Hello all.
It seems to me that whilst there are some good but more budget focused lever actions out there, most seem to be replicas that use top eject:
Chiappa
Rossi
Mossberg etc
Even Winchester 92 and 94s that are built today are top eject.
It seems that only Marlin and Henry are still making side ejecting lever actions.
Given the ever increasing popularity of scopes. Would you not think it would pay these other manufacturers to make side ejecting lever actions?
Any thoughts on why?
Because angle/side eject on a lever action is an unholy abomination, and putting a scope on a lever action is a violation of the laws of nature. If John Moses Browning wanted us to have scopes on our lever guns, he would have designed a bolt action.
Now go do 12 hail mary's, 10 our father's, and flog yourself 10 times for this sacrilegious heresy, and never have these Satanic thoughts again.
=)
Okay now that the fun is over...
About the only reason for side eject is, as you surmise, the use of a scope. Problem is, putting a scope on a lever gun pretty much eliminates all of the best qualities for which people admire lever guns. A stock Winchester (because that is the ONLY lever gun) is a rugged, dependable, naturally pointing, quick to shoulder-aim-fire, fast follow up shot, type of gun. It is easily carried in a scabbard, slung on the back, tied to a canoe (my preference), hung on a 4 wheeler or snow machine, behind the seat of the truck, etc etc etc.
The moment you put a scope on a lever gun, ALL of that is taken away. Then it becomes this slow to aim and fire, delicate, thing that you have to keep in a padded case until you're ready to shoot.
Now I took a hog last year with a friends 30-30 Marlin with a scope. It worked well. Even at 25 yards, the scope let me be certain for that behind the ear shot hogs require, which would have been more challenging without the scope. I missed the second hog, one the run, clean because of a lack of target acquisition.
Once you put a scope on a lever gun, it becomes a single shot affair. Given the inherent diminished accuracy of the flat nose bullets required in a lever gun, compared to pointy bullets in a bolt gun, there is no reason to give up that accuracy unless you get all the benefits that come with a lever action.