Most Knowledge required to collect.

Status
Not open for further replies.

tark

Member
Joined
Nov 25, 2013
Messages
5,164
Location
atkinson, ill
What would be your nomination for the collectible firearm that requires the most knowledge to collect? Knowledge to keep you from falling into a pit of quicksand, to help you in spotting fakes, to give you the ability to tell a good deal from a bad one.

For the sake of this thread, we will not mandate a single model. The manufacturer is the criteria. For instance, all Winchester Lever actions would be considered one category. All colt revolvers, another. You get the idea. How expensive a gun might be to collect has no bearing on the discussion; how much knowledge that is required, IS. There are many to consider:

Colt six shooters, for one. Model P SAA. Good old hoglegs. And all those percussion six shooters...Ahhhhhh!

Lugers. What can you say? You had better know your stuff....

Winchester Lever Actions....wow. Where to begin?

M-1 Garands can be a real snake pit and carbines an even bigger one. Restoring a period correct all matching and correct parts carbine can be a real pain.

Those are just four, and I know you will each have your own choice....so convince us all that your choice is the most difficult...
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Old top break revolvers!!!

Everything you mentioned has multiple volumes of written materials to reference.

Turn of the century top breaks were made by who knows how many different companies in dozens of variations, with limited reference materials available.
 
I'll play. Classic black powder rifles (1740-1865). Many modern custom makers, reproductions, and custom makers from the actual time. You really would have to know your stuff and even then carry a printout of period makers and their marks. Even then...good luck.
 
Wartime German Mausers are tough. Need to know your stuff due to high Level of fakery for desirable guns.
 
I would say classic black powder revolvers, primarily those used in the Civil War.
 
IlikeSA is right. Black powder rifles are very hard to study since it seems every county had a smith. There is a shortage of documentation and they were subject to modification/modernization by subsequent smiths.
 
I'm jumping on the black powder bandwagon. Followed by anything used during wartime, just because of the insane amount of reproductions out there.
 
Another vote for antique BP arms. Flintlock, wheellock, matchlock, etc.

They have scattered original documentation at best, many different makers each with a slightly different way to make things and many parts that were individually hand made. Combine that with many replicas made over the years and the comparative ease of making a replica/fake (as compared to a Luger or Winchester), small numbers of true originals and high values.
 
Firearms produced in the U.S. in the 1700's-mid 1800's. Good luck on identifying, and placing an accurate market value on those boomsticks and pistols.
 
Lugers P-xx several armories and konzerns

and the animals were built commercially on top of that. Ihave seen a couple of presentation grade P-08's that were literally worth a king's ransom.

woerm
 
I would have to say single shot black powder U.S. martial and semi-martial pistols.

Not very much information on them at all, it's an obscure section of collecting but one were numerous old guns apply. An arcane and challenging subject to be sure.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top