Can't decide: Remington 870 Police Magnum, Wingmaster, or Mossy 590A1

If you watch closely you'll see the occasional older blued Wingmaster in riot configuration on the market as well. I've noted one or two that were pretty much unused.. Yes, they wanted a premium -but it was still just a bit more than half of that $600 for a new one... Police type shotguns were in the inventory of almost every department a few years back - and many were hardly ever used, issued, or carried. If I'd had a chance to purchase my issued 870 - I'd have jumped at it since it was in perfect condition (particularly compared to the weapons that were issued daily for the street and were all pretty much rack grade poppers -a mix of Mossberg and Remington).

From my point of view the Remington was superior - mainly because of the location of the safety... I had occasion to point a locked and loaded shotgun at many, many live targets on the street, at very close quarters in high stress moments - and I had to be absolutely certain I'd never fire a round accidentally. In every case my trigger finger was on the safety (and I had to clear it before moving to the trigger...). Those that haven't carried a shotgun into hot calls over and over again may not appreciate that - but I did... I was always afraid that with a Mossberg I might inadvertently clear the safety while maneuvering under stress -just the possibility was enough to put me off of them...

I like the 870. There's a blued finished Police 870 at a local pawn shop for right at $300. I would buy it but I already have an 870 Express with walnut stocks and a 20" barrel. and then I also have a like new 870 Police Magnum that is still in the box.
If you like I could get some pics of the 870 at the pawn shop and what he would charge to ship to your FFL.

Another vote for the 870. Wingmaster or Police.
I'm left handed and use my thumb to operate the safety.

You'll like the Wing Master! The actions sound like bank vaults..

drobs said:

Another vote for the 870. Wingmaster or Police.
I'm left handed and use my thumb to operate the safety.

Click to expand...

That's how I work the safety when I shoot left handed, also.

The Corps uses Mossberg.

Venom007 said:

The Corps uses Mossberg.

Click to expand...

Not all of us. My Department issues the 870.

Jason_W said:

I’m going to try again today after work. Then, in 10 days, I can take it home and hit the trap stations at a local range.

I should have enough left over after all the punitive taxes and fees for one of these as a shorter utility barrel

https://www.midwayusa.com/product/9...-gauge-3-20-rem-choke-with-rifle-sights-matte

Click to expand...

If you cal live without the choke here is a cheaper barrel. https://www.midwayusa.com/product/4...xed-improved-cylinder-rifle-sights-parkerized

You won't need a choke for inside and can use the long barrel for trap and so on.

Jason_W said:

The desire for the choke tube barrel is for added hunting versatility, which is why I ultimately went with the Wingmaster over the Mossberg. Throw in an extra full tube and I'm ready to go for turkey. Open choke for home defense or close range slug hunting, and whatever choke works best for longer buckshot patterns.

Click to expand...

That's a good idea.

I have both and love both. My 1972 Wing Master has beautiful wood and very nice blued finish. If I could only have one, it'd be the Wing master. hdbiker

I'll always prefer the tang safety to the crossbolt.