You would think so, but I have such on mine and it still rattles and causes damage. In addition, sometimes the loop of rawhide fouls the action.A short loop of rawhide or cord will stop the noise and damage
I have never known a cowpony that I would like to be sitting on while taking a shot at something.
I've got 3, shot center fires and rimfires from them all for as long as I can remember, down a coyote, rope calves, drag to the fire, haul a deer home, I DON'T subject them to my 300wm, all the colts I train do not get proofed unless for a hunting client, but I'll say this, I'd rather have the gun half slung the first time I fire than try to fight the boot if the .22 spooks em, usually it's an autoloader that clacks more than pops, but the worst one still jumped about 2' to the side the first time, now that they're all getting semi retired it's about time to start proofing another......but I assure you, a pony that can stand next to the branding pot without flinching when it's lit is quite capable of being trained to shoot, and most of mine make half decent bloodhounds too!If you are a working cowboy, the lanyard through the the saddle ring could be used to tie the carbine to the D-Ring of your rear (roping) girth of the saddle. Since you typically do not need instantaneous access to the rifle, it kept it out of the way and securely stored until you had to use it as a working tool for snakes, varmints, food, or to put down an injured or sick animal. I have never known a cowpony that I would like to be sitting on while taking a shot at something.
1957 Interview of a cowboy in the 1880's
Hi All,
not that this ends the debate about the saddle carbines but I did find the insight interesting. Folks that enjoy cowboy research might find it enjoyable.
http://www.nps.gov/parkhistory/online_books/thro1/rickey.pdf
The Rifles and Carbines section starts on page 46 of the pdf. It only briefly mentions the way in which they were carried on the saddle.
it describes in a scabbard, usually on the left side to avoid getting in the way of the rope. The article says that the carrying of a rifle was not all that common.
Actually these were not Winchesters. They were excellent 92' copies called El Tigre .44-40. They sold for $33 bucks in the 1960s. They sell for $800 now. I should have kept mine.I remember reading somewhere that the 92 Winchester was used in large numbers by South and Central American military. I suppose that may have been reason for the SR to have shown up on rifles not typical to our own Cavalry.