Having a hard time deciding which Used .357 to buy... opinions please.

Status
Not open for further replies.

Analogkid

Member
Joined
Jan 16, 2011
Messages
497
I am wanting a decent older 6" 357. Unfortunately funds are limited to about $500 total. I have a few friends that have some that fit the bill and are available in my price range. I am currently looking at these 4. I am looking for something mainly to plink with but will handle full house rounds from time to time and more so than the New production budget 357's I see currently.

1. A early Dan Wesson 6" with the exposed barrel nut. Its super Mint in both looks and action.

2. A NIB Older Ruger Security Six in Stainless. 6" I'd wager to bet it has never been fired save from the factory.

3. Used but nice looking Dan Wesson model 15 vent rib. This is a touch more than I want to spend but the guy is a good friend and will hold onto it for me.

4. Used Taurus Tracker in 357. Yeah I know. But I like the looks and used ones are in this price range. I worry about the longevity of this one though since there are some horror stories about. I assume they have made tons of them and they are cheaper and that's why you hear more bad about them. The two I am looking at are well used but in decent shape. Fit and finish is better than the taurus norm at least on the two I am looking at.

I have also seen some used Black model gp-100's for sale locally but they really don't do much for me even though I know they are really strong revolvers.

I know some of you guys may have all three or have had one or the other and I would like the input. I know the Dan Wesson's can be challenging to find spare parts for and I know Ruger isn't supporting the Security Six with parts either. So this is in my mind as well. Are any of these good choices?
 
Last edited:
The Dan Wesson with the rib. The exposed barrel nut Dan Wesson is probably an ok choice, but it's more of a collector piece. The model 15 is back in production, and parts of all kinds are readily available. It's going to be a better shooting gun in general than the other choices you have listed.
 
Security Six or The Dan Wesson with the rib. Either one is a good deal in that price range.
 
The one that feels best in your hand, points the most naturally for you, and has the best sights & trigger.
 
Last edited:
Analogkid

1) Used Ruger Security Six.
2) Used Dan Wesson Model 15.

If neither of these two guns work out okay for you maybe consider saving up some more money and look for a used S&W Model 28.
 
I'll chime in for the Dan Wesson with the exposed nut- the pork chop barrel is awesome:) Sure, there's a kind of "made it in my shop" look, but the one I had was awesome.
 
In a 6" magnum for the range I highly recommend the older M586. It's a great revolver that shoots well and looks great too. It's a very solid revolver so you can shoot any ammo you want.

Edit: If you prefer Stainless the M686 is identical but for the blue. I own a 4" M686.
 
GP100. Incredibly strong. Is what replaced the Six, which so many have fond memories of. The GP is stronger, though.
 
The Dan Wesson revolvers will probably have the nicest trigger...and best accuracy. Also the coolest looking (if that matters) :cool:
 
Definitely the Security six, had one back around '73 and sold it to a co-worker who passed away, tried to get a hold of his widow, but to no avail to buy it back.
 
I bought a 6" Security Six in the late 90's for $175. Sold it a few years later for $225 because I wanted a 4" .357. I am still kicking myself.
 
beag_nut

GP100. Incredibly strong. Is what replaced the Six, which so many have fond memories of. The GP is stronger, though.

That's what I thought too when the GP100 came out. I was very happy with every Security, Service, and Speed Six I owned and still kick myself for trading them away (typically for one of those new-fangled semi-autos). So I thought: "Great, this new GP100 should be a stronger, improved version of the Security Six." though truth be told I was more than happy with the Security Six just the way it was.

But the GP100 weighed in at 41 oz. (competing with the 42 oz. S&W Model 686), but not possessing the balance and handling characteristics that made the 34 oz. Six so popular. It was bigger and heavier, had a grip design that I never felt comfortable with, and had a heavy and gritty trigger in both double and single action mode.

So while I do have fond memories of the Six Series I can't say the same thing for the GP100.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top