Cimmaron, Uberti, Tiffany, etc are all the same from what I can find.
Howdy, that is incorrect.
Cimarron is an importer. They do not manufacture anything. The same with Talylors and a few others.
Uberti is a manufacturer, in
Gardone V.T., a suburb of
Brescia, Italy. They have been in the replica firearms business since about 1959. They got into it at the approach of the 100th anniversary of the beginning of the Civil War. These days Uberti is owned by Beretta, one of the oldest manufacturing companies in the world.
Pietta is another Italian replica arms maker.
Can't tell you anything about Tiffany, that's a new one on me. However, back in the late 1800s New York based Tiffany and Company, the jewelry store, bought some Smith and Wesson revolvers and embellished them with silver, gold, and jewels. These revolvers were not meant to be fired, they were only for display. Here is an example. As the legend says, this one is in the collection of the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York City.
Back to the main subject. Last year, Uberti changed the design of the hammers on their replica revolvers. Although the mechanism is still basically the same as a Colt, no transfer bars or anything, they changed the design of the hammer. Although the firing pin is still located in the hammer, it retracts so normally it will not contact the primer of a cartridge. When the trigger is pulled, a small actuator pushes the firing pin forward so that when the hammer falls the firing pin will strike the primer and fire the cartridge. This was done because traditionally it is unsafe to keep a live round under the hammer of a conventional Colt style revolver. With a revolver using the traditional Colt style mechanism, it is only safe to carry it loaded with five rounds, and an empty chamber under the hammer. If the gun happens to be dropped onto the hammer spur, with a live round under the hammer, there is a very good chance it will fire. Which incidentally is why Ruger uses a transfer bar to transfer the energy of the hammer blow to the frame mounted firing pin. If you load a modern Ruger up with six, you can pound on the hammer spur all day and nothing will happen other than damage the hammer.
Uberti is in the process of changing over all their replica Colt revolvers to this system, however a few of the older style revolvers, with the firing pin fixed in the hammer, are still available. I had a chance to fire one of the new ones a couple of months ago. I did not have any problem with it, but the lady who was shooting it had such a smooth, controlled trigger pull that the gun did not fire every time she pulled the trigger. It fired every time I yanked the trigger. I believe she bought it from Taylors. I believe she sent it back to have it fixed. Have not heard anything further.
Some of the older style hammers with the fixed firing pins are still at the distributors, but they are disappearing fast.
Here is a video that describes the new Uberti retractable firing pin.
Eventually, the older style Uberti revolvers with a fixed firing pin in the hammer will no longer be available, as new stock with the retractable firing pin replaces them.
So far, Pietta is still making their replica revolvers the old way, with a Colt style lockwork and the firing pin is still fixed in the hammer.
I have had a few Uberti clones over the years. This 45 Colt Cattleman, marketed by Cimarron, with its 7 1/2" barrel is the only one I still own. I bought it used about 10 years ago. Nothing wrong with Ubertis, but I have been replacing them with Colts over the years.
This revolver has had some work done to it by a cowboy gunsmith. He smoothed up the action. While he was at it he replaced the original split trigger/bolt spring with a wire spring. The original leaf style springs are the ones that can break fairly often.
Like this broken trigger/bolt spring from a Colt.
The smith also replaced the hammer spring with a lighter aftermarket spring.
Here is the Uberti hammer, fixed firing pin and all. There is a bit of wear to the case colors from being fired lots of times.
Anyway, if you want one of the Ubertis without the retractable firing pin, hop to it.