I Passed up the opportunity to shoot a nice bull elk yesterday morning at my house.

Status
Not open for further replies.

MCMXI

Member
Joined
Jul 1, 2008
Messages
9,233
Location
NW
Yesterday morning at 3:30am my gf and I were wakened by the sound of two of our four dogs barking. The Great Pyrenees has amazing hearing and it turns out that a small herd of elk (15 or so) were in the yard. There was a calf, a bunch of cows and three bulls. One of the bulls was a nice specimen, not a B&C but still a good looking bull (see bottom photo at lower left). When I woke up at 6:45am they were still bedded down anywhere from 50 yards to 100 yards from the house with some in the open and some among the trees. I live on 20 acres at 3,200 feet elevation that borders private forestry land that climbs to around 6,500 feet. We've seen elk up there while hiking on trails and had some cows and bulls in the yard in the past but never a herd with three bulls so it was exciting to say the least.

Just before 7:00am I got dressed, grabbed my new Muck boots (we have 12" to 18" of snow on the ground), put on an old work jacket that I wear when working in the yard (damn noisy brass snaps that clack against rifle stocks), picked up my .375 H&H rifle, put three rounds in my pocket and figured I'd take a look outside. I opened the door to put my boots on and as I was pulling on the first boot I looked up to see a nice bull looking in my direction. He would have been about half way up the hill just to the left of the garage in the bottom photo. He didn't seem to be bothered and just stood there looking towards me for 30 seconds or so and then towards the rest of the herd that was moving off up the hill. I slowly knelt down, turned the power ring down to 3X, quietly opened the bolt, put a round in the chamber, depressed the center of the extractor to help ease the claw over the case rim, slowly closed the bolt and raised the rifle .... I had him dead to rights. He was 70 yards away at most and standing still with a near perfect broadside shot and my main thought was that he deserved better than having me put him down after he'd spent the night in my yard watching over his herd. I was wearing one boot and one house slipper and it didn't feel right to me. As the herd walked up the hill (to the right in the photos) and over the ridge at the top of my property I followed them up, shuffled on my knees for 10 yards or so below the crest and then crawled a few more yards so that I could watch them. By this time the nice bull (I think) was 175 yards away at the treeline and offering another easy broadside shot but I let him go. I have mixed feelings about yesterday morning. I would have liked the meat, but in hindsight, if I was going to shoot anything I should have shot one of the lesser bulls since I'm not really a horn hunter. However, given that the herd stayed around the house for at least 3-1/2 hours and seemed to show a lot of trust it didn't feel right to kill one of them.

I learned a few things yesterday about myself and my equipment. First off, don't belly crawl in 12" to 18" of snow with binoculars around your neck without the lens caps in place. When I raised the binos all I saw was snow! After removing the snow from the objective lenses and eye pieces I soon realized that they were next to useless with water smeared all over the lenses. I learned that once you're "inside" a herd of elk they can act like cattle. My gf took her Doberman out to use the bathroom at 5:00am and the elk didn't seem to care. I also learned that I'm totally unprepared for these spur of the moment hunting situations. My rifle wasn't ready to go, my hunting gear wasn't ready to go, I didn't have any gloves, I didn't have tape on the muzzle of the rifle and the rifle wasn't loaded as I stepped outside. Another thing I learned is that while my 3-9x40mm Zeiss Conquest scope with the RZ600 reticle is great for shooting animals, it really sucks at identifying horns in low light, and when a low contrast animal is at a treeline with darkness behind it I really needed the binos. I only have a bull elk tag for the region I'm in so shooting a cow would have potentially been a bad idea.

This was my morning yesterday. You can see one of the bulls in the bottom photo. My gf took that photo with her cell phone at 3:40am so I can't be sure that he's the nice one of the three bulls but I think he is. Maybe they'll be back, maybe this weekend I'll put on my snowshoes and try to find the herd ... we'll see.

elk_2.jpg

elk_3.jpg
 
Cool story. If all was legal I'd have taken the shot. But then again I've never taken an elk and it is on the top of my bucket list.
 
jmr40, I got home about 20 minutes ago and my gf told me that at least 20 more walked up through the property at about 6:00pm heading up to the mountains behind us. She was out with the dogs and my 12 year old Rottweiler ran up to the top of the hill to get a better look. There were at least 3 calves this time so my pup was risking life and limb getting so close. :)
 
I honestly think you made the right call. Shooting from the house just isn’t what I would have in mind for an elk. And I’ve never killed one either. But it’s on my list. Maybe a couple round (or square) bales of alfalfa could be brought in and then you can watch them all you want. Let the yard be a safe haven for them. They seem to feel it’s that way anyways.
 
MCMXI I gotta admire your decision not to shoot from inside the house. Your gut instinct is solid, you just elevated yourself to a real hunter who hunts and respects what he hunts. There is no sport shooting deer in your yard or fishing in a barrel. Great story, thanks for sharing.
 
You said hunting elk was mainly for the meat. I figure you were just not ready to butcher and haul a bull elk. ;)

I have a tractor so dragging the elk all of 50 yards to the garage and hanging him up wouldn't have been much trouble at all. Butchering an elk is always a big job, no question about that, but that wasn't the reason I passed on this one.

@BigBore44 & @ms6852, thanks for confirming what I thought was the case. Hunting elk is a great experience but this wouldn't have been hunting. There are tracks all over the property this morning from the 15 or 20 that passed through last night. There were two nice whitetail bucks heading up the hill this morning. They're probably all feeling pressured to move up the mountain to safe areas. With 18" of snow on the ground up there it would make for a very tough hunt so there's little chance of them having to deal with any hunters. My gf and I hiked 8 miles up there and back scouting for deer and elk just two weeks ago. This is how it looked then about half way up the mountain. It took us close to 4 hours to hike up and down 2,700 feet or so and I can only imagine how long it would take humping through deep snow with 80lb of meat in a pack and the thought of having to make three or four more trips.

blacktail_trail.jpg
 
MCMXI, I appreciate your sharing of your story. I lived in Great Falls, MT for three and 1/2 years when I was stationed there in the Air Force. To this day my wife and I regret our decision to move from Montana. We made some great friends there that we are still in touch with. A great state and great people!
 
My nephew lives on a cattle Ranch near anaconda Mt.
Your story sounds like some of his.

He had to take his kids to the end of their lane to meet the school bus because of a cow/calf moose living nearby.
 
A great state and great people!

@Milt1, true and true. I spend quite a bit of time with friends who live in Belt, MT which is close to Great Falls. We hunt on land owned by farmers who have been there for many, many generations. I've found MT folks to be among the most helpful that I've ever encountered. I managed to drive off a road last year into a very large snow-filled ditch and had to turn away numerous offers of help as I waited for another stranger who had turned around to get a couple of straps from their place a few miles up the road.

@Armored farmer, I've yet to see a moose up here but I know they're somewhat common a few miles North, East and West of Whitefish and particularly out towards Eureka.
 
You only have to explain it to yourself (and the family, if you're going hungry).

Last Sunday I watched 4 does walk out into the field about 30 yards away, and would have taken the biggest if not for it being a buck only day. I got into the stand late as a last chance that day.

Couple minutes later a buck comes out after em, real suspicious of my stand, and tries to do his thing with em. I could tell his rack was wide, but couldn't see the tines (open sights). Thought about him for a while then decided to take him... I'm in it for the meat anyways.

As I was quartering him up later I felt a little bad for the guy. Nothing I did led to harvesting him. He was just doing what nature intended.
 
Great story, today I was out at a friends place, we saw about 60 Elk on the way to his house and lots of deer both mulie and whitetails. We can home without firing a shot. I agree with your choice not to shoot one in your yard. I too live in Montana, born and raised here. I still find more enjoyment in the hunt than the work of butchering. The scenery of where we can hunt is what I treasure as well as hunting with a good friend. So I say keep hunting and when you need to, harvest what you need. Tomorrow I am headed out again and this time I will be taking my good luck charms, both my daughters will be going with me. Life is good when you get to hunt with your kids. Just my thoughts from The Big Sky Country, Montana.
 
I can only dream of living in a place like that, and harvesting an elk is on my bucket list too. But I also feel it wrong to shoot an elk or deer in the yard. I'd consider them guests or visitors, and they deserve to be respected and watched/admired.
 
To many folks, it ain't about the kill, but about the hunt. Some folks can never understand that. Folks that do, are hunters and not just shooters. In modern America, very few of us that can afford to shoot a .375 H&H rifle sporting a "3-9x40mm Zeiss Conquest scope with the RZ600 reticle" is in desperate need of meat, so we hunt for a reason other than survival. While I have no problems shooting a doe while sitting in my bow stand in the woods, I have plenty of opportunities to shoot them and small bucks under the apple tree in the backyard. Totally legal, under a 30 yard shot from the porch and a much easier time gettin' 'em to the shed for skinnin' and butcherin'. Still, just can't get myself to do it. Don't hardly seem right. Get more satisfaction from lettin' 'em go than puttin' one down right there. So I can identify with your decision and applaud you for your choice.
 
My gf and I headed up the mountain before sunrise on Saturday morning and ended up when the day was done hiking 7.2 miles through 12" to 15" of snow (we're still paying for that). We saw elk sign everywhere and spooked three bulls and a cow on our way up to a ridge line to get a good glassing position. I told a coworker about the elk in my yard and he was keen to join us so he came into the area from a higher vantage point and shot a decent bull at around 3:00pm. He came back yesterday with a friend and two mules to recover the meat and I let him into the pasture through a locked gate and it was an easy morning for him. My gf and I plan on going back up there on Friday in the hope of getting one or two of the nicer bulls, but just being out there and seeing elk is something special. I'll bring a spotting scope next time since the 10X binos I have are good, but I'd like more power and a steady rest to spot these ghosts. Here are some photos from Saturday's hunt.

Following the gf up the mountain
1.jpg

Views from a ridge
2.jpg

3.jpg

4.jpg
 
I'd have taken the bull, I don't get the notion that taking one after an 8 mile hike is somehow 'better'. I doubt the settlers or Indians did it the hard way if they didn't have to.
 
They killed to survive. That is not the case in today's world. Two related yet very different reasons for hunting.

A distinction without a difference. A big part of why I hunt is meat for the freezer. Sometimes in hunting an easy close shot happens, are we supposed to pass that up also? A guide once told me he's had clients who did exactly that, don't ask me why, maybe to show off their long-range shooting skills. I really don't get this thinking, perhaps some really aren't comfortable with the hunting/killing process. It's an animal, why pass up a close shot that would have a very low chance of wounding or losing an animal? A lot of people have ranches and hunt on their own property. They all taste the same.

YMMV

On a lighter note, glad to see MT is getting moisture after a horribly dry summer.
 
Hunting elk on public land is tough up here in MT. I know a number of hunters that have spent weeks or even months of their lives out in the back country and haven't even seen an elk let alone shot one. A coworker passed up a bull elk his first year in MT (25 years ago or so) because he thought it wasn't big enough. He went 16 years before he got the chance to shoot another despite hunting hard all of those years. He was the one that got an elk last weekend. For many the idea of an elk hunt is a once in lifetime opportunity, a bucket list item as @jmr40 said. I'm going back out this Friday and Saturday to see if I can get a nice bull but I still don't regret letting those three go last week. Maybe I'll never get another chance, but I sure will enjoy trying just like we did last weekend. When you're sitting in a chair with your feet up, a nice fire going and a good beer in your hand having hunted for close to 12 hours, hiked 7.2 miles, seen some nice bulls, felt that you have a chance, and heard a friend shoot an elk, you really feel that you did something that day.

Sometimes in hunting an easy close shot happens, are we supposed to pass that up also?

@Paul7, that's a straw man argument there. If a bull elk comes within 20 yards of me on Friday after I've put in the work to get to the top of a couple of ridges you bet I'm going to shoot him. I respect these amazing animals and for me that means not shooting them from the deck of my house.
 
Hunting elk on public land is tough up here in MT.

So why pass up an easy shot?

I know a number of hunters that have spent weeks or even months of their lives out in the back country and haven't even seen an elk let alone shot one. A coworker passed up a bull elk his first year in MT (25 years ago or so) because he thought it wasn't big enough. He went 16 years before he got the chance to shoot another despite hunting hard all of those years. He was the one that got an elk last weekend. For many the idea of an elk hunt is a once in lifetime opportunity, a bucket list item as @jmr40 said. I'm going back out this Friday and Saturday to see if I can get a nice bull but I still don't regret letting those three go last week. Maybe I'll never get another chance, but I sure will enjoy trying just like we did last weekend. When you're sitting in a chair with your feet up, a nice fire going and a good beer in your hand having hunted for close to 12 hours, hiked 7.2 miles, seen some nice bulls, felt that you have a chance, and heard a friend shoot an elk, you really feel that you did something that day.

In that scenario, you've had a nice hike, if you like hiking, but a failed hunt. As far as doing something, I have enough of that between work and family responsibilities.

@Paul7, that's a straw man argument there. If a bull elk comes within 20 yards of me on Friday after I've put in the work to get to the top of a couple of ridges you bet I'm going to shoot him. I respect these amazing animals and for me that means not shooting them from the deck of my house.

Is it even legal to hunt at 3:30 am?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top