal back the onion, get to another layer and see what she is truly telling you and look at what you are telling her with your actions. Often, it's the unsaid that really matters the most.

by the way, she knows every gun I have, and I have a binder listing them, their value, and which ones to sell off if I pass and whcih to keep in the family. the binder also contains info on how to use the generator, the Kerosene heater, and where the valuables are stashed.
 
Last edited:
If finances are not the issue, I'd just buy them from private parties, put a safe in a storage spot, maybe have a friend rent it for me, so there's no record of it to be found. Wives are dangerous, actually. I'd never recommend that she know everything. Some sort of cache, $, income-source should be completely secret, under a Nevada corporation, etc. Half of all marriages end in divorce, many are very acrimonious/apathetic. I would never tempt a woman by letting her see that she could really "score" in some way by treachery. I couldn't sleep at night, knowing that disaster loomed. Bad enough that she can get what she knows about, in my book. I trust her with the "half" that she knows about, and that's it, man. She can already get half of my ss and if/when I get a VA disability, she gets 1/2 of that, too. That's if I'm DEAD. :) I have set things up for her very nicely as it is. She has no complaint coming (which is not the same thing as not hearing any). :)
 
THE QUESTION: If you're spouse wanted to know whenever you bought a new gun for the reasons my wife stated, even if you've agreed to have separate checking accounts as long as mutual expenses are paid for, you make sure all needs are provided for, and you give to the other person liberally, would you also provide this information?

Yes, and I proudly have - most of the time. Over twenty ago when I met my wife I realized that if I hide anything, I'll spend the rest of my life hiding and I couldn't imagine living like that. She had no previous first-hand experience of firearms and when she first time saw my gun room was a kodak moment. Her jaw dropped. Her only concerns so far have been better (child proof) safes back in 90's and asking me with a firm tone of voice to take machine guns to basement when her friends come over.

Had she ever started pressuring me, we would've had a long conversation. You can't change people; people can change when they themselves want to, but habits and beliefs are the second strongest urge of all human beings and attempts at changing them without extreme, solid proof or other factors that motivate the person to alter his/her belief system are doomed to fail.

You're most definitely not putting guns before her. You're putting guns before her unfounded beliefs, associations and - to be honest - media-induced misohoplia and it's entirely up to her to let go of her beliefs and think rationally.
 
I live in Alabama. I am an Alabama football fan.

Now if you're not from around here you will say "so what?".

We have another college in this state called Auburn. There is no more intense hatred in the sports world than this rivalry. People get killed just about every year over this one football game. This past year one Alabama fan shot another Alabama fan because "she wasn't upset enough over the loss". Both were women.

With that said there are plenty of "mixed marriages" that work out and last forever. Maybe they don't talk from September through December but they stay married.

You and your wife can work out any situation as long as both parties are willing to accept that disagreement is a part of ANY relationship. I don't see that your love of guns should be insurmountable for her nor should her apparent dislike be impossible for you to live with.

I got divorced after 7 years of marriage right after college. Irreconcilable differences and all that. I was then fortunate to meet and marry a girl that accepted me for exactly who I am. I like guns so she got interested, slowly, in the hobby. I hunt so she became a hunter. The last anniversary present I got her before she passed was a S&W revolver that she picked out. Anytime she asked me why I needed a new gun I asked her about her shoes. I mean how many pair of shoes does one woman NEED.

In those years we had arguments about almost everything conceivable just like any relationship. One partner should not have to give up something they enjoy even if the other does not participate. Other than infidelity, drug/alcohol abuse, or something that drains too much time and money from the FAMILY I think that any issue can be worked out between two willing partners.

Bad news. I think she may be trying to tell you something. It sounds like she loves the country you are in and you can't wait to get back to the USA. Uh-Oh.
 
Our whole lives everyone will be forced to do things and deal with thing we don't like or want to do.This is just another thing for your wife to deal with.Being its gun specific shows you have an anti-gun person in your house.If it were buying too many pairs of Air Jordan sneakers ,I feel it wouldn' be an issue.Be careful ,this could be an explosive issue.:(
 
There are several different veins here that may run together.

In her mind, you are keeping a secret. She knows your passion for firearms but also has no idea how many you have. She may feel that the action of keeping the number a secret can carry over into other areas of what else you are keeping from her. It becomes a trust issue.

She may also be looking at having kids. How safe will they be with "so many" guns "laying around". I'm not saying there will be any in sight or not secured but she doesn't know this because you don't have them right now. She may have a skewed vision of guns laying in every drawer or cabinet and feels any kids you may have will be in danger. She's convicting you for something you haven't done nor may ever do (be careless with storage). Right now you have no guns. She likes that.

It's also about control. She may feel she has none in your relationship. She wants to know the exact count because there may come a day when she'll ask "do you really need another gun? You already have 20 or 30 or 80, etc. Put that $500 or $800 into little Johnny's college fund. You may have an agreement in place now, about finances, but women look ahead to when you have kids and they want some control that goes with it. She may see you guys struggling to buy diapers but you always have money for another gun. She may think that your gun buying may be a sign of out-of-control behavior and her and the kids will suffer due to this "illness". To her, guns can be on the same level as being an alcoholic, drug abuser, hoarder or gambler. She may know someone who ruined their family due to an obsession like just mentioned and fears that may happen to you guys. She may want you to join gunaholics if you have way too many guns and she wants to know the number so she can figure out if there is a problem now or in the future.

There are many reasons why someone reacts in a way that differs from the previous norm. The only real answer is to find an entire evening to sit down with the express purpose of discussing this issue. Make no threats. Make no demands. Use the time to listen to what is being said (on both sides). Don't get snitty or nasty. Communicate. Once all the cards are on the table you have to analyze what was just discussed and then ask yourself if you can live under these feelings and emotions. Make an intelligent decision on your future before bringing kids into the equation.

Once kids come, everything changes. I think you are seeing what she sees when you have kids. Women do that more than men. The kids become more important than any hobby you may have, no matter how long you've had it. If you come to terms, great. If you can't then be prepared to move on.
 
My first thought: this is all going to get harder once kids are part of the equation.

It's hard to give advice without knowing either one of you. There are nuances that complicate these issues that will never be communicated to the folks trying to answer your question, but hopefully a few of the responses will be helpful.

The direct answer to your question is "yes, if she wants to know about purchases, even if made with 'your' money, then she has the right to know about them." There's "your" money and "her" money, but she may not see it that way. If she's been unemployed and actively looking for a job for more than half a year then she may feel like your resources are something you both need to be able to depend on, and that you're squandering financial security on a hobby. If so, discussion should bring this out. If she's not actively looking for a job and she's depending on her MRS degree to pay the bills, then this is definitely part of the problem. Especially if you are talking about kids and she plans on staying at home with them - you're spending the (future) kids' money on firearms that you can't even use right now.

If she's worried about firearms and safety, then that's an issue of education. Take her to a place like Gunsite where you both will be armed all day, during all activities, and safety will be practiced at all times even when training on the range. A car is dangerous too, but it's made significantly less so if the operator is properly trained and is acting in a safe manner.

If she is opposed to civilian firearm ownership and being a gun owner is a symbol that represents something at the core of your being, then it will be much easier to deal with this now then after a couple of kids are around and mom's in full-on "protect the children" mode.

It's also possible that she's immature. I've dated girls who thought they should be the most important thing in my life, and that if work requirements conflicted with a planned date that work should suffer. It's possible it's something similar here - your time and money should be spent on her, and this is a long-standing hobby that you should be giving up now that you're in a committed, loving relationship. Like comic books or internet porn.

I don't know what it is, and I don't know the answer. I can say that the issue is probably a lot more complex that it appears now, and it's possible she doesn't even know the root cause of her emotions. Is it fear, resentment, uncertainty, or can she identify the emotion?

This will take some work, but this is absolutely something that should be talked through until a clear understanding is reached. You both need to understand each other's position, and you need to have a clear idea of what you're willing to give up (gun ownership, control over spouse's gun ownership) in order to keep the relationship. It's possible the relationship isn't workable, and there are some core issues here that will prevent you both from being happy in the long run. If so, correct it.

Marriage is something that should be a net win for both partners. Nobody should be asked to give up something they care deeply about. Figure out what the issues are, and either address them directly, or decide whether the relationship is worth trying to save. If she's afraid of firearms then work to minimize her fear (preferably through education and experience rather than disarmament). If financial security is at the root of this then address that - for a while my investment in firearms was fixed, and buying something new meant selling something to pay for it. If the issue is one of control, then I've got bad news for you...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top