Mixed Parts 1861/1851 Quiestion

Status
Not open for further replies.

BrandonB

Member
Joined
Sep 20, 2017
Messages
6
Hey All, first post! I'm seeking info on my original 1861 Colt. The strange thing is, it has the barrel and loading lever assembly of a 1861, but the frame and the rest are numbered to a 1851! Could this be a factory thrown together "Franken-Colt"? I know they did a lot of weird things with spare parts to get guns out to the soldiers during the war, and maybe this is one of them? The 141xxx SN comes back as a 1851 made in 1863.vThanks for your input! Brandon
 
Is the serial number on the bottom of the barrel different from those on the frame, trigger guard and the grip butt?
 
Yes, the barrel has the same SN. As soon as I figure out what site to use for image hosting and how to post them, I will!
 
Pics Attempt
 

Attachments

  • wm_11084900.jpg
    wm_11084900.jpg
    48.8 KB · Views: 41
  • wm_11084901.jpg
    wm_11084901.jpg
    83.1 KB · Views: 38
  • wm_11084903.jpg
    wm_11084903.jpg
    37.2 KB · Views: 36
  • wm_11084904.jpg
    wm_11084904.jpg
    71.6 KB · Views: 35
  • wm_11084905.jpg
    wm_11084905.jpg
    88.5 KB · Views: 39
I found nothing in my limited library on Colt percussion revolvers.

Has this revolver been in your possession or your family's possession long? It could be a field repair or any number of things.
 
The 141xxx SN comes back as a 1851 made in 1863
From the pictures that looks like a legit 1861. I would question the source that says the serial number is a 1851. Mistakes were often made in the records. You have the uncontrovertible physical evidence.
 
Recent purchase. Thinking of breaking down and getting a Factory archive letter, but I would have to submit the number and model as a 1851, because they will just tell me that the serial # doesn't exist for 1861 Navy revolvers.
 
Everything Ive seen says that 1861 Navy SN were between 1-38000. This is in the 141000 range and all matching so I'm really scratching my head here!
 
I have a total of 38,843 1861 Navy revolvers were produced between 1861 to 1873. On the 1861 frames should be mark on its left side COLTS/PATENT in 2 lines which is not present on your revolver.

An archive letter will clear things up for you.
 
Last edited:
So is it still considered a "collector" piece, or is the value greatly reduced with this odd mix of parts?
 
There's no COLTS/PATENT marking on that frame. There isn't even a remnant of that marking on your frame. But all of the cylinder engraving is gone also so that may not be a big deal.

A factory archive letter is the first place I would start.
 
Collecting or Collector's value is a whole another world way beyond any information in this forum.

You do have a nice looking Colt. You probably already know this but do NOT CLEAN your gun or refinish the grips. The value of many old guns has been lost when well-meaning owners remove the original finish (called patina) thinking it helps to make the gun look newer. Just give your gun a light coat of gun oil.
 
It would be interesting to see if Colt records contained information about the barrel being replaced on this gun (as an 1851) with the newer 1861 style and it being numbered accordingly.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top